The making of the Jewish state
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
1 Spcialist Organiser no 289 28:October 1986 page 9 the Israeli Broadcasting ithority. It is therefore likely to dismissed by the left as ionist propaganda'. It ouldn't be.
Zionism is a term that has now ased to have any very clear mean5. It originally meant a Jewish litical movement aiming to set up a wish state in Palestine. The onists were a minority of Jews until ill after Hitler took power in Gerany. With the founding and consolidain of the state of Israel in 1948 and ter, the original 'Zionism' was congned to history.
What does 'Zionism' mean today? he right of the Jewish state of Israel exist, even if you would like to see radically changed? In that sense robably a majority of politically ware people in the world, vastly ough their outlooks differ, are lionist. . In that sense, too, Socialist ganiser is 'Zionist' But the 'Zionism' that is denouncI on the left is not some vast amorlous body. It is far narrower than at. In practice it means the lionist hard core of activists and ¡thusiasts, that is the Jews. - except that it is political hostility to almost an entire people, and on a matter of life and death.
*Pillar of Fire' tells a story which should make every anti-Zionist' socialist who sees it examine his or her conscience. For the facts do not lie. And though inevitably the story told by 'Pillar of Fire' is the story as seen by the Jews, and the series is thus "biased', beyond that the facts are straightforward.
The late Isaac Deutscher compared Israel to a 'liferaft state' - the Jews who have survived the Holocaust fled there. The tragedy was and is that there were people there already.
Hitler — the most terrible enemy in the history of the Jews - made the state of Israel. In the '30s hundreds of thousands of Jews went to Palestine - because no other country would have them.
The great American democracy, whose Statue of Liberty invites the world to 'give me your poor, your huddled masses' , could not find room for Jewish refugees even to save their lives. A shipload of Jewish refugees crossed the Atlantic but the few hundred passengers could not get permission to land in the USA — or anywhere else on the two continents.
They returned to Europe on the eve of World War 2. Most of them perished.
There are many pictures of the millions of Jews of Eastern Europe going about their daily lives -trading in the see ho atmost alr of them destined to die soon at the hands of Hitler's racist maniacs.
In 1937 a Commission of Enquiry was set up by the British government which then ruled Palestine, and it recommended that Palestine be partitioned, giving the Jews their own state. It was shelved because of Arab opposition. The Arab opposition was understandable enough: but maybe if the Jewish state had been set up, the Jews of Europe would have had a refuge, and millions might have survived. Instead the Jews of Europe were trapped on a continent which soon offered them nothing but death.
Palestine itself came close to being a death-trap for the Jews there. If the Germans and Italians had won the battle in the Western Desert in 1942, mid-'41. In Poland, the Jews had been treated with great brutality and herded into a ghetto in Warsaw: the Jews the Nazis encountered in the USSR were slaughtered immediately.
Then came the extermination camps. All in all, nearly six million Jews died.
Presumably the next episode will show what happened when the few survivors of the death camps tried to pick up their lives again. In Poland, many were attacked and driven out: they fled, mostly to Palestine.
The terrible truth is that Zionist propaganda' had all its work - and much more - done for it by the virulent anti-semites and those who either connived with them or looked away. 'Pillar of Fire' made the telling point that though the Allied airforces had control of the air over Europe from mid 1944 and hit innumerable airports, depots, munitions factories, etc. (not to speak of cities), and though what was happening in the death camps was known to the Allied governments, no attempt was made to destroy the death factories or the railway lines leading to them.
Watch what's left of the series.
Scan page 10
OF MARXISM ungary '56: work gainst Stalinism