Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Marxist method

Socialist Organiser no. 289, 23 October 1986 · scan pp. 10–11 · Martin Thomas · about 2,130 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser. no 289 23 October 1986 page 10 In this column so far I've dealt, really, with just two basic issues. I looked at human nature, and argued that it was god-given. Other societies have difslavery and exploitation.

These two issues, I think, illustrate the Marxist method of dogma or a set of articles of faith.

them. circumstances generated ano Liberal A classical liberal thinker would say that 'freedom' is a good thing - the same eternal concept of freedom is a good thing in the same way, for the same reason, in all times and places. The liberal would gauge the progress of society by the measuring-rod of that concept of freedom in his or her head.

Marx would reply that this just comes down to measuring all human history by the standards of an idealised capitalist society. Capitalist freedom - free enterprise was progressive against feudal restrictions. But it is also unfreedom for the working class and in the course of class struggle it will be replaced by a new sort of freedom - by workers' liberty.

So Marxists do not look at society statically, as a snapshot without any past or future. They try to study things in their development, to understand them as part of a historic:| 'moving picture' In ott i ways, too, Marxists try to und stand society as a whole, not jus liecemeal.

Split up Orthodox social science splits itself up into many specialisations. Economists study laws of supply and demand, but say that questions of fundamental economic institutions are outside their scope. Political theorists talk about this or that modification, but explain that the basic economic underpinning are beyond their remit. And so on. Somehow the basic issues of changing society turn out to be outside ev yone's specialist area!

Nhile the orthodox economist is off calc lating how much increase in the supply of potatoes will educe he price by 1p, the Marxist economist is probing the concept of "price', reducing it to more basic concepts like value, labour, labour-power, exchange, and setting them in their historical context.

Orthodox social science and Marxism share a commitment to checking their theories against the facts. But they go about it in different ways. I'll discuss that next we e dership struggles around talinisation, an intense Hungarian ional sense of grievance against ssian overlordship, and direct aci by the working class, led to a vement which did create the line of an alternative political tem of working class self-rule.

n fact the Hungarian workers ated a specifically working class tem of workers' councils, and interposed it to both capitalism Fi the Stalinist bureaucratic system.

ey were defeated and crushed by L. Stalinist Russian army, as hac On the Paris workers by the army Versailles. But in the Central forkers' Council if Budapest they fireted the classic form of workng iss democracy, the lineal continuavn of the Commune, of the Russian viets in the pre-stalinist era, and to extent of the Hungarian Soviet public of 1919.

TRo Tictors have aominated the view of Peru from abroad. One is President Garcia's unilateral decision to limit Peru's debt repayments to 10% of its export earnings. And the other is the ongoing war with the guerillas of Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path - a name taken from Jose Carlos Mariategui, a Peruvian Marxist prominent in the 1920s, and probably Latin America's most distinguished Marxist theoretician).

Peru, the third largest country in Latin America but with only 15% of its land area usable for agriculture, is divided into three main areas: the narrow coastal plain where over 50% of the population live; the massive highland region, and the sparsely populated, huge jungle, Amazon area.

The immense diversity and spread of Peru has made both national integration and national politics problematic. Equally problematic has been the ethnic divisions. Although Amerindians are 50% of the population, and mixed 39%, the white 12% of the population have always dominated politics and the economy.

The great rebellion of Tupac Amaru in 1780 had as its aim the establishment of an Indian and mestizo republic, and an attempt to revive the Inca resistance to the language and traditions were banned.

When mass politics emerged in Peru in the twentieth century, it had to come to grips with the problems of the Indian population. To ignere the explosive It demonstrated that the bureaucracy could not tolerate independent initiatives; simultaneously it showed that the distance between the first criticism of the Stalinist bureaucratic system and demands for its end is extremely short, precisely because of the arbitrary and unnecessary 'function' of the bureaucracy.

Even within a phase of destalinisation, which many then took to be an evolutionary 'thawing' of the bureaucracy, it resorted to ruthless force, and felt obliged to smash and destroy every vestige of the independent working class organisations that had begun to grow in 1956.

National No doubt the national oppression made Hungary exceptionally explosive - but when the explosion came, it resulted in specific working munist Party did to its cost, was to LIC IcW Com court political failure as a mass political movement. Mariategui clearly saw this, and advocated a worker-peasant alliance which recognised the specific problems and concerns of the Indian population.

He argued strongly that neither the middle classes with their racist disdain for the mass of the population nor a national bourgeoisie were capable of carrying out the tasks of national economic liberation. It was, he argued"'not possible to be effectively nationalist and revolutionary without being socialist." However Mariategui's theories within the Peruvian Communist Party were defeated, and instead the CP adopted the then Comintern position and formed a small purely proletarian party which lapsed into sectarian isolation. Fifty years later many on the left were to officially call themselves Mariateguists, but in some cases, as with Sendero, perverting his analysis.

The mass popular party which did emerge from the 1930s was APRA, founded in 1930 by Victor Raul Haya de la Torre. APRA (the American Popular Revolutionary Alliance) finally came to power on its own in 1985 when its candidate, Alan Garcia, took 46% of the vote in the Presidential election. Haya de la Torre founded the party, as its name suggests, as a continent wide movement, but the movement never really spread beyond Peru.

Haya argued for a national anti-imperialist revolution which would implement a programme for national capitalist development. The key group to bring about such a revolution was the middle classes. Inspired more by the Mexican Revolution broken by the Revolution itself" (p. 197). These ideas originated in Lenin's 'What is to be Done?' and the development of the totalitarian party-state was carried even further by Lenin's successor, Stain, under whose rule the party was turned into a mere instrument of the Stalinist state power.?

But Lomax himself brings out clearly the fatal role of the vacillating and unsure policy of those who found themselves reluctant leaders of a revolution. It surely follows that a different type of leadership might have made the difference between the defeat which occurred and the victory which was possible. Certainly the revolt could have been spread to Poland and perhaps beyond.

A revolutionary organisation which had a clear programme and trained cadres involved with the masses might very well have changed the course of events. Such a concluamericanism without empires". But the tradition of an anti-imperialist rhetoric remained strong within APRA as can be seen from President Garcia's speeches.

Disastrous

The 1945-8 government was a disastrous period for APRA as their populist, but incoherent economic policies led to rising inflation and economic chaos. The military easily overthrew them in the coup of 1948. Thereafter APRA tended to degenerate into a purely opportunistic party, even supporting for periods the oligarchy.

In the 1950s and 1960s the rural poor slowly began to organise. Militant strikes, rent strikes, and land invasions swept across the highlands of Peru. In one strike and land invasion in La Convencion, a Quechua speaking Trotskyist, Hugo Blanco, led a year long struggle that also became an armed rebellion. After the Cuban revolution there was an attempt to establish focos in the sierra.

As was in keeping with the voluntaristic enthusiasm of the times, young students took to the hills, not speaking Quechua or understanding the Indian communities, believing there would be spontaneous support from the campesinos. When this failed to materialise the army had little problem in brutally wiping out the focos. When Sendero emerged in the 1980s, it was to be solidly rooted in the local communities.

Growing social unrest, economic difficulties, and the failure to take a sufficiently nationalistic line against the American oil company, IPC, led to a bloodless military coup against the government of Belaunde in 1968.

and backward material conditions in Russia. If the highly centralised party became a factor in the growth of totalitarianism, it was only after it was swamped by careerists (1924) and then purged until there was little left even of the original membership.

In 1905-7 and 1917 Lenin's ideas led the Bolsheviks, not to substitute themselves for the working class, but to be the most clear-headed elements within the organs of self-control and action which the working class set up.

Had they not existed, and had they not led in stabilising the gains of the working class by setting up a workers' state, then a counterrevolutionary state would have been set up.

The experience of Spain, where in the Republican areas, from July 1936 to mid-1937, the workers had real control, even though workers' councils did not emerge, proves tht. The political vacuum was filled by elements hostile to workers' control.

The anarchists who did not believe any state power was compatible with liberation wound up accepting the need for some state, of the impossibility of a cavuum if fascism was not to be allowed to create its own state - and opted for the counterrevolutionary Popular Front. The gains of the working class in the Republican areas were liquidated.

Things can only be otherwise if there are no enemies of working class revolution, internal or external, and if conditions in society are such that no state power is necessary. Lomax ends with a quotation from SaintSimon: "The government of persons is replaced by the administration of things". But this relates necessarily to the fully communist societymore advanced materially than even the most advanced societies today.

Between capitalism and communism there is transition, which Marxists understand as the dictatorship of the proletariat.

'Semi-state"

Certainly this is a 'semi-state', difering centrally trom all other states n being rule of the majority over the ninority. and, therefore directer or labour communities" in the private sector whereby workers were to participate in management and profits, tion reform which increased literacy and made Quechua a second official language, and introduced a nationalist Third World relevant curriculum, an extension of social security, and an attempt at mass mobilisation through the government agency, Sinamos, the National System for the Support of Social Mobilisation.

Split

Not surprisingly when faced with these top down, but crucial reforms, the left split on how to respond to military reformism. For the Maoists the Velasco government was fascist or semi-fascist, and after a bitter strike with the Maoist dominated teachers' union, the government cut back on its educational reforms.

Some former guerillas joined the government. The pro-Moscow Communist Party initially strongly supported the military, but began to distance itself from the regime when the government set up a trade union federation (led by gangster elements) to challenge the CP and other left influence in the unions. As in many parts of Latin America the unions were divided along different ideological lines.

The military reformers however ran into a whole series of problems, not least with their own colleagues. The USA tended to portray Velasco as a beach-head for Soviet communism in Latin America, particularly when the Soviets made large arms sales to Peru.

Scan page 11

IDUSTRIAL SEALINK

----- pull-quotes -----

not fixed but changeable. In class struggle people change both society and themselves. Then I looked at 'free enterprise" and 'equal exchange'. These sorts of freedom and equality belong to capitalism. They are not eternal or

ferent sorts of freedom and equali- ty. And from the point of view of the working class, free enterprise and equal exchange generate un- freedom and inequality, wage-

looking at things. And Marxism is mainly that — a method. It is not a

What can we say about the Marxist way of approaching these It is historical. It takes no values or concepts for granted, but looks at where they come from, and

AN ION 'Hungary 1956'

Spaniards. It was brutally repressed, and in its aftermath, the Quechua

the creation of state enterprises and state investments in industry, educa-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 289

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →