Protestant puppets?
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
There are two theoretically possible answer. First is that you look to conquering the Protestants by physical force; the other is that you look towards winning them over, or at least a section of them.
Whether or not conquest is desirable, it seems to us that given the relationship of forces it is not possible. The Protestants could hold at least a part of the northeast of Ireland - through pogroms against Catholics living there, and so on. Therefore you have to look towards winning over a section of the Protestants, particularly the working class, politically. I'd like to what Sinn Fein's • ideas are about that task?
Tony Dale: Paisley talking about civil war does highlight the danger of it. Paisley is softening up compared to many others in the Loyalist camp.
With people like Robinson taking control of the mobilisations it increases the danger.
It's not a question of crystal ball gazing - will there or won't there be a sectarian civil war? To recognise the possibility, as Sinn Fein do, is more serious than many on the British Left. On the British Left much of the response to the Deal has been to say, Well, it's not really affecting the Protestant Britain, oT here an tendencin to sth the Protestants just as puppets, just as dupes, and not recognise that their reaction to the Deal shows the extent to which they are an independent force, Daisy said that the Anglo-Irish Deal strengthens the Loyalist veto. Yes, it's got written into it that the Protestants should be consulted and so on, but the Loyalists want themselves alone to decide what happens in the north. The Deal takes that away; it says that what's going to count is what we think in London, and what our counterparts think an important change.
Peter Keenlyside: It worries me lem people describe the relationBritain and Ireland as above.
Daisy said - and it struck me as very strange - that there isn't much likelihood of a sectarian civil war. And the reason she gave is that Britain wouldn't allow it. Now whatever the rights and wrongs of using the slogan troops out, on its own, we're all agreed that Britain's involvement in Ireland must end. What if we're successful - tomorrow? Then the thing that will prevent civil war will be removed. It's strange for people fighting British imperialism to look to it to prevent civil war.
Liam Conway: Daisy said there wouldn't be a civil war. I think it's true that the Anglo-Irish Deal won't lead to civil war, because it doesn't threaten the union between Northern Ireland and Britain. But if you look at history, civil war has been most likely when the Union was threatened.
On the question of Protestant supremacy, I think it's wrong to deal with the Protestants as a whole unit in a supremacist sense, or to talk about them as if they were only the Protestant leaders and not ordinary Protestant people as well. Socialists have got to cut through Protestant and indeed all - leaders and look at the roots of the Protestants' fears.
And of course there are plenty of Protestants suffering unemployment as well as Catholics.
We have to look not just at their social concerns, but other concerns too.
The Protestant minority in the whole of Ireland see themselves as having a separate identity. It's a working class interest, that they feel a separate identity. It's not just a concern of their leaders who are duping the Protestant workers South reing aces their deser at the
----- pull-quotes -----
in Dublin. It's taken away Protes- tant self-determination' , and that is