Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Whose freedom ?

Socialist Organiser no. 286, 2 October 1986 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 739 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

OFMARXISN Martin Sorry about last week's column; a typesetting mistake omitted the -source of the long quotation in it.

The quote was from Karl Marx Capital volume 1. Marx's point was that values and attitudes usual1y presented as eternal and natural are in fact shaped and moulded by the economic relations of society.

"The innate rights of man" , he says sarcastically, find their most typical expression in the processes of buying and selling. The market place is the realm of "Freedom, Equality, Property and Bentham" (We shall see later what he means alism, generally, all can sell freelyIn feudal society the typical working person could not sell his or her labour freely: he or she was tied to the lord's land. In capitalism workers are free to choose their employers he modern capitalist concept of freedom is different from earlier concepts. When feudal lords talked about their liberties' , they meant their traditional privileges, In early; commercial, capitalism, a free person was by definition an independent property-owner, someone who did not work for wages.

So the modern capitalist concept of freedom is wider. But it is still very limited. It is a negative freedom, an absence of legal restrictions rather than a positive freedom - a liberation of humanity from scarcity and drudgery and insecurity. Indeed, part of it free enterprise* - contains as its unspoken but necessary conclusion the conprice, than others.

But this capitalist equality, like capitalist freedom, is limited. It is formal equality, concealing the fact that some have masses of wealth and others have nothing to sell but their labour power. • Property? According to some modern economists, even the poorest workers have some property, some "capital'. Their labour-power is 'human capital, which they can rent out at the going rate just as bankers lend out their money capital.

In fact one class has no property other than maybe some clothes, a house, or some furniture: the other class, the capitalist class, monopolises the great masses of wealth which dominate society.

"And Bentham"? Marx puts it like this: "And Bentham, because each looks only to his own advantage". Jeremy Bentham was a bourgeois philosopher of the early 19th The other point that Marx makes is that the market-place is only one side of capitalism. In the market-place the worker (the seller of labour-power) is equal with the capitalist (the buyer of labour-power), just as any other seller is equal with any other buyer. But there's another side to it - a side which vanishes into the mist from the bourgeois point of view, but which is central from the workers? point of view.

When we go from the marketplace to the factory or office, *He who was previously the money-owner now strides out in front as a capitalist; the possessor of labour-power follows as his worker, *The one " smirks importantly and is intent on his business; the other is timid and holds back, like someone who has brought his own hide to market and now has nothing to expect but - a tanning" ballots increase union democracy and give control to ordinary members.

But the answer is not ballots imposed by Tory judges, but self-reform by the unions to create a real, accountable, participatory democracySubstitute Legal rights are never a substitute for working-class action at the point of production. Employers will try to ignore them, and established courts and tribunals will show bias in favour of employers in administering them.

But legal rights are part of the struggle. Every trade unionist knows that bosses will try to break or twist written agreements when it suits them; but we still fight for written agreements. And law giving rights to workers or unions is only a sort of 'written agreement" between the working class and the capitalist class at the level of the whole country rather than one workplace, company, or industry.

A fight for such legal rights can unite the working class. It means that the stronger sections of the working class are fighting for rights which they can impose by direct action to be extended to the whol class, including the weaker section And then those legal rights can an important lever for those weal sections to make then stronger!

Organiser no.

Scan page 12

again: only hours after capitulating By a SOGAT clerical member machine ror New realism raises its ugly head redundanci dundancies (over 50% in the lachine room, for example), longer

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 286

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →