Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Still logiamm ogj Labour and Nuclear Power

Socialist Organiser no. 285, 25 September 1986 · scan p. 12 · Lol Duffy · about 1,556 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

ORGANISEE 986 will be seen as the year the nuclear controversy dominated labour movement debates. In the year of Chernobyl, an incredible 184 motions on Labour's conference agenda are on energy policy, 183 against nuclear power and just one, from Copeland (which includes Sellafield), calling for Careerism is the pro John Baker, Chairman of NIREX, dashes from a secret meeting with Council hear Fulbeck, Lincs., 12 September 1986. Photo: Nigel Clapp.

A woman militant from the South African Metal and Allied Carol Hall, Wapping striker and acting MoC at the Times Paul Whetton, Notts NUM member and Bevercotes branch secretary, recently victimised for his trade union activity Unmesh Desai, Newham Monitoring Project and Anti-Fascist Hotel and Guest House Association, 87a Coronation Street WICKER keeping it, Pat Phoenix was a socialist who was always ready to speak out for working people on platforms for jobs and peace, social justice and internationalism.

Her courage and ner commitment will long be remembered and we mourn her passing.

TONY BENN Last week it looked for a while as if there would be some movement away from the political stalemate in Sir Frederick Catherwood, a Conservative Euro-MP who has been holding private discussions with all the Party leaders in Northern Ireland, proposed It seems inconceivable/ that conference will not vote to phase out nuclear power quickly. And yet ... a certain anti-nuclear majority at the TUC conference was subverted. During secretive stitch-ups, NALGO was persuaded to ignore its own policy and vote for a delaying tactic of a moratorium on future plants and a safety review of existing ones. An antı-nuclear majorıty of over a million became a proGeneral Council one of just 60,000.

Will things go differently at Labour Party conference? Here, the game is slightly different. Kinnock and Cunningham are trying to head off not a vote against nuclear power - that is a foregone conclusion -but a two-thirds majority which in theory at least guarantees the policy a place in the election manifesto.

Despite overwhelming opposition to nuclear power amongst CLPs, the real battle is for the trade union block votes. With the switch of ASTMS, firefighters and cinetechnicians, the two-thirds should be easily won. However, cynics will remember how union leaders have sometimes "acidentally" voted the wrong way or missed the vote!

Trade union delegations will have the utmost pressure exerted by a Labour leadership keen to appear moderate and "realistic" who talk of reducing dependence on nuclear power but only over several decades!

-During that time the could see several Chernobyls, ding to current estimates.

An article in last week's issue of Labour Weekly (757) by Peter Hain and Graham Allen calls for better facilities for MPs. The two PPCs argue that improved facilities would allow the Parliamentary Labour Party to carry out the jobs the Party wants them to do.

They also call for a democratically run Parliamentary Labour Party as opposed to the present system which leaves the decision making in the hands of those "Parliamentary Labour Party members who form the government."

Hain and Allen say that unless their conditions of a desk, telephone, an office, two secretaries and a researcher, all paid for out of public funds, are met "there could be an action replay of the 1960s and 1970s Labour governments where ministers become distanced from the Party" and "the result. would be disillusion, rebellion and eventual political disaster"

The PLP itself', they say, should prepare the necessary motions to enact this policy immediately upon coming into government" - They may be right when they say that poor facilities and an undemocratic Parliamentary Labour Party are causes for Labour's policies not being implemented in Parliament. But I suspect the main reasons are a lack of commitment to socialist policies by most Labour MPs and an unwillingness to take a leading role in fighting for a socialist socieLy.

The Parliamentary Labour Party tends not to be made up of the best working class socialists elected bethat the Anglo-Irish conference should not meet for two months and that in that time there should be UnionistNationalist talks on the setting up of a form of Northern Ireland government in Belfast which would be acceptable to a majority of both Catholics and Protestants.

John Hume, the leader of the constiOn the plus side is the support for phasing out of such as Heffer and Benn. The latter worked with the nuclear industry as Minister for Technology and was lied to, misled and pressured by them.

The arguments against nuclear power as it exists at present threaten to become overwhelming. Not only have we been close to disasters several times in its short life but dozens, if not hundreds, have suffered and died from radiationlinked diseases. These include the leukaemias and thyroid cancers caused by leaks, deliberate and accidential, and the cancer deaths of nuclear workers, whose compensation claims are always settled out of court.

Mountains of waste accumulate with no method of disposal. The problems of dismantling retired nuclear power stations has yet to be faced.

The use of "civil" plutonium for atom bombs has gradually been exposed despite the lies and evasions of Her Majesty's Government.

Even the economic case for nuclear power has been severely dented. After the promises of free electricity (!), costs turn out not much different from conventional sources.

But the double crux of the debate will be the questions of jobs and alternative energy sources. The working class needs serious answers to these questions. Such answers exist (see Science Column) and must be convincingly presented, in personal capacity)

socialism! That's for sure. Many Labour MPs, and PPCs, see the goal oi getting to Parliament and beyond that maybe achieving a place in government as the pinnacle of their 'political' careers.

Think of those stalwarts of socialism who have been Labour Party MPs in the past. Ramsey MacDonald, David Owen, Shirley Williams, Reg Prentice, - and now being serialised in the scab Murdoch Times, Robert Kilroy-Slick.

The action replay of the 1960s and 1970s Labour governments is indeed on the cards, but not because of the lack of Parliamentary facilities. It is because the Labour Party has failed to learn - or refused to learn - the lessons of past Labour governments which ran this bent capitalist system at the expense of Labour's own working class supporters.

tutional nationalist SDLP commented

that this should not be difficult since the Anglo-Irish conference anyway meets only about once every two months.

The surprise was that the leaders of the two big Unionist parties, lan Paisley of the Democratic Unionist Party • and James Molyneux of the Official Unionist Party did not immediately rule it out and at first it looked as if they might agree to give it a try.

But then they changed tack and insisted that the Anglo-Irish agreement had to be formally suspended and its headquarters at Maryfield closed down before there could be any negotiations.

This would be completely unacceptable to the SDLP, and to the British and Irish governments.

It may be that Paisley and Molyneux were hauled back into line by their own more uncompromising supporters. That is what happened on the eve of the Unionist Day of Action last March when Paisley and Molyneux emerged from discussions with Thatcher talking about compromise only to be forced to publicly eat their own words when they got back to Belfast.

Meanwhile the death toll from sectarian assassinations in Northern Ireland rises almost daily. Paisley, for the first time that anyone can remember, issued a firm condemnation of the Protestant sectarian assassins.

Significant

The Protestant reaction to Sir Frederick Casherwood's proposals is significant because sooner or later some centre-stage politicians will be persuaded to take their political lives in their hands and try to work out an agreement with the SDLP within the Anglo-Irish agreement.

That will speed up the polarisation within the Protestant community, freeing from restraint those who are prepared to resist the Anglo-Irish agreement by violent means. There are many such people and some of them are talking openly about striking at the South — as the UDA did murderously by setting off bombs without warning in Dublin back in 1972.

blem!

The fight for more democracy in the Labour Party, which was stepped up after the defeat of the last Labour government, could have led to greater democratic control of Labour MPs and therefore to a more answerable Labour government. But that campaign has now been ditched by many who initiaHy supported it in favour of the election of a Labour goveriment at any cost and by way of the presentation of a respectable image.

The fight for democracy and socialists has been replaced by the drive to out-SDP the SDP. We must continue to fight for socialism in the Labour Party. The big lesson of the last years, when so many former left-wingers have given up, is this: the struggle for socialism in the Labour Party, and throughout society, can only • be won by those with strong political commitment!

No amount of desks, telephones and secretaries will improve the politics of a careerist!

SOCIALIST ORGANISER MEETING Labour Conference Fringe Meeting Our Common Struggle Speakers Workers Union SOGAT Lol Duffy, Wallasey PPC Action 7.30 p.m. Monday 29 September

----- pull-quotes -----

cause of theirrecord in the fight for Photo: Morning Star

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 285

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →