First Principles
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
COMRADE JIM Denham (SO, 25 September) has correctly identified the three areas of our 1. Is Ireland subjected to imperialist, or colonial, domination 2. The position of the Northern 3. The responsibility of British Let us clarify our differences on 1. I stated (SO, 18 September) that the "basic problem' in Ireland was *British colonialism, which had taken a hold on Ireland for several hundred years, and had encouraged sectarian divisions for decades, betore the 'Surely" , I wrote, 'the great problem of the Irish working class is that forcible partition took it into the imperialist epoch with one of the most suggests) equate them with the South as British socialists have the right to basic tasks of the bourgeois revolu- African Boers. I did not say they are put forward a socialist programme tion - national independence - not for Ireland that goes beyond support I said that they were 'not an op- for the nationalist resistance and the I attacked the claim in Socialist pressed national minority but in fact call for British withdrawal and Irish Forum (a magazine published by SO) have been given privileges over a long that Ireland has had its "bourgeois period by Britain to encourage sec- As internationalists, we have not a revolution"? Comrade Denham tarianism'. I said this to stress the right but a duty to learn about, and defends that formulation, saying that fact that for 200 years Loyalist reac- discuss with other Marxists, the 'the Republic of Ireland is a tion was armed, encouraged, and methods of struggle and the prodeveloped, relatively advanced strengthened with economic favours gramme of Marxism in all countries. capitalist state... integrated into But comrade Denham is confusing European capitalism independently May I call in evidence the words of things. My argument with comrade of Britain through the EEC' , and is a British communist who I believe did O'Mahony had nothing to do with "definitely not a "puppet" try to get to grips with the Irish ques- the programme of Irish socialists, it bourgeoisie or a colony of Britain?. tion, William Paul? His pamphlet had to do with the programme of *The Irish Crisis 1921' (available in British socialists; it had nothing to do the Cork Workers' Club Historical with whether we go beyond the deReprint Series) speaks of the extreme- mand for Irish self-determination, Let us leave aside comrade ly reactionary nature of the Ulster but whether we go as far as that. Denham's reference to the bastard 26 capitalist class, and the way it used I said that British socialists could county state as 'the Republic' , an in- not introduce a demand for a sult to his Irish readers which reflects He explained that class divisions federal form of government into his apparent insensitivity to na- would prevail at the end of the day. their own programme as a precondiFor the Protestant workers, he wrote, tion to supporting Irish selfNow, is the 26 counties a relatively *it was Carson who demonstrated determination. I attacked comrade advanced capitalist state'? In that political movements only yield to O'Mahony's phrase, (SO, 10 April) economic terms, we must qualify this force. When these workers move that he was 'in favour of British by saying that while it may be ad- against capitalism, the revolutionary withdrawal, but as part of a political vanced' relative to colonies or semi- movement of Ulster will have good solution which actually allows selfcolonies elsewhere, it remains reason for thanking Carson for his determination'; that is, only in conbackward relative to capitalist junction with a federal Ireland Paul thus recognised that in a policy; that is, not unconditionally.
And are we not obliged as Marxists revolutionary situation, the to say why Ireland is one of the most militarism of Protestant workers economically backward countries in could backfire on their capitalist Europe? Is it not because its masters. I believe that such a I did not say, as comrade Denham economic development was choked, suggests, that British socialists must throttled and manipulated by Bri But the fact remains that since *support the nationalist resistance 1921 sectarianism has deepened; to- and its demand for selfOf course. And I used the word day, with no revolutionary situation, determination uncritically'. That was 'colonialism' not because I was the Protestant workers are by and 'conflating' it with imperialism as large behind their extreme right-wing My point was that British socialists comrade Denham says, but because near-fascist leaders, who speak for had to make the unconditional deIreland was subject to Britain's mand for self-determination their economic domination long before the own; support it not simply because it epoch of imperialism, and this has is being advanced by Republicans or left its mark on Ireland until this day nationalists, but because it is a princi— not only in the form of economic These leaders, with working-class ple without which the international backwardness, but in the form of support, have thwarted British at- working class will never go forward, tempts to impose a capitalist solution without which international workingPolitics reflect economics, but not in the north, not because they are class unity will never be achieved. directly. That is why in 'relatively ad- "very effective anti-imperialists, but Let us argue about the programme vanced" Ireland, the question of na- because Loyalism, that reactionary for Irish socialists. But first, let us as. tional independence (in the political and crisis-ridden frankenstein created British socialists get our own prosense) has not been resolved; in by Britain to maintain its control of gramme correct. Does it include the 'relatively backward' semi-colonies in Ireland, has gone out of British con- unconditional demand for Irish selfAfrica and South America, it has. determination, or is comrade May I ask again the question that My difference with SO is that they O'Mahony right to place conditions comrade Denham ignored? Has 'one believe that there is something inof the most basic tasks of the herently 'anti-imperialist' about the bourgeois revolution — national in- northern Protestants. I say that, until dependence' been carried out in the Protestant workers are split from Ireland or not? And is partition the their Loyalist leaders — and I doubt result of British colonialism, or (as whether anything short of a revolu"Socialist Forum' claims) of a 'split tionary situation can do that - they Letters are welcome: send to PO are attacking Thatcher, the 2. On the position of the northern Hillsborough deal, and the RUC, Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 300 Protestants, comrade Denham has from an entirely reactionary stand- havefo cut them. J1017 TUl may misquoted me. I did not call them (settlers' or or can-ter 13, Comrade Denham asks do we A plastic bullet Simon Pirani Revolutionary Party continues the disagreement on Ireland.
by Britain?
Protestants.
socialists towards Ireland, each point.
native bourgeoisie emerged'. RUC block Loyalist march "agents of British imperialism' self-determination?" religious sectarianism, Unconditional possibility could still be realised.
not my point.
the Ulster capitalist class.
Split on it?
Too much Irish blood has already been spilled because of British socialists' failure to stand firm on this principle.
words or less, please, or