Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Last week 1 argued that money, prices and…]

Socialist Organiser no. 285, 25 September 1986 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,521 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Last week 1 argued that money, prices and buying and selling are not eternal facts of nature like the alr and the sky, but particular arrangements in a particular sort of society.

They are the means by which, under capitalism, connection is made between the distribution of human labour to produce various goods and services and the ... sumption of those goods and services.

That connection could be made in different ways, by conscious human control. Under capitalism it happens without conscious control, through the seemingly automatic workings of the market.

If you can't find a job, it's noone's decision: the labour market is overstocked. If your factory goes bust and closes, it wasn't a plot: there just wasn't demand for its products at a profitable price. you can't buy enough to live decently, you can't blame any individual: the prices were set by the free market.

So the real active forces in the economic system seem to be things commodities and money, which exchange in definite proportions because of some mystical property in them.

Commodity and money relations also COVE up exploitation. For workers it seems as logical that the capitalist pays them a 'fair' wage as that they pay the shopkeeper a "fair' price for a pound of potatoes.

*The sphere of circulation of commodity exchange, within whose boundaries the sale and ourchase of labour goes on, is it of the innate rights of man. It is the exclusive realm of Freedom, Equality, Property and Bentham.

Freedom, because both buyer and seller of a commodity, let us say of labour power, are determined only by their free will. They contract as free persons, who are equal before the law. Their contract is the final result in which their joint will finds a common legal expression.

Equality, because each enters into relation with the other, as with a simple owner of commodities, and they exchange equivalent for equivalent.

Property, because each disposes only of what is his own.

And Bentham, because each looks only to his own advantage...

[Bentham was a bourgeois philosopher of the time].

When we leave this sphere of simple circulation or the exchange the free-trader vulgaris provides of commodities, which provides views, his concepts and the standard which he judges the society of capital and wage labour, a certain change takes place, or so it appears, in the physiognomy of our dramatis personae.

He who was previously the money-owner now strides out in front as a capitalist; the possessor of labour power follows as his worker.

The one smirks self-importantly and is intent on his business; the other is timid and holds back, like someone who has brought his own hide to market and now has nothing but tanning else to expect but Here too the conclusions are of political importance. Bourgeois concepts of human rights, freedom and democracy are not the only ones given by nature.

The working class can develop other values. Under capitalism it does so only partially and occasionally, because "the ruling ideas are the ideas of the ruling class". But in a revolution the working class changes not only social relations but also its own ideas. Organiser no. 285. 25 September 1986 Page 10 Polish bourgeois hegerace nf "democracy in " as the New York Times duscribed it has been an immense source of satisfaction to the Reagan administration. It is a myth of course that the USA prefers bloody military dictators to safeguard their interests. They support such dictatorships when those interests are threatened: but they prefer to do business with regimes that at least have the facade of elected legitimacy.

Satisfied

The US has cause to be satisfied. Only the new President of Peru, Alan Garcia, has taken action on restricting payments on the debt, and issuing statements attacking imperialism. The transition to democracy - with the notable exception of Chile - has politically been a remarkably stable affair, more so than most observers predicted.

The process was characterised by a pólitical unification of the Latin September 1986 Page as, instead of ands for social and retorms and a participademocracy, were channelled alto accepting a very self-limiting democracy, a conservative economic programme, and the postponement of essential reforms. Democracy in Latin Amenca uas marina hao been essentially an electoral affair. And even in Brazil the people who had taken to the streets in their millions to demand direct elections for the President were fobbed off with the indirect election of Tancredo Neves, and are still awaiting the right to participate in direct Presidential elections.

Superficially at least it looks as if a magic conjuring trick has occurred. The bourgeoisie who had supported the military coups which swept Latin America in the 1960s: and 1970s are now able to present themselves as the true representatives of democratic values and guarantors of human rights. Long-standing supporters of the military such as President Sarney of Brazil are able to portray themselves as true believers of people's democracy. Privatisation of the State sector has been espoused as democratic, and state enterprises linked to the bad old days of mılitary, authoritarian rule.

Yes even cause inass radical proDebt In the last four years the debtcaused depression in Latin America can only be compared to that of the Great Depression. The total Latin American debt rose from $20.8 billion in 1970 to $360 billion in 1984, 86% concentrated in just six countries - Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Venezuela, Chile and Peru. Beginning with Mexico in August 1982, a combination of the effects of a rise in real interest rates, a terms of trade loss, an export loss due to world recession, and an oil price rise for oil importers, forced one Latin American country after another to renegotiate their debt repayments.

The cost of such renegotiations have been enormous for the price of renegotiation has been the acceptance of an IMF readjustment programme which was designed to reduce imports and increase exports to obtain the foreign exchange needed to pay interest payments on the debt. Imports were reduced from S101 billion in 1981 to $61 billion in 1984.

Although the amount of exports increased substantially, the decline in their prices meant Latin America was exporting the same value in exports in 1984 as in 1981 - $99 billion.

However substantial with the debt crisis Latin America is about to enter its phase of the construction of the bourgeois democratic hegemony comparable to Europe and Japan after the Second World War.

If that does happen then it will occur in circumstances very different to that of Europe and Japan who constructed a consensus around rising living standards fo all. It would be an hegemony based on a despair about the feasibility o! more radical alternatives, and a fea about the return of the military. would be a negative acceptance o the present. It is hard to believ that that is stable.

The possibilities for left-win alternatives should arise.

But in general the left in Lati America is in general disarray the guerilla struggles of the '60 and "70s have cost them dear. Ou side of Central America no guerill group was able to develop a ma: base - indeed the foco theor tended to despise such painstakin work.

There is a widespread distrust ‹ militaristic adventures, and of tho who supported them. The Con munist Parties of Latin America with the exception of Chile - a divided and with relatively litt influence. There is thus a hu vacuum on the left - waiting tol filled.

Scan page 6

"SAINT RUPERTS Labour must support Wapping strikers. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, IFL. BLACKROOYa WHOPPING EXPOSED As someone who has contributed in a modest way to the profits of Benson and Hedges Ltd., I took a personal interest in the very public death of Pat Phoenix.

This morbid fascination was fully catered for by the tabloid press, hanging about like vultures waiting for good old Pat to pop her clogs.

Good she was as well. A lifelong Labour supporter, she had posed for photographers alongside Michael Foot at a time when being associated with Worzel was not exactly guaranteed to boost your street credibility.

The death-bed drama was undoubtedly her finest performance, and to the extent that she was aware of it, I am sure she did not object to the media's close attention.

Even so the despicable Peter Adamson, spilling his guts to the Sun as she lay dying was thoroughly nauseating: "Len weeps for Elsie" was the headline. How much Adamson was paid for his intimate revelations, I do not know.

Elsie and Pat merged into one as the tabloids awaited the inevitable end: her brilliant last act was marred only by the presence of the priest who doubled up by marrying her to Anthony Booth and administering the last rites at the same time.

I was pleased to read in the Sunday press that she later "fired her priest" for "being too morbid"

If Pat Phoenix was the week's Goodie, then Raz Koumba Balogum was the Baddie. He denies that upon

----- pull-quotes -----

Years of repression have taken thei hirtation and eye partitipa group

bad al Owen

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 285

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →