Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[John O'Mahony reviews 'Hungary 1956' Spcialist: Organiser no…]

Socialist Organiser no. 289, 23 October 1986 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,885 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

John O'Mahony reviews 'Hungary 1956' Spcialist: Organiser no. 289:23 Oetober 1986 page 8 The defeated Hungarian Revolution of 1956 is to the struggle for direct workers' power in the states where Stalinist parties rule, what the Paris Commune of 1871 was to the anti-capitalist revolution.

Of the Commune Engels said: *That was the dictatorship of the proletariat" - and Marx and he set about analysing and learning from it. Hungary in 1956 was what Trotskyists had been calling the anti-bureaucratic "political' revolution for two decades. It vindicated what Trotsky had outlined as the necessary programme for communist revolutionaries in the USSR, from 1935, and what some of the post-war Trotskyists had adapted and applied to the new Stalinist states: the progamme for an anti-bureaucratic revolution to overthrow the mis-rule and the privileges of the Stalinist bureaucracy, and to dismantle and destroy the totalitarian state machine which serves it.

There had been many revolts against bureaucratic rule in the USSR itself. In 1953 there were the strikes and uprisings in East Germany. In 1956 in Poland there was the Posnan uprising.

None of these, however, had reached the stage of creating an alternative power structure. In Hungary, the combination of internal C HILL/LL Hungary 1956', by Bill Lomax. Published by Motive.

£2.95 from all good bookshops.

explosive It demonstrated that the bureaucracy leadership struggles around could not tolerate independent indestalınisation, an intense Hungarıan itiatives; simultaneously it showed national sense of grievance against that the distance between the first Russian overlordship, and direct ac- criticism of the Stalinist bureaucratic tion by the working class, led to a system and demands for its end is exmovement which did create the tremely short, precisely because of outline of an alternative political the arbitrary and unnecessary 'funcsystem of working class self-rule.

In fact the Hungarian workers tion' of the bureaucracy. Even within a phase of destalinisacreated a specifically working class tion, which many then took to be an counterposed it to both capitalism system of workers' councils, and bureaucracy, it resorted to ruthless evolutionary 'thawing' of the and the Stalinist bureaucratic system. force, and felt obliged to smash and They were defeated and crushed by destroy every vestige of the indepenthe Stalinist Russian army, as had dent working class organisations that of Versailles. But in the Central been the Paris orkers by the army had begun to grow in 1956. Workers' Council if Budapest they National recreted the classic form of workng class democracy, the lineal continuation of the Commune, of the Russian made Hungary exceptionally exSoviets in the pre-Stalinist era, and to plosive - but when the explosion an extent of the Hungarian Soviet came, it resulted in specific working Republic of 1919. class types of organisation and Before Hungary a writer like Isaac weapons of struggle, such as the Deutscher could base himself on the general strike. Conditions specific to social analysis which Trotsky made in Hungary and Poland created the conthe late 1930s of bureaucratised ditions where the workers were no Russia, and counterpose that analysis longer prepared to be ruled, and the to Trotsky's political concusions local bureaucrats were no longer able after 1935. He argued that a political to rule (though the Russian revolution was not necessary, and moreover that there was no rooted antagonism within Russian society, or within the other Stalinist states, that would produce a decisive confrontation between the bureaucratic caste and the working class. There was no equivalent to the rule.

worker-bourgeois antagonism, and consequently there would be social progress, an easing of tensions and conflicts, and, ultimately, a reflect adjustment of the level of political democracy to the advancing level of technology. The bureaucracy did not come into fundamental conflict with the potential for growth of the economy, but could adjust — consequently there would be no political revolution.

Stalinist ings, crippled by party 'legalism'.

Others, regarding the Stalinist system as an utterly reactionary system in which the workers were little different from slaves, had also dismissed the working class under Stalinism as a potentially revolutionary class.

The Hungarian Revolution refuted all of them. It raised up in real life and, in defiance of Stalinist might, fought for an alternative working class political system to bureaucratic rule. Replicating the Russian Soviets of 1917, it showed they had been no accident or aberration.

It demonstrated that the uneveness of developments in different Stalinist states made impossible any overall bureaucratic control except by military force, and created the possibility of explosive interactions.

broken by the Revolution itself' (p.197). These ideas originated in Lenin's 'What is to be Done?' and 'the development of the totalitarian party-state was carried even further by Lenin's successor, Stain, under whose rule the party was turned into a mere instrument of the Stalinist State power.' But Lomax himself brings out clearly the fatal role of the vacillating and unsure policy of those who found themselves reluctant leaders of a revolution. It surely follows that a different type of leadership might have made the difference between the defeat which occurred and the victory which was possible. Certainly the revolt could have been spread to Poland and perhaps beyond No doubt the national oppression. A revolutionary organisation which had a clear programme and trained cadres involved with the masses might very well have changed the course of events. Such a conclusion flows logically and inescapably from the picture Lomax himself paints of what was wrong, what was missing. But Lomax believes that any such party would necessarily be substitutionalist'. Indeed he says that the bureaucrats were able and willing to mode of operation and the goal of all rule); but the classic working class political parties are necessrily in concharacter of the Hungarian Revolu- flict with the self-liberation of the tion is proof that its essence is not workng class, which exercises its selflimited to states where national op- rule directly through its control of the pression is adjoined to bureaucratic factories. It has as little need to 'take power' once it has control of the facBill Lomax's chronicle of the ac- tories as it had need in Russia in Octivity of the Hungarian working class tober 1917 to appoint a 'People's argument the revolutionary working in 1956 establishes beyond serious Tsar' Conceptions like "taking power' class nature and significance of the relate to an entirely different system. Hungarian Revoution. He is especial- Control is power; power other than counter-revolution carried out by the ly clear in bringing out just what the substitution for the working class's self-control develops towards seltstooges meant in real terms to the Russians and their local allies and direct control. It is not at all clear how the difworkers. He describes how the means ferent factories which are controlled of production were literally seized by the workers would interact. from the control of the working cass. Through a form of market? Or if Also valuable is his description of the there is to be planning, how is it to be Communist Party opposition group- organised? This reaction against the Stalinist His conclusions (chapter 7) experience leads to a denial of any however, are weak. He defines the positive role to any revolutionary sum of the activity of the post-1956 Kadar CP as 'substituting its own party. Lomax seems to believe that the direct class interests of the Hungarian "power-political interests" for 'the historically unique. He does not refer workers'. The main fault of the op- to the Russian or other experiences. positional 'Communists' was that He substitutes fairy tales about they were a half-way house between Bolshevik substitutionism for any imthese two. Rakosi before 1956 and plicit or explicit reference to the exKadar after it were 'substitutionist. perience of how the Bolshevik Party This in turned flowed from loyalty interacted with the spontaneous acto Leninist conceptions of the revolu- tivity of the Russian working class in tionary party and its relationship with 1917. And the identification of the the masses', in which 'can be seen the Stalinist state machine and its purgcontinuity between the orthodox ed, broken and careerist-ridden parMarxist-Leninist idea of the Stalinist ty' with Lenin's ideas in 'What is to party leadership and the revisionist be Done?' is simply nonsense on the eliefs of Imre Nagy and the refor- factual level.

mist oppostion, a continuity which The Stalinist state grew out of the was only challenged and eventually isolation of the Russian Revolution revolutionary state would have been set up. The experience of Spain, where in the Republican areas, from July 1936 to mid-1937, the workers had real control, even though workers' councils did not emerge, proves tht. The political vacuum was filled by elements hostile to workers' control. The anarchists who did not believe any state power was compatible with liberation wound up accepting the need for some state, of the impossibility of a cavuum if fascism was not to be allowed to create its own state - and opted for the counterrevolutionary Popular Front. The gains of the working class in the Republican areas were liquidated.

Things can only be otherwise if there are no enemies of working class revolution, internal or external, and if conditions in society are such that no state power is necessary. Lomax ends with a quotation from SaintSimon: "The government of persons is replaced by the administration of things" . But this relates necessarily to the fully communist societymore advanced materially than even the most advanced societies today. Between capitalism and communism there is transition, which Marxists understand as the dictatorship of the proletariat.

'Semi-state'

Certainly this is a 'semi-state' ', ditfering centrally from all other states in being rule of the majority over the minority, and therefore direct rule, needing no bureaucracy. But equally certainly such a transitional stage is essential and unavoidable. It is rooted in the material conditions of capitalist society - conditions that can only be changed after the revolution. The attempt by revolutionaries to avoid it will produce conditions where the 'sttae' vacuum is filled by anti-working class forces. Either that or revolutionaries will never dare act until all conditions are propitious and until an immediate transition to a situation where only things are administered is possible. With this revolution, in at least the most ad- paralysing purism, only simuaneous vanced countries would allow what Lomax envisages to be the first step.

Indeed, sadly lacking this very important book is any sense of internationalism, either in terms of international perspectives for the Hungarian Revolution of 1956, or even in the account of the October Revolution and its degeneration. Everything is simply read off from the organisational conteption which Lomax attributes to Lenin and the Bolsheviks, and he ignores the international revolutionary perspectives of the Bolsheviks, the failure of which was the precondition of the Stalinist degeneration.

The conclusions of anarcho-syndicalism are as futile for revolutionary politics now (even when presented as 'conclusions' from the experience of Stalinism - as they were in the Russian Revolution and the Spanish Civil War. But at least they allow Lomax to depict vivdly the tremendous revolutionary capacity developed by the Hungarian commune of 1956. And that is an important achievement. Read Lomax's book.

Next week's SO will include "The Lessons of Hungary' and a review of Peter Fryer's 'Hungarian Tragedy'.

Scan page 9

IDUSTRIAL SEALINK NK By

----- pull-quotes -----

HUNGARI 1956 Well worth reading

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 289

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →