Double standard
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
tion. Daisy contribution suggested that the idea of repartition exists in the Loyalist community, but in the cold light of day they would drop it very quickly. If that is her view I think it is underestimating it, and the Republican News editorial was more accurate. Could she explain in more detail Sinn Fein's attitude?
Martin Thomas: It's quite common on the Left in Britain to hear people describe the Northern Ireland Protestants as paper tigers"; to say that the Anglo-Irish deal is entirely in their interests, and they just don't understand what's going on. The analysis that Daisy gave is a lot more realistic.
That raises a question. If the Protestant backlash is a response to a serious shift in the policy of the ruling class, that same backlash is going to exist against any movement towards a united Ireland How should socialists and republicans deal with that? all ›w it to happen.
Paisley and the other Unionist leaders are very well aware that the Anglo-Irish agreement does not erode their rights. In fact it entrenches their rights in many ways. It actually states that the Loyalist veto will be always upheld.
Repartition isn't a real possibility, in our view.
What are we doing to win over Protestants policially? There's no way that Sinn Fein is going to win over Loyalists by political argument while their supremacy is guaranteed to them by the British government. So long as their supremacy is guaranteed, they won't listen to any discussion or talks. They won't even talk to John Hume, We think a basic requirement for any talks to develop is that the Unionist guarantee is taken away. Then they will engage in discussion. But until then, why should they talk to us? ialism.
Britain got out of colonies where it was in a better position to extract profit. I don't know what it gets out of Ireland. The situation can't be explained with the classic analysis of imperialism. If you try explain it like that, you miss a lot of points.
The Protestants have got every reason to be wary of deals like the Anglo-Irish Agreement. At the end of it the project is for Britain to establish a relationship with Irish capitalism like that it has with any other capitalist country: an inter-capitalist relationship.| The project for both the British and Irish ruling classes is to normalise the situation. That does mean doing away with this 'odd' situation in the North. At the end of the day, it's in the interests of British capitalism to have a united That's not to say that the project will succeed. It will fail because it's a solution imposed from Niall Power: First, on civil war. Nobody would underestimate the very real danger of civil war. But I do detect a certain double standard when some people on the British Left discuss this question.
We call for an end to apartheid and one person, one vote in South Africa. There is the distinct possibility that the granting of those things would lead to civil war not just between whites and blacks but between blacks and blacks: a distinct possibility. But that doesn't lead us to water down our support for the ending of apartheid, or for one person, one vote.
I fail to see why we should water down our support for one person, one vote in Ireland either.
Second, on the sincere presume - call for workers unity in the North. Comrades, as much as you may wish for that to happen, I can assure you it simply won't happen while Britain remains in Ireland. If you doubt that, I suggest you go to Ireland, get more informed of the mentality and the material privileges of the Protestants - workers included.
You won't break through to any form of working class unity while Britain remains there.
A majority - a majority - of the Irish working class wants to see Britain out of Ireland. Why don't you support that majority clearly and unambiguously, without wanting provisos about particular forms of unity with one significant minority in a particular part of the country?
Third, I would like to ask SO for more information about federalism. Sean mentioned that federalism was one of the proposals coming out of the Irish Forum Report.: Is that a form of federalism that you would support?
I think Britain would like to leave Ireland, but it also needs to protect its interests. It does have financial interests, it does have industry, not only in the north but also in the south. The British taxpayer may be losing from it, but the British capitalist isn't.
And the military interests need to be protected, in the sense of American bases in the north of Ireland. A united Ireland - and certainly a militarily independent one - would threaten those quite seriously:
And ideologically, Britain isn't going to be forced out, like America was forced out of Vietnam.
Martin Thomas: I don't think any of us are saying that it's an straightforward task for the conclusion that that difficult task is the key task. To say that it's difficult is to say that progress in Ireland is difficult.
It's not just because we're fantastically concerned with the rights! of the Protestants, though I think we should be to a certain extent.: It's also a question of realistic calculation. Even if we said thatthe Protestants don't have anyrights at all, they nevertheless have force. As Daisy put it, they're al substantial minority, concentrated. and heavily armed. They have the force to prevent Ireland being: united.
Even on those grounds, you have to address the problem.
----- pull-quotes -----
socialists or republicans to address themselves to Protestant workers.