Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

A sense of identi

Socialist Organiser no. 287, 9 October 1986 · scan p. 7 · about 1,485 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

direct election to the Presidency.

He was a cautious old-style politician in the Vargista tradition, and Governor of the important state of Minas Gerais. Never an open supporter of the military, he helped found the short-lived PP party in 1979-80 — a party known as the bankers' party — before joining the PMDB.

His vice-presidential candidate was Sarney, who had recently resigned as president of the pro-government party, the PDS, to join the Democratic The whole affair was designed to ensure the original military project of a controlled return to civilian rule without disruption.

It worked. Neves' victory in the electoral college was greeted with wild applause. His sudden death before he could take office led to incredible scenes of mass mourning, and Neves' elevation into the pantheon of Brazilian greats.

But with Neves' death, Sarney, But the new unions also reflected the concentration of an industrial proletariat determined to find its own method of representation, and, with the Pl, its own voice in national The new unions had to contend not only with the hostility of the Government and the traditional parties, but also with the opposition of the Brazilian Communist Party.

The Brazilian CP, once the largest of Latin American CPs, had declined over the years under the impact of repression and illegality, In 1980 the veteran CP leader Prestes was allowed by the military regime to return to Brazil, only to find himself almost immediately sacked when Brazilian 'EuroCommunists' took over the party and forged an alliance with the pMDB.

When the new unions formed a national trade union congress, the CUT, in 1983, it was the first central trade union body since the military dissolved the CGT in 1964. But the demise. The party is still rather illformed: its ideology is vaguely socialist, but it has no clearly defined programme.

The party has many fractional groups within its ranks: various Trotskyist groups, ex-guerillas, Maoists, left Christians, social democrats, etc. This can cause confusion. Once one of the fractions in Salvador robbed a bank to send money to Nicaragua, thus allowing the opponents of the PT to have a field day.

The PT is not yet a really national party, but still very much based around Sao Paulo and among sectors of the intellectuals and professionals.

It is beginning to get some support hands of a large and armed class of landowners who have always run their properties like fiefs.

Emergence

In 1985, 160 people died in clashes over land. Agrarian reform is an explosive issue in Brazil. And so far it has mainly been the Church which has pushed for a radical agrarian reform.

Although still fragile, the PT is the best hope for the emergence of a combative, class-based politics in Brazil which can offer a socialist alternative. And in Lula, the metalworkers' union leader, they have the first authentic working-class leaders to have emerged in Brazil for decades.

But the task facing the PT is an uphill one. The long tradition Brazil of leaving politics to 'them' is deeply engrained throughout society.

They face, for example, the problem of Brizola, whose socialist rhetoric and popularity is still in the authoritarian populist tradition which Vargas established with the Brazilian Labour Party. Brizola's party has attracted many socialists.

If there is mass discontent looking for a more radical alternative, then Brizola is likely to be the main beneficiary of such discontent. In addition, Sarney, after a period of seeming to be a lame-duck President, emerged as an immensely popular figure when he launched the 'Cruzado Plan' to stop the drift to hyperinflation and later a development plan promising growth and la whole range of social programmes.

Postponed

The Cruzado plan froze all prices, but it also froze wages after a wage rise of 8 per cent to all workers and 16 per cent on the minimum wage. But the plan was so popular than a whole series of strikes, including a planned general strike, had to be postponed by the Cul. The cur had to content itself with fairly mutfled criticisms of the plan, although one trade union study claimed that the plan meant a real cut in wages of about 20 per cent.

The Conclat gave uncritical support to the plan.

Politically, too, there has been a growing tendency towards the emergence of 'charismatic' non-party political figures. Sarney himself seems to be becoming one of these.

Other indications of this trend were the victory of ex-President Quadros in Sao Paulo, the emergence Payman Rezai continues his The change of course from multicultural to the new ethnic strategy was facilitated by the publication of Lord Scarman's report on the Brixton 'disorders' According to the ethnicist analysis, second generation British blacks are 'caught between the cultural expectation of their parents (first generation migrants) and the social demands of the wider society. The young often feel that they do not fit in either culture... . This search for identity and ethnic distinctiveness is a direct response to racism. Ethnicity itself is a 'sense' of this identity.

Scarman's report tied in neatly with this ethnic framework - further developing the idea of ethnic need and problems which now replace racial disadvantage.

Along with the Home Affairs Committee report (1981) the main different ethnic needs were identified. These were based on racist categorisations of the Asian and West Indian communities, on the grounds of group psychology, customs, family structure, inherent disabilities.

Face.

Grants were allocated for ethnic groups through local authorities and the definition of ethnicity was widened to include a variety of national and religious groups, e.g. Italians, Jess, Moslems, Chinese.

Sivanandan argues that the ensuing 'scramble' for grants led to sharpened ethnic rivalry, which was further developed into 'institutionalised ethnicity' by the Left Labour Councils. Only a few genuinely anti-racist campaigns came out of this e.g. against deportations, police harassmant and racist attaicks.

Scarman's analysis rests on a socio-psycological' view of racism and racial disadvantage, but Sivanandan argues that this view is actually more "socio-biological?

The reality of racism, for Scarman, is a matter of subjective feelings, perceptions, attitudes and beliefs. So young blacks have a 'sense of rejection' and the Asian community has 'a belief' that the police do not protect them from 'alleged' racist attacks.

The main effect of Scarman's 'findings' was to shift the terrain of the struggle against racism from the political one to the 'personal" one: institutional racism was a 8 2.

matter of black 'perception' fri racism one of "prejudice' The acceptance of Scarman's findings paved the way for Racism Awareness Training (RAT). RAT has its roots in the Human Awareness Training (HAT) courses at an American military base in Florida. The course was the military establishment's response to the black riots in the American cities in the late 1960s. It was meant to uphold the principles of individual dignity, worth and equal opportunity.

The instructores brief at the Defense Race Relations Institute was to teach 'minority' history and cultures and explain personal The race relations aspect of AT emerged after the publication f the 'radical' Kerner Commission port on the riots. A further US sport in 1970 developed Kerner's leas and defined racism as any ititude, action or institutional ructure which subordinates a per-. on or a group because of his or neir colour'. From this it conclued that to fight racism involved hanging the behaviour of whites nd increasing the capabilities of on-white groups' • This is referred › in Britain as tackling racial disdvantage. The report put the main sponsibility on the white populaon.

These two reports generated a hole plethora of literature in ducation, psychology and the hurches to tackle the task of chaning white behaviour. Models for icial awareness training of teachers 1 integrated schools were developd. These involved making trainees ware of 'covert' and 'overt' racism nd how whites benefit from this: ither trends in the development f RAT argued for the creation of new white consciousness based n the awareness of cultural, instiational and personal racism all at nce. Cultural racism had to be kamined in language, books and le media. Confrontation techiques' were offered as a good way f challenging personal and instiational racism.

Others like Judy Katz at Olkaoma University argued that racism as a white problem which it was its own interests to overcome. ccording to the Commission on lental Health (1965) racism was lentified as the number one menil health problem. In the US: 'Its estructive effects severely cripple le growth and development of illions of our citizens... * Accorng to the "latest' research, racism as shown to be a 'psychological, roblem. deeply imbedded in hite people from a very early age ›th on a conscious and an uninscious level.

For Katz racism is part of the illective consicousness of white merica - there's no getting away om it.

----- pull-quotes -----

review of an article by A. Sivanandan in 'Race and Class'

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 287

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →