Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Goodies V Baddies

Socialist Organiser no. 286, 2 October 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 810 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

simone, trom cheat to cuen. verge well, and au we lowme types wilU WUln 'Mona Lisa' has had a lot of advance publicity, generally very favourable. Yet it's disappointing. It's well acted, beautifully photographed and well put together, but it lacks the vital something that would fully bring it to life.

The plot is the problem. It's a very conventional good versus evil story. Nail Inean the director has tried to conceal its banality under layers of TCH JUL HAVM SV symbolism and arty photography, but it can't be hidden. And the arty treatment just distances you further — you have to stand back to admire it, so it doesn't grab you like other thrillers do.

It's a simple enough story. Fall guy George comes out of jail after seven years taking the rap for his boss Mortwell. As compensation, he gets a job chauffeuring a high class whore, tinat ta aliant Nannas Last Friday Channel 4 showed a documentary called Plenty They came to Britain as refugees 18 years ago from Kenya and the documentary touched on three Belinda Weaver reviews 'Mona Lisa'. falls in love, but the feeling isn't mutual. Simone wants to use George to find her friend Cathy, another whore, who used to work for Simone's sadistic pimp, Anderson.

George may be a chunky, quick tempered fellow, but he's the knight in chinine armour with a heart of old as well. He's the main character and he's likeable, if a bit short on brains. His pal Thomas, who makes a living selling luminous Madonnas and other plastic works of art, also brings a quirky, likeable eccentricity to the film.

George and Thomas are basically innocents, and the plot shows its antiquity by making innocence their means of protection from evil. Simone has lost her innocence, as have Cathy, Morton the or him. George may love Simone, but le doesn't understand her, and his not understanding her saves him from destruction.

He's just a bit player in the struggle between Simone who wants her freedom, and Mortwell, who makes a living from flesh peddling and drugs. George doesn't belong in the big league.

Hellish

The film is set in London, and of it have been dressed up to make them seem hellish — such as the Kings Cross sleaze area where George and Simone first look for Cathy. The sex clubs where George searches are suitably tawdry, a far cry from the swank hotels and houses where Simone plies her trade. But breaking free of either world is equally difficult, as May, whom George thinks at first is Cathy, and Simone both find out.

Thoush he's making a pretty basic the family have changed from being the "typical" Asian family into a fairly radicalised unit. For example their daughter Sujarta is living with an English man, while one of their sons, Mukesh, a Sikh, has married a Hindu woman, Raj, the eldest son, is living with a white woman and has integrated good-and-evil story, Jordan has tricked it out with a few symbols which may be comprehensible to fans of his earlier films, but which are otherwise gratuitous - the white rabbit George gives to Mortwell, the white horse George sees as he restores Cathy to Simone, the red hearts on the Brighton pier.

Simone herself is a symbol — 'Mona Lisa' - and as such, doesn't really make connection with the audience. She's as closed to us as she is to George. And George falls into the same trap as some of Simone's clients, by falling in love with what he thinks she is, rather than with the reality.

There are no bad performances in the film. Bob Hoskins as George and Michael Caine as the villain Mortwell. are both outstanding. But you admire them from a distance - the film doesn't have the kind of shocking immediacy that would really draw you kids for six months at a time, while they have to work away, living in hostels, being isolated and teeling alienated. Similarly, black men and women in Britain will argue that the tamily 1.e. the house, is sometimes the only place where they can escape from racist attacks and abuse - so we must be careful when analysing how the family affects our black comrades.

Religion

Religion of course is divisive. But at the end of the day workers have more in common with eachother than they do with some god or allah or whatever.

Does it really matter if somebody has dreadlocks or wears the Star of David.

Religion creates far too many brutal barriers that disunite and weaken our class.

The Barrot family highlighted the problems of integrating into a community, a society that is hosile through its blind prejudice andteeply misguided beliefs, JUN

----- pull-quotes -----

Chapati, Plenty Chips' about the Barot family who live in Leicester.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 286

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →