B id Campaign groups
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
TERE will be much interesi at s year's Labour Party conference Campaign Forum, set up last -ekend as a framework for coopition between the Campaign oup of MPs, Labour Left Liaison, i the left inside the trade unions.
Tampaign Forum will both strengin the Left's fight for commonly teed goals - democracy in the Ly, accountability of Labour's repreitatives - and provide a framework help the left define its politics, rategy and tactics in the run-up to the action and after.
Campaign Forum will attempt to The watchword must be: left unity in tion for common goals — open disssion of the differences within the ft.
The harsh truth is that the Left has en dithering for years. Campaign rum is important because it should prove left cooperation on immediate actical issues (elections to the Natal Executive, conference resoluns, solidarity with working-class uggles).
It could give the Labour left a visiity it has not had for quite a while, d thus help us to act as a counterright to both rank and file demoralition and the Labour leaders' retreat fore the Tories' political and ideologal offensive.
Campaign Forum will also have to epare for Labour in government. One of the left's central weaknesses ring the fight for democracy in the rly 1980s — as SO argued at the time was that it never seriously extended : fight to the trade unions or rearmed elf politically. Most of those who coiled from the last Labour governint's record in office failed to think ings through to the point of reaching ble conclusions radically different m the ideas of Labour's old lefi ng, which had been so feeble and so mpromised during the '60s and "70s. e coming to party leadership of first ot and then Kinnock disoriented the Foot and Kinnock had the support of est of the left, and started our with : same basic policies as the mainolin Foster reviews 'The Making f the Second Cold War' by Fred olitically it is not very good.
He gives a clear summary of the lilitary facts of the arms race, and world politics since the late 970s. This second edition of the ›ok (the first edition was publish| in 1983) takes the story up to Tly 1986.
On detailed questions Halliday is oughtful and often acute. But hat do all the details add up to? hat do the facts mean? What's it about?
Halliday's answer is that the old War is based on "the Great intest" between "capitalism and mmunism" as represented by the SSR. He is careful to note that he use of the term communism is t intended to suggest that the -viet Union has attained what -x or Lenin have described as the emmunist organisation of siety"; he is critical, and indeed e book's cover quotes a Stalinist -iewer denouncing Halliday for anti-Soviet snarls"
Yet his criticism is expressed as gret that the USSR has not "been veloping torms of socialist demo+cy at home and adhering tola stream left — which they then used to help them prop up and renovate the old Labour establishment.
The growth of the SDP panicked many leftists into the conclusion that they should not go too far, and thus softened them up for Neil Kinnock's message: office is everything• On top of this, the local government left took power in a number of areas in 1979-82. Whole layers of the left found themselves at local level making — or justifying — administrative decisions and choices based on the limited options allowed by the capitalist system and the Tory government - the sort of "responsible' 'don't-rock-the-boat" decisions that the Kinnockites were urging them to accept as a programme for a Labour government.
The local government left, led at first by the avowed careerist and 'me-first' politician Ken Livingstone and the muddled opportunistic ex-revolutionary-socialist Ted Knight, turned local government into a huge school of reformism and class collaboration. Often they found themselves, the lefts, playing the role of managers against the workers; they developed an open hostility to trade union militancy.
The left is only now recovering from the disarray created by those developments - which arose decisively from the left's own lack of preparedness and lack of clear goals.
There is some recognition of the problems now on the left. When Campaign Forum was established, it was generally accepted that it should campaign for positive socialist policies and not just be a 'negative' opposition inside the Party. It was also agreed to include the trade union Left in the Forum framework, and to build Campaign Groups in the different unions.
Class
Much, however, still needs to be discussed and filled out. Socialist Organiser does not believe, for example, that putting forward a programme based on a sum of the demands of different campaigns inside the Labour Party — a left version of the Rainbow Coalition' — can add up to either a comid the col clearly distinct military policy [from the USA's] internationally"
as if the USSR's rulers could reasonably be expected to reform themselves in such fashion!
Halliday's detailed narrative ties the Second Cold War most specifically to the US's conflict with revolutionary movements in the Third World. For him, this is inseparable from the "Great Contest" . The USS's "ideology and social interests" tie it to anti-capitalist revoluist" structure, is a marginal aberration.
Distinctions
I'm not convinced: but for all that Halliday's examination of Third World revolutions is valuable. Too often both left and right speak of such revolutions as simply one expression after another of some single world-historic Force or Process or Tide. Halliday analyses, draws distinctions, differentiates.
Between 1962 and 1974, he points out, there was only one revolutionary seizure of power in the Third World. The Portuguese revolution of 1974 and the Vietnamese victory of 1975 opened a new period. Between 1974 and 1980 there were 14 Third World revolutions. prehensive or a radical socialist programme on which to organise the working class to replace rotting British capitalism with working-class socialism.
Central to any socialist programme, we believe, must be the working class and the fight for working-class control of society.
There are many other issues - for example, Ireland - on which the left needs to begin a serious discussion, and on which it now does little but empty slogan-mongering.
There is another, positive side, best shown in the way so large a part of the Labour Party responded to the miners' strike — despite Kinnock and the Labour leaders. A defeat after a heroic fight is a thousand times better than an abject surrender with no fight at all.
Strong
Many Labour leftists went through a major school of class struggle in the 1984-5 miners' strike. The left was strong enough to win a major victory at last year's TUC and Labour Party conferences in support of the Although there were only feeble attempts to organise the left after the winding-up of the RFMC and Tony Benn's deputy leadership campaign, we remained strong enough to mount serious resistance to the various attempts at a damaging witch-hunt in the Party.
The left is not strong enough now to stop Kinnock and Hattersley presenting Labour as a new version of the SDP. The situation could be very different after an election, with the Labour leadership trying to run a decrepit British capitalism in severe crisis. The left will have mechanisms to make that leadership accountable which have not existed in the past -mandatory reselection of MPs, annual conference election of the Leader and Deputy Leader.
Kinnock and his faction understand this only too well. Hence the witchhunt and the recurring moves to gut the democratic reforms. The Labour Party may not yet be safe for a Wilson/Callaghan-type government.
This is the importance of the Labour left trying to reorganise now. CamForum should help the left politically — as we failed to do in the early '80s, and still need to do now.
dwar Since then there has been none:
partly, maybe, because of the US counter-offensive, but also because those 1974-80 revolutions were almost all against colonial regimes or old-fashioned dictatorships of a
----- pull-quotes -----
lild broad Campaign Groups in local Visible
falliday (Verso, £6.95). red Halliday's book is useful but
tion, and the contrary orientation of China, with the same "commun-