[Obeying the rule of profit nationalisations in the…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Obeying the rule of profit nationalisations in the financial sector public ownership being the lever fo Forum is important because it should improve left cooperation on immediate practical issues (elections to the NatIonal Executive, conterence resolutions, solidarity with working-class struggles).
It could give the Labour left a visibility it has not had for quite a while, and thus help us to act as a counterweight to both rank and file demoralisation and the Labour leaders' retreat before the Tories' political and ideological offensive.
Campaign Forum will also have to prepare for Labour in government.
One of the left's central weaknesses during the fight for democracy in the early 1980s — as SO argued at the time — was that it never seriously extended the fight to the trade unions or rearmed itself politically. Most of those who recoiled from the last Labour government's record in office failed to think things through to the point of reaching stable conclusions radically different from the ideas of Labour's old left wing, which had been so feeble and so compromised during the '60s and "70s. The coming to party leadership of first Foot and then Kinnock disoriented the left.
Foot and Kinnock had the support of most of the left, and started out with the same basic policies as the mainBack in the early *80s, Labour Party conferences declared angrily that a Labour government would promptly and thoroughly undo the Tories' criminal programme of selling off public assets. And no compensation would be paid when the enterprises were renationalised.
The Tory press howled with horror. The Labour leaders were quieter but no less horrified. They set to work on whittling down the conference policy.
Now, in a National Executive statement to the 1986 conference, they have unveiled the result. The big bang has been successfully reduced to a whimper.
What's left is little more than the renationalisation of British Telecom. Even that will be in two stages.
As a first stage "Labour will make full use of" the 49% government shareholding that already exists. The second stage will come "as soon as distant future").
Even then it won't be very good. All privately-owned shares in BT will be swapped for non-voting shares. Thus - so the argument goes — the prin muddled opportunistic ex-revolutionary-socialist Ted Knight, turned local government into a huge school of reformism and class collaboration. Often they found themselves, the lefts, playing the role of managers against the workers; they developed an open hostility to trade union militancy, The left is only now recovering from the disarray created by those developments - which arose decisively from the left's own lack of preparedness and lack of clear goals.
There is some recognition of the problems now on the left. When Campaign Forum was established, it was generally accepted that it should campaign for positive socialist policies and not just be a 'negative' opposition inside the Party. It was also agreed to include the trade union Left in the Forum framework, and to build Campaign Groups in the different unions.
Class
Much, however, still needs to be discussed and filled out. Socialist Organiser does not believe, for example, that putting forward a programme based on a sum of the demands of different campaigns inside the Labour Party — a left version of the 'Rainbow Coalition' — can add up to either a comciple of government control will be established without conflict with BT shareholders.
The National Executive statement claims that this arrangement will block any "speculative gains" other than those already made by people who bught BT shares at privatisation and sold them off again soon afterwards.
So far as I can see, that's just nót true. Everyone who bought BT shares on privatisation made a speculative gain of about 50p per share, as the price quickly rocketed from 130p to 180p. Some cashed in that gain immediately. Others hung on to it: and those others will still have their gain after Labour's "second stage"
The only difference is that their gain will be in the form of a non-voting share worth 184p (the current prices) or wnatever, instead of a voting share worth the same amount. And the new non-voting shares can be freely bought and sold.
But our leaders are so thrilled by this scheme that they plan to extend it elsewhere. Other nationalised enterprises besides British Telecom will be allowed to sell shares, so long as they are nonvoting shares.
This is highly dangerous. The new shareholders will have considerable Although there were only feeble attempts to organise the left after the winding-up of the RFMC and Tony Benn's deputy leadership campaign, we remained strong enough to mount serious resistance to the various attempts at a damaging witch-hunt in the Party.
The left is not strong enough now to stop Kinnock and Hattersley presenting Labour as a new version of the SDP. The situation could be very different after an election, with the Labour leadership trying to run a decrepit British capitalism in severe crisis. The left will have mechanisms to make that leadership accountable which have not existed in the past -mandatory reselection of MPs, annual conference election of the Leader and Deputy Leader.
Kinnock and his faction understand this only too well. Hence the witchhunt and the recurring moves to gut the democratic reforms. The Labour Party may not yet be safe for a Wilson/Callaghan-type government.
This is the importance of the Labour left trying to reorganise now. Campaign Forum should help the left to unite, to discuss, and to rearm politically — as we failed to do in the early '80s, and still need to do now. control, votes or no votes., Suppose for example that British Telecom under a Labour government goes for big job cuts. The unions resist and are strong enough to push the Labour government into opposing these cuts.
What will happen to these privately-owned shares? At the first sign that Labour might oppose the job cuts, share prices will crash. This will be both a real difficulty for the enterprise, and a powerful argument for the management to maintain the job cuts.
And aside from that, to sell shares to private investors you have to make those shares profitable for them. Nationalised enterprises will be used as sources of income for the moneyed classes!
In its opening passages, the National Executive document tries to present itself as a radical alternative to the sort of nationalisation programme carried out by the 1945 government. "The failure of public ownership...does not lie in being too radical, but in not being radical enough" . There has not been enough workers' control, and not enough public ownership in finance. in fact, the document mentions new It looked as if the left might win one victory against the witch-hunt at this year's Labour Party conference. enthe expulsion of Amir Khan and Kevin Scally from Birmingham Sparkbrook Labour Party has outraged many beyond the hard left. The expulsion was endorsed at Labour's National Executive Committee only by a narrow majority, and Birmingham's right wing city council Labour group has condemned it.
Appeal
So Khan and Scally might have won their appeal to Labour Party conference. But now it seems that the Labour leaders will manoeuvre the issue off the conference agenda.
The reason given is that a conference debate could prejudice the Labour Party's position in the event of legal action. Khan and Scally have threatened to take the Labour Party to court.
This development highlights the short-sightedness of using the capitalist courts in disputes within the labour movement.
It has become common practice for witch-hunted left-wingers - Militant nationalisations in the financial sector only as a vague possibility, and democratic control over the Bank of England not at all. The basic drive is not towards workers' control, but control by market mechanisms.
Already nationalised enterprises are run very much on the basis of profit. The document proposes nothing strong to change that. The new type of shares it proposes will increase the profit orientation of nationalised enterprise.
And "a balanced economy which the private and public sectors support each other" (which is what the document calls for) can only operate on market, profit criteria when the public sector is much weaker than the private one. It will be weaker, because for the foreseeable future Labour's leaders are not even proposing to restore the public sector to the size it was before 1979.
'The case" for what the document calls "social ownership" is "restated" in terms which make the subservience to capitalist market criteria even clearer. Social ownership, it says, is best for public utilities and services like telephones, electricity, gas and so on. Socially-owned industries can make profits "for Britain" . And they can discriminate in favour of British suppliers.
There is no trace here of the idea of supporters, Briefing supporters, other leftists like Khan and Scally alike — to go to court. Sometimes the legal action has thwarted the witch-hunters. It has seemed to work.
But any such use of the courts can only mean substituting their "justice" for the fight for democratic procedures within the labour movement. It contradicts the basic principle of the independence of working class organisafions from the capitalist state.
The courts may occasionally favour the left. But they will much more often favour the right. And certainly the procedure of labour movement disputes regularly being settled by the capitalist courts would inevitably favour the right wing.
The current wave of court cases has done very little to stop the witch-hunt. It has provided the witch-hunters with the occasion and the pretext to streamline their procedures for expulsions and propose a new 'Star Chamber' And now it has given them a let-out over Khan and Scally.
We must stop the witch-hunt — through a mass campaign in the rank and file for a democratic labour movement, not through futile appeals to the capitalist courts. public ownership being the lever for collective democratic control of the nollantiva damnatin contral of thi economy, in place of the inhumanity of the capitalist market mechanism.
In such a framework "worker involvement" can only be a means of tying workers to the interests of profit. The document makes this fairly explicit: "a widespread acceptance of responsibility for making the organisation successful is vital".
There are proposals for greater trade union rights to information and consultation, which are useful but vague, but the main, 'democratic' proposal is the old, and failed, one of workerdirectors.
The document also includes proposals for a British Investment Bank, talk about new "strategic stakes" for the government in various sectors... and a welcome fvor the American idea of employee share-ownership plans!
Wrapping it all up are clear warnings not to expect too much: "it will require more than one term in office to complete our programme... "; and not to expect renationalisation under any terms of what the Tories have privatised: "We will not allow our priorities to be dictated by the Tories' privatisation programme"
~ 100K
Scan page 4
-PAN ABOUR BLACKPOOL 86 elections STRIKE Winning ded enquiries like the one in Liver- 10 TA IO TO YA Constitutional Committee wants people a hearing. The proposal for the National stay through the night and allow The YS must be built, not witch-hunted! Photo John Smith, _By John Bloxam AS at previous conferences, Socialist Organiser will be producing a daily conference briefing for delegates and visitors.
Socialist Organiser has a distinctive voice on many basic political issues facing the Left. For example: our fundamental opposition to both capitalism and Stalinist totalitarianism; our insistence on the need to go beyond sloganising on Ireland and develop a working class, internationalist response to both the Anglo-Irish deal and the danger of sectarian civil war in the North of Ireland; and our advocacy that the South African trade unions should organise an independent workers' party there and fight for a democratic, revolutionary socialist alternative to apartheid.
Paper
Since 1979 SO has produced every year a popular dally Conference Briefing. On two separate occasions, last year's conference being one, we have cooperated with Labour Briefing and By Dennis Skinner MP By Dennis Skinner MP The proposal for the National Constitutional Committee wants opposing. There has been no consultation about it at all, no involvement of the rank and file.
It's always been accepted in the party that such constitutional changes should be done by way of an enabling resolution, so that the change only takes place the following year, thus allowing the constituency parties in the country and other affiliated organisations to have a chance to amend the proposal.
what 1s happening with this constitutional amendment is that it is being put straight before the Party Conference - without consultation. It is being done like that to get it through before the General Election, and in order to relieve those right wing NEC members nning who are happy to have long-win- who are happy to have long-winded enquiries like the one in Liverpool - but who are not prepared to pool - but who are not prepared to stay through the night and allow people a hearing.
There is no question that it will be a Star Chamber. The left on the NEC originally opposed it in principle but, when it was going through the NEC, we tried to change some of the details. One big thing that's wrong with it is that there are five trade union representatives to only three from the constituencies and two from the women's sections (who will in fact really be elected by the trade union block I think the proposal is dangerous and frightening.
One of the other things that has to be campaigned against is this new paper that is going to force trade unions to ballot on industrial action and on their own elections. It is accepting many of the proposals on balloting that came out of the Thatcher government, which we opposed at the time. The most remarkable thing was that when In
----- pull-quotes -----
parliamentary time permits" (which is probably code for "some time in the
riefing for