Who's the Pink 'Un?
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser no. 284. 18 September 1986, Page 11I Jim Did you know that the Financial Times is controlled by Communists? I must confess that this news came as something of a shock to me. But it must be true because Norman Tebbitt said so. Norman, you may remember, also exposed the Church of England as a Marxist front organisation, so he obviously has a nose for these things.
And if sceptics should want proof that the Pink 'Un is now in thrall to Moscow, just take a look through some back issues of Marxism Today and notice how many of its contributors turn out to be F1 journalists. Even that famous wine column was written by the FT's resident beaujolais expert. Of course some cynics might say that this says more about the pinkness of the CPGB than it does about the FT's commitment to the dictatorship of the proletariat.
What I can vouch for, from personal experience, is that the Pink 'Un is essential reading for the trade union activist. A few years ago myself and one or two other malcontents used to produce a fortnightly bulletin that went into BL's Longbridge plant to the annoyance of management and senior stewards alike. People were amazed at the accuracy of our information on company policy, and even speculated that we had a mole in BL management.
The truth was that we lifted most of our "scoops" from the FT, which invariably gave out the lowdown weeks before any information was released either by the company or by union officials. I'm glad to see that our unwitting informant Arthur Smith, the "Midlands Correspondent" , is still at his desk following motor industry developments with a gimlet-eye.
Graham Day, the new Chief Execufive of the Rover Group (nee BL cars), is not a happy man, according to Smith. "New elements in the market, such as Nissan, would increase competitive pressures and make life very difficult. He did not expect any improvement in the overall share held by UK car assemblers. Not-exactly ar earth shattering revelation, I agree: but where else have you ever heard the big boss be anything other than "confident" or "optimistic"?
Down at Dagenham too the bosses are showing signs of panic: on Wednesday the 10th, the FT reported that "Mr Derek Barron, Chairman and Chief Executive of Ford of Britain, yesterday called for close monitoring of the EEC of cars produced by Nissan in the UK.. He was commenting on Monday's announcement, two years ahead of schedule, by Nissan that it will proceed to production of 100,000 cars a year by 1991 in Washington, Tyne and Wear, and perhaps eventually to 200,000.'"
It seems doubtful that Mrs Thatcher will take much notice of this kind of bleating. She has always disliked British motor industry bosses (apart from Michael Edwardes, of course) and suspected them of being in league with the unions against her. Nissan's set up, in Press and Wear, is much more Tyne taste.
The FT reported the opening ceremony in some detail: "Clearly delighted, Mrs Thatcher welcomed the announcement by Mr Yutaka Kume, President of Nissan, that Phase 2 of the Washington project is to go ahead. This will involve expansion of production from 24,000 to 100,000 cars a year ...Mrs Thatcher had to observe Japanese customs by performing the Daruma ceremony. The Daruma - Japan's national good luck symbol — is an egglike head which always returns to the upright position when knocked off balance...Yesterday Mrs Thatcher opened the Daruma's second eye, symbolising that the gods had now been officially invoked to bless Phase 2.* The FT was less enthusiastic: Thursday's editorial noted that it is an ironic coincidence that the announcement by Nissan of Japan that it would accelerate plans to assemble cars in the UK should be followed by General Motors" decision to phase out most truck production by Bedford, its British subsidiary." If that did not pour enough cold water on the Daruma celebrations, then the FT had a further solemn stricture to deliver: "If the principal intention is to evade European import barriers it is likely to result in low value-added 'screw-driver' plants, while subsidies of the scale of the £100 million which the UK has offered Nissan are bound to distort the European market." Distorting the market! We can't have that! And from a Tory government as well!
The point about this little Cook's tour around the FT's coverage of recent motor industry developments is to illustrate the basic value of the Pink "Un: it understands how capitalism works, and it understands only too clearly that a British motor industry has no future. It expresses doubts about the Nissan enterprise because such Anglo-Japanese collaboration could "distort" the Europeanisation of the industry that the FT wants to see -as exemplified by the recent Ford UKFiat truck link-up. It criticises Thatcher from the standpoint of the rational European capitalist. Such objectivity is of value to socialists but we should not mistake it for socialism - that's Norman Tebbit's error.
Of course it is true that many FT journalists are indeed socialists — of a sort. Like Professor Hobsbawm of the CP, John Lloyd (who recently resigned as the Pink 'Un's Labour Editor to take over at the New Statesman) and Philip Bassett (Lloyd's successor as Labour Editor and - surprise, surprise, — now a regular contributor to the New Statesman) have set themselves up as a sort of unofficial industrial relations "think-tank" for Neil Kinnock. They can criticise Thatcherism from a rational - even humane - standpoint. But it is a standpoint that urges collaboration between unions and management, for the smoother running of the present set-up. They can tell the truth about the country's economic shambles and expose Thatcher's pretensions with impunity because the proles don't read the FT. The Pink 'Un remains the internal bulletin of the ruling class: the fact that its Labour and Industry team moonlight for Kinnock is a warning for us, not a cause for celebration!