Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Summing up: John

Socialist Organiser no. 286, 2 October 1986 · scan p. 9 · about 1,405 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Jolin Maliony: You can't desirable, but in any case it/ measure the threat of sectarian wouldn't happen, Mules said about his motivation ation, working class unity is not the infighting in Unionist ranks - possible. However the idea that you is quite right. But then it is an old will only get it after a united Irejoke that lan Paisley is a bit of a land is simply nonsensical. You will "fake right' . He's a demagogue. You not get a united Ireland unless you can't measure the threat of civil find some way of uniting the Irish civil war by Paisley. What comrade war by Paisley's manoeuvrings.

The basic thing is that even today, even with the Deal, the Protestants think they can rely on the British state - it's their state, they identity with it. So long as it's there, they don't have the motivation to organise themselves for sectarian civil war, or rather for a war to carve out their own area of Ireland, to create their own state.

But given their heavy concentration, particularly in Antrim and Down, I don't see any reason to doubt that if they feel fundamentally threatened they will resist, and sectarian civil war will be a real part of the situation.

We should beware of logic chopping. It's fine to point out the contradiction in comrade Mules argument - that Britain prevents civil war, etc. But it's also absolutely irrefutably true. It's true that if Britain left without a political settlement the Protestants would try to sort it out in their own way.

In Britain we have to insist all the time that the Six County state is an artificial entity, and shouldn't exist. But that idea also contains a potential lie that Leftists can tell themselves: the lie that no Protestant majority state is viable or conceivable. In reality there is such a conceivable state - smaller than the present one -that could emerge out of a sectarian clash.

It is inconceivable that the Catholics could win. I don't think that subjugating Protestants is I agree that in the current situpeople; you will most likely get a repartitioned Ireland as a result of the Provo war. So it's a vicious circle.

You won't get a united Ireland by Catholic conquest of the Protestants. The Catholic half-million in the north could not conceivably conquer the Protestant million. It's inconceivable that the Catholic population in the South would mobilise to try to do it. It's just not possible.

Out of that we derive the notion of combining our propaganda for a socialist Ireland and for British withdrawal with some sort of democratic solution - a democratic version of federalism. On that basis you could at least talk to some of the Protestants. You could create small groups of united workers on that democratic basis. aiffer neati differences with Sinn Fein. We In reality that's one of our would accept that the Protestants are a legitimate Irish minorityThey are not just a political minority that can be said to be pro-imperialist or 'unionist' - though they are unionists. I'm not too sure of the precise definition though I wouldn't baulk too much at calling them a national minority.

Ireland's problem is that there's a national minority, but instead of that minority relating rationally and democratically to the Irish majority, the whole thing was snarled up by the intervention of the British ruling class in the artificial form of an artificial partition - which created a bigget Catholic minority than the Protestants would have been in the whole of rationally, as socialists, and also as We've got to look at Republicans, One of the problems with Sinn Fein is that to a considerable extent it's come to reflect the northern Catholic minority and to a serious extent to break with fundamental aspects of republicanism, for example in its abandonment of federalFederalism isn't something SO has just thought up. As long ago as 1921 the political leader of the Republicans who were soon to be in arms against the Free State government, De Valera, adopted some notion of federalism, recognising that there had to be an attempt to accommodate the Protestant minority.

It was very late in the story. History might have gone differently if that proposal had been part of the original Home Rule Bill of the 1880s. It wasn't. 1921 was very late in the affair, and there have never been many Protestant takers for the idea as far as I know.

But the point is to have a basic democratic programme that will allow workers to talk to workers and allow socialists from either community to assure people from. the other community that they respect their identity and do not propose any form of sectarian or national oppression.

I don't think that just because we're in Britain we can accept a self-denying ordinance that we have no right to do or say anything but simply reflect straightforward Provo Irish nationalism. I think it's far too complex for that.

and Dans been touched on is why Britain wants to stay in Ireland. It is an economic reason. But it's also a strategic reason, which noone has touched upon.

Seamus Mallon and Fitzgerald when the Anglo-Irish Agreement came out actually touched on it Mallon indicated that he would be willing to negotiate an end to Free State neutrality if he felt that would end the northern-Irish political deadlock. So Britain is there for strategic reasons tied up with NATO If they think they can bargain with the 26 Counties for an end to their neutrality, they'll do so. There's already been moves towards that; Fitzgerald is already talking about it.

When I said Britain wouldn't allow a civil war, I meant at present, within the partitionist state. If the troops are removed, some people say there would be a civil war. We would like to believe - and maybe it is an illusionary belief, but we'll have to wait and see - that if the troops are withdrawn, Britain declares its intention to withdraw, withdraws its military presence, and hopefully eventually its economic presence, this will force the Protestant working class to open dialogue with Republicans. That is our belief, The veto gives Protestant supremacy, whether you like it or not, or you think that they're not supreme. They're not in the sense that they are unemployed, as Republicans are you just have to look though not to the same extent. at Harland and Wolff, and Short Brothers, which employ a total majority Jo Protestant working class people. Republicans don't have that input into the job scene.

You can see that from the majority of the trade unions, from the NICICTU committee in the North, which is totally controlled by Protestants. That's because they're in work. Not full employment; but in any case whether they're in employment or not, they still believe they have supremacy. Whether or not reality says otherwise, they still believe that. While they do, and while their veto enshrines that belief, as it does, there's no way they will talk to Sinn Fein or Republicans. They won't even talk with the SDLP.

To suggest that this is what we should be doing is cuckooland stutt. Come over to Ireland and try it for yourselves. It's not going to happen.

I'm not saying that flippantly. Ideally that's what we would want. Some of us try it through trade union work, where we're meeting Protestant working class people. But most of the unions have clauses in their constitutions disallowing any discussion of political matters - by which they mean things to do with Ireland; they don't mean talking about the war in South Africa or in Nicaragua. They simply mean talking about the war in Northern Until the ICTU removes that constitutional bar on discussing politics, there will be no discussion. But in unions and trades councils where we can discuss, we do raise these issues.

Federalism. When Sinn Fein did have a policy of federalism, certainly didn't encourage unionists to talk to us, or encourage the Protestant working class to do so. I don't think federalism would create more discussion.

Sinn Fein dropped it because we saw it as a sop to the Loyalists and we felt it was weakening our positions. We also felt strongly that it wouldn't in the long run create a socialist Ireland that that's what we are trying to do.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 286

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →