Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Kronstadt was proletarian

Socialist Organiser no. 289, 23 October 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 590 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

That Bough, who accused me of except that 1 also mentioned that It is a traditional Stalinist and stressing the role of Trotsky in the full and exhaustive publication of degenerate Trotskyist ploy to engaging in personalities, when I suppression of Kronstadt and thus the personnel, naming names, was accuse anyone who opposes the done by the sailors at the time, in party line of being petit bourdid no such thing, should now turn the publications of the Kronstadt geois. Thus the workers of Budaround and claim that I am "incap- Soviet; and mentioned a number pest were petit bourgeois, as of able of reading what people actu- of people who have subsequently course is Solidarnose, as were the ally write" is rich (Letters, SO 284). written on the issue after reading East Berlin workers in 1953; and so for Bough it appears were the was the first time the question was workers of the Vyborg Quarter and raised, but he mentioned that date. there was one sailor who had been referred to no earlier debate, and allowed to retire, he had already talked of an alliance then and now; been over retiring age at the time of and if he doesn't think that the the October Revolution, and had plain wordage of his letter was to been wounded severely, and had accuse Ciliga and Serge of being - been allowed to return home. The perhaps unconscious - Stalinist authors of the "Cahiers" of the Letters are welcome: send to PO agents then he is incapable of read- Kronstadt Commune dug him out Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 300 as the only example of a sailor who words or less, please, or we may He quite rightly says that I only "had been posted elsewhere" they instanced a government decree:

change!

interest in disarmament must now rethink their priorities and place the campaign against Star Wars and for a nuclear test ban which would seriously hamper its development at the top Here we have the key to understanding the Morning Star: the campaign against Polaris, Trident, Cruise, and the US bases may, it concedes, be "very important" But the real task now is for all of us to fall in line behind the Russian bureaucracy and it's latest set of "peace proposals"

Colas and net instence policy, is all very well but the Morning Star would much prefer us to become a diplomatic pressure group for Mr Yes, it's reassuring to see that some The Morning Star may have gone tabloid but it's still just as dishonest, Some good activists still buy it, of course, because it seems to be on the side of the working class and often gives sympathetic coverage to strikes.

You can seem like a really rotten sectarian if you attack it or if you point out that it is only kept going by massive orders from the governments On Wednesday, though, the Morning Star did give me a momentary shock. An article entitled "Stop interfering" turned out to be about Afghanistan. Had the Morning Star finally plucked up the courage to voice some criticism of Russian foreign policy? No! The "interference" referred to was that Andrew Wiard, Report.

He denies that he said that 1938 this evidence. ing what he himself writes.

could find. In tact I forgot to mention that the sailors of Kronstadt.

LAURENS OTTER, Salop.

have to cut them. of the agenda"

paratively short period of time"

Gorbachev.

things never change.

predictable and boring as ever. of Russia and Eastern Europe.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 289

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →