Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Lesson in history

Socialist Organiser no. 288, 16 October 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 847 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

WHAT a weak historical analyst is Simon Pirani! In his vision of history the world never changes.

Ireland was a British colony 300 years ago; it remains a British colony today. To suggest anything else is an insult to Irish As an Irish reader, Jim Denham's remarks offend me less than Simon's.

Simply watching Ireland as a child in the long summer holidays, I had sufficient intelligence to notice dramatic changes in the 60's and 70's. New industry and housing were just some ot the signs that Ireland was a developAnd we must not analyse the world when considering Ireland. We must put it in a European context only.

The fact that it is more advanced than some 'independent nations' in Protestants lined üp against a wall the third world is not relevant to Simon. His point is that partition is a This is virtually impossible while working class made any more procolonial by-product with the same gress than the Irish, for all their narelevance today as it had in 1921, green or orange — as paramount. tional independence? Have the splits when you were lucky to find a toilet Simon's inability to understand the caused by British Imperialism in Ireland, let alone a horse (no,an historical process leads inevitably to disapeared from the minds of the the conclusion that Irish Nationalism is a seamless robe and self- Are the Turks who complain about determination the bottom line to Bulgarisation in Bulgaria, merely the which socialists must give their un- dupes of the long dead Ottoman emquestioning support. John pire? Is the nationalist completion of This is nonsense. Even in 1921 O Mahoney is thus mistaken to pro- "the bourgeois revolution in Ireland' much of British Capitalism (sup- pose federalism - as federalism going to guarantee the rights of both ported by the Liberal Party) would means conditions on troops-out and communities — or present the prohave been happy to see the back of the Six Counties. Unfortunately the If you answer there questions other half and the Protestant majori- is a principle without which the inter- honestly you will see that selfty in Ulster were willing to threaten national working class will never go determination is not so simple, civil war to stop the setting up of a I ask Simon, have the Sri Lankan The British State, amidst and impeding post-war economic crisis, decided on a short term solution in an effort to restart business as usual.

_As for today, even if Ireland is relatively backward in Europe this is. not necessarily related to partition.

Italy has been united since the 1860's, but Southern Italy is still much more backward than Northern Italy and at least as backward as Southern Ireland. Which big bad wolf is to Ah, but national independence is cone of the most basic requirements of the bourgeois revolution' . Did you know that no bourgeois progress can take place in the 26 counties? - you have to have 32. I suppose South Korea has not had a bourgeois revolution as it only has possession of Simon's history gets worse when it comes to the protestants. Despite the lack of historical evidence to show that Catholics and Protestants could unite on the national question, Simon thinks that 'in a revolutionary situation the militarism of protestant workers could backfire on their protestant and catholic workers?

igh DRUG use is linked to unemployment, according to a recent report in the British Medical Journal.

Two doctors in Edinburgh conclude from a survey of drug-users in their area that high levels Oil right!

UNEMPLOYMENT is still high, homelessness is booming, and the Health Service is more and more strapped for cash. But some people are doing well.

Profits have now reached their highest level since 1964. The rate of return on capital for British companies in 1985 was 11.9%, Profit rates declined steadily but/slowly of unemployment serve foster drug use"

More than half the unemployed young I men they surveyed said they used heroin, cocaine, or LSD, as against one third of those in work.

through the 1960s, and crashed to a low of 4.2% in 1975. They increased sharply in 1976 and '77 under Labour government austerity policies, then crashed again in 1978-81.

Since then profits have been improving thanks to the combined effect of North Sea Oil superprofits and the Tories' "assault on the working class, are being serialised in Murdoch's scab Sunday Times, where most trade union activists will miss them.

In one passage of the memoirs he gives an interesting MacGregor'seye-view of the TUC leaders.

"L found it quite amusing that in the meetings readers. we had I should be sitting there with them and we should all be talking around trying to find a solution, not so much to the strike but to the problem created by Arthur Scargill. They understood the nature of the difficulty just as well as I did" ing capitalist economy.

Now do you wonder that the TUC leaders never delivered on their pious promises of sup port for the miners?

both see the national question

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 288

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →