'Britain won't allow it'
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Daisy Mules: When Paisley made his very aggressive statements about civil war, we analysed that as a result of the power struggle going on among the Loyalists. Peter Robinson is being seen by the harder line Loyalists as a potential leader, so somehow Paisley had to regain ground. Also Paisley wanted to scare people.
After the divorce referendum, he immediately backtracked. He said that now there was no need for a civil war because the 26 counes had shown by their denial of divorce as a civil right that Irish mity was mot a possibility.
There's been a lot of publicity of Loyalist attacks on the RUC and the UDR mosty the RUC -mes. But titey ve als
Scan page 9
united working class until you have a united Ireland. You'll get a united working class after a united Ireland. You can see the force in that argument. But if you analyse the situation the opposite also holds: you don't get a united Ireland until you've got a united working class.
Does that mean the whole situation is impossible? It means it's very difficult. It means you can't rely on the two-stage theory. You have to be trying to create a united working class, or at least a partially united working class - you're not going to win over the entire Protestant working class - at the same time as you fight for a united Pat Murphy: What's happening in the Loyalist community? What are the prospects for its opposition? It seems to me that if lan Paisley is being forced into posturing - like his call for action on the streets and so on - it's an indication of the strength of the Loyalist opposition. Paisley has dominated the Protestants since 1970 and his party has been increasingly dominant since 1979 or so. If he's forced to posture, it shows the strength of the Loyalist opposition.
Civil war isn't just morally bad because people start butchering each other. The point is that the political settlement that would come out of it would be repartition. So there are political reasons as well as moral ones to recoil from the prospect of civil war, It's not a question, as Niall said, that we don't recognise the right of the Irish people to deterimine their own future. But there's a difference between recognising that right and realising it. To put it starkly: the political force that can create a united Ireland doesn't exist at the moment; it has yet to be created. That's one of the rea-sons why a united Ireland seems so distant. _Sinn Fein's struggle, justified as it is, is limited. It's limited geographically, and also physically to 10% of the entire Irish people. It's also politically limited, but that's another discussion. It's continued struggle at best can defend the Catholic community. But all it can do is maintain the stalemate, and Republican martyrs on a Belfast wall.
push and prod the British government into attempted reforms.
Support amongst constitutional nationalists for the Accord is partly, as Daisy said, due to their fear of Sinn Fein. But it also concedes something to them that's new. It concedes that the Southern Irish government has got a say in the affairs of the North.
But also the Republican movement is vulnerable to that kind of strategy. The idea of reforming the Northern Ireland state continues to have some weight. The alternative - a united Ireland - seems remote and distant. That's a problem we have to confront.
The British and Irish governments are trying to create a framework that will break the stalemate - in their interests. That's exactly what we have to do. We have to create the force that united Ireland.
We have to break from conventional Catholic-Irish nationalism, and return to traditional Republicanism - uniting the Irish people.
ot double standards. But there's a ditterence between the kind of civil war you might see in South Africa on the one hand and Ireland on the other. It's a difference for example of a situation like the Lebanon - two working class communities slaughtering eachother, with no progress coming out of it; and a situation perhaps like Spain.
Civil war in South Africa might be a necessary stage to unite the country and allow the working class to fight for its own demands. Civil war in Ireland would be different. And that's what the discussion is about. Everyone here supports the struggle for a united Ireland. But if there is a civil war, which would mean repartition, that would certainly not be an advance on the situation, and could well be a step backwards. - That's our concern in talking about civil war and repartition.
Daisy said she doesn't think there would be repartition. I'm not quite sure why she thinks that.
There are two arguments, I think. One is that the Protestants aren't strong enough to organise their own state outside of Britain. I just don't think this is the case. They're strong enough numerically and armed enough to do it.
The second is that a Protestant state wouldn't be economically viable. But it doesn't depend upon cold economic calculations. I can't assess that. It depends upon a political drive, which would be very strong.
Comrades have pointed quite rightly to the problems of creating working class unity. But they're missing the point - it's a problem, it's been tried before and failed so it'll have to wait for a united Ireland... This just ignores the points that have been made here, We're not saying that we've got all the answers. We're trying to address the problem. That's important. The comrades haven't explained how a united Ireland is going to happen outside of some kind of unity.
----- pull-quotes -----
Dialogue with ity
Leba John Bloxam: Niall complained
Fein 41 PRECIA
IN70O A10Л NEBA JARED TOA 197 THEN OL JAMES LAL VOL HUK