Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Waves, wind and iobs

Socialist Organiser no. 285, 25 September 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 681 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Supporters of nuclear power in the labour movement have made much of the supposed job losses and shortages of electricity if the industry was closed down.

An article in the Autumn edition of New Ground, quarterly magazine of Socialist Environment and Resources Association) exposes the fallacies in their arguments, using the CEGB's own figures!

The author, David Ross, shows that the CEGB has spare capacity of about 7000 megawatts (MW), even on the coldest winter's day, while electricity generated by nuclear plants amounts to about 5000 MW. thus, there would be at least 2000 MW in reserve, even if nuclear plants were shut down immediately with no alternative methods brought in.

Looking at some of the alternatives, namely wind and wave power, often pooh-poohed by government and industry spokespeople, Ross reveals that the CEGB's own experts state (in a booklet called Alternative Energy Sources) that these could supply sizeable chunks of the UK's energy needs.

Wind generators situated in only the most suitable sites, placed off-shore to avoid dis turbing the environment, could generate enouch electricity to satisfy our total needs.

Wave generators alone could supply more than enough power to replace all existing nuclear plants. The Department of Energy estimates the cost of such electricity at 8p per unit, somewhat expensive. But the CEGB booklet admits that this figure would be halved, using a Norwegian invention. The Norwegian experimental wave power station is already producing electricity at 4p per unit.

The CEGB expert also believes that tidal energy could produce 6% of Britain's energy needs, comparable to the 10% now met by nuclear power. Even without considering geothermal (hot rocks and springs) power, solar power, burning refuse, conservation measures, use of "waste" heat from power stations etc., it is clear that there need be no difficulty in replacing nuclear energy.

But what about jobs? Figures of 150,000 job losses are regularly bandied about by Labour Environment spokesperson John Cunningham or the EETPU's Eric Hammond. | Well, it so happens Ireland Available from SO: skills and techniques needed for constructing, say. wave power stations are just those avatlable in some of Britain's declining industries. Vickers Engineering and Shipbuilding have submitted a design for an Oscillating Water Column generator which could produce power at 4p per unit. Sitting on the ocean floor, it would need 700 steel tubes, each 80 metres long, weighing 2300 tonnes. Vickers already employes 12,500 workers Cumbria, where Sellafield is sited, and would be well placed to offer alternative jobs to some nuclear workers.

Another design for a waves generator by Sir John Cockerell, inventor of the hovercraft, could employ the workforce of Consett steel works for five years.

Wind generators could supply employment for the skills of the aerospace industry, while geothermal power would utilise drilling and mining skills; etc., etc.

In the meantime, the knowledge of the nuclear industry could be put to good use trying to devise safe ways of disposing of the dangerous radioactive waste and equipment left byBritain's brief excursion into. nuclear power.

The rest of this issue of New Ground contains much of interest to socialists and trade unionists, Jake Jackson, research officer for GMBATU, outlines the threat to workers lives and health posed by Tory cuts in health and safety and lists priorities for Labour to strengthen the Health and Safety at Work Act.

Two articles establish food •aditives as a socialist issue. In one, Melanie Miller describes the threat to workers' health in food factories and details strike and other action taken by food workers.

On nuclear power, an update on Chernobyl paints a grim picture of future illness and death. Another article outlines the nuclear debacle in Brazil and India, as Western nuclear companies try to find new markets for their unpopular wares.

New Ground 11 is available from SERA, 9 Poland Street, London WIV 3DG. A year's sub is £3, or for an introductory copy send 5 17p stamps. Membership of SERA (including sub to New Ground) is £9 (£8 by bankers' order).

Socialis FORUM Number

----- pull-quotes -----

3ox 823, London SI INA. 50p plus p&p

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 285

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →