Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Crushing workers to sustain the American dream

Socialist Organiser no. 288, 16 October 1986 · scan p. 9 · Martin Thomas · about 686 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Martin Thomas reviews oners of the American Dream' by Mike Davis (Verso, £7.95).

Mike Davis paints a frightening picture of what capitalism is doing to the US working class.

Businesses have shut down unionised operations in the North and East, and shifted to non-union working in the South and West. Unionisation in the private sector has dropped from 35% in 1960 to 15% in 1985.

Increasingly, bosses are able to divide the workforce into two segments: a minority of well-paid, highly-qualified workers, kept loyal by relatively high pay and good career prospects; and a majority whose real wages have been steadily falling since the early 1970s.

We have "the masses of the working poor huddled around their K-Marts and Taiwanese imports" while the top 20% or so provide a growing consumer demand for *travel and designer clothes, posh restaurants, home computers, and fancy sports cars"

The trade union leaders have collaborated in their own downfall, with shortsighted policies. Talk about unionising the South was always just talk, and there is not even talk any more.

The union leaders are concerned above all to keep their dues-paying base in their traditional areas of strength. To try to keep that base or at least to halt its erosion there is almost no concession that they will not offer. Politically, they are tied to Cold War conservatism, The union leaders policy does not work in its own terms. Some of the businesses offered 'give backs' have simply used the cash to set up new non-union operations! And the mass of the working class has been abandoned by the union leaders.

The self-eclipse of the labour movement leaves the political arena open for domination by the well-off middle classes - the 'yuppie right wing. These are the people behind Reagan (participation voting by workers in the US is, as Davis points out, extremely low) -and increasingly they pull the Democratic Party their way, too Davis prefaces his analysis of the US today with a historical overview. Why is there no labour or socialist party in the US, even a reformist one?

The traditional answer to this question points to three factors: the westward movement of the US's frontier in the 19th century, which meant that every worker could reasonably hope to become a small independent farmer or business person; the relative wealth of the US, as the world's greatest industrial power after World War 1; and, at the point where the first two factors were breaking down, and the emergence of a labour party was possible, in the 1930s, the criminal role of the Communist Party in channelling the best militants behind Roosevelt and the Democratic Party.

Davis claims to offer a new answer, but it seems to me that what he really does is develop a strand in the old answer. He stresses the role of ethnic divisions in the US working class, and the consequences of repeated failures by the labour movement to overcome those divisions. Today is another example of such failure: for the better-off minority of the working class are mostly Anglo and white, while there is a big proportion of Hispanics and blacks among the worse-off.

Davis rips apart the arguments of those socialists who want to work in the Democratic Party, but ends up, oddly, semi-endorsing Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition.

He sees the future in cataclysmic terms: terrible economic crisis in Latin America, the Far East, and the US, caused by the inability of the increasingly pauperised working class to provide enough consumer demand while production expands; and some sort of vast common rebellion of the peoples of Latin America and the Hispanic and black people in the US.

About that I'm not so sure: capitalism can in fact expand for long periods on the basis of very limited mass working class consumption, and economic crises do not usually produce political responses in so tidy a fashion. But for a caustic indictment of the swinishness of Reagan's America, and of the pigheadedness of US labour's current leaders, this book is hard to 15p plus post from PO Box 823 London SE15 LABOUR:

1986

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 288

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →