Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

MARXISM Good and bad sides

Socialist Organiser no. 288, 16 October 1986 · scan p. 10 · Martin Thomas · about 549 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no 288 16 October 1986 page 10 N THE last column I examined Karl Marx's analysis of freetrade, free-enterprise, individualist ideology - the intellectual bedrock of Toryism.

What this ideology does is to take the concepts of 'freedom', equality, and so on generated by relations in the capitalist marketplace, elevate them into eternal moral absolutes, and then proclaim capitalism to be the ideal system as judged by those moral values.

It ignores the fact that those moral values are not eternal at all, but products of capitalism ('freedom' means very different things in different societies); and it takes the formal, legal equality of worker and capitalist in the market as representing the essence of the situation, rather than the oppression and exploitation of the worker in the workplace.

In fact - so Marx argues - the "freedom' and 'equality' in the market place and the oppression and exploitation in the workplace are two sides of the same coin. They both arise from labour power - people's capacity to work, to produce, to create - becoming a commodity, something bought and sold.

On the one side there is a class, the working class, with no way to live except by selling its labour power; on the other hand there is a class, the capitalist class, which in return for whatever modest wage is just sufficient to maintain the working class at its customary living standard gets the entire productive power of society.

Piecemeal

What distinguishes Marx's appreach from many less radical socialists is that he analyses capitalism as a whole. In contrast the essence of what Marx called "bourgeois socialism' is to split up capitalist society into its various aspects, and to propose piecemeal reforms for each particular evil.

They consider production - in abstraction from the fact it is production for exchange, not for need and find that the different. 'factors of production', capital and labour, are 'natural necessities' They further find it natural that part of the resulting revenue goes to the workers, part to investment, and part to reward the capitalists.

So what do they complain ahout? That the capitalists' income seems too high, the workers' too ow; that the capitalists are too authoritarian. And so they propose wealth taxes, higher wages, worker-director schemes...

Again and again, their idea is to cut away the bad sides' of capitalism, its 'unacceptable face', vitie lene fattis that the good tact is that the sides' and the 'bad sides' are inextricably interwoven. They are part of one system.

And indeed, as Marx put it, "It is the bad side that produces the movement which makes history, by providing a struggle". What socialists need to look towards is not capitalism minus its horrors, but the class struggle generated by those horrors.

Oscar Wilde put the same idea in ivid language: "The virtues of the poor may be readily admitted, and are much to be regretted.

We are often told that the poor re grateful for charity. Some of them are, no doubt, but the best mong the poor are never grateful.

They are ungrateful, iscontented, disobedient and rebellious. They are quite right to so" Sharansky Anatoly (Nathan) Sharansky spent nine years in a USSR jail because he wanted to g to Israel. Nikolai Baranov wide. Anatoly (Nathan)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 288

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →