Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Behind the Boycott Who Killed Mac Hel?

Socialist Organiser no. 289, 23 October 1986 · scan p. 12 · Bob Fine · about 1,066 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

ORGANISER FOR WORKERS' LIBERTY EAST AND WEST SOUTH AFRICA/MOZAMBIQUEI Speculation is widespread that the South African government or security forces are responsible for the plane crash tht killed Mozambique's President Samora Machel and 28 others.

South Africa cannot deny that its sabre-rattling against the black African state to its north has reached fever pitch in recent weeks. The South African-backed Mozambique FOLLOWING his dismissal, Mick McGinty immediately went for an industrial tribunal - asking for reinstatement pending a full hearing. That hearing comes up at the end of this week.

I'm quite confident that the injustice to Mick will be quite evident when it's argued in court. Having said that, it remains to be seen with the latest round of tribunals if there is any softening of attitudes.

WHETTON'S Resistance Movement has carried out actions against the regime of Machel's FRELIMO that came to power a decade ago. Parts of the country have degenerated to a state of civil war.

Economic sanctions by South Africa against Mozambique, coupled with military action against African National Congress bases alleged to be sited in the country have caused chaos for FRELIMO. The threat of invasion has been looming over their There was a magnificent response — UDM as well as NUM.

The UDM leadership tried to get men to go to work as normal. There was the disgraceful sight of UDM branch officials on the picket line urging men to cross it, to go to work, and to sell Mick McGinty's job down the river. Even some UDM members couldn't stomach that.

Every time they do something UDM put their foot in it.

The tactic now is to wait to see the outcome of the tribunals - in the Welbeck case, Mick's case, and my case. We've got to take some positive steps to safeguard future jobs, even if we don't get our own jobs back. We won't stand by and see other branch officials and union activists picked off.

The Coal Board has said it's prepared to backdate its pay deal, but in return it wants an agreement to take the pensions out in all future strike action. I think thạt is a nonrunner.

I'm sure that most of the rank and file lads who want their backdated pay rise are not prepared to sell out on that basis. I hope the National Executive will stand firm and say: pension rights are not up tor negotiation on pay issues.

There's been talk of the Coal Board looking for a no-strike deal. But if the right to pensions is not up Conor Cruise O'Brien's recent visit to South Africa provoked outraged opposition from anti-apartheid activists in the country. O'Brien is an heads, and now, coincidentally, Samora Machel — who Pretoria has promised to overthrow - is dead.

Whether or not Pretoria sabotaged the plane, the honeyed words of sympathy from apartheid spokespeople are nauseating hypocrisy. In the short term at least, South Africa's rulers will benefit from the greatest crisis Mozambique has experienced since it won independence. from Portugal in 1975.

SOUTH Moses Mayekiso and outspoken opponent of apartheid, but an equally outspoken opponent There is a real danger that the deteriorating economic situation will provide fertile soil for the right wing guerillas to take power. If that happens, South Africa will benefit in the long lerm, too.

Apartheid's imperialistic actions towards its neighbours must be condemned as much as its repression of the people of South Africa itself. Mozambique — and Angola, and Botswana — must be defended against apartheid's attacks. of the policy of an 'academic boycott' of apartheid. Police had to defend his lectures from angry protesters.

But recent events suggest that changes may be introduced into the African National Congress policy of a blanket boycott. The old policy - that no South African academics should be met by foreign counterparts - has been abandoned for a number of different conferences.

In York, a lot of South African academics attended having been previously ratified by the ANC, who themselves sent representatives. A number of South African academics attended one recent conference of the Review of African Political Economy, At a Critical Legal Studies conference there was some confusion over the barring of a South African Marxist lawyer, who was eventually accepted. The attendant laywers and others concluded that no one should be barred on grounds of nationality or country of origin.

Controversy There was controversy at the World Congress of Sociology over the attendance of an academic from the University of Natal, who was known to have links with Buthelezi.

In fact the academic boycott has been broken in practice for many years: there are a lot of South African students in Britain, and British academics have been visiting South Africa. What is now being recognised more publicly, is that there has to be some discrimination on political grounds over who, and who not, to boycott. It cannot be enforced across the board, and certainly using simple racial criteria (only boycotting white South Africans) would be an untenable policy.

In South Africa the equivalent of the Association of University Teachers are trying to set up their own 'vetting' body. And the ANC, naturally, consider their own decisions to be crucial. As yet the issue is unresolved.

Conor Cruise O'Brien's visit focuses some of these issues quite sharply.

For certain O'Brien's actions and comments were extremely provocative. Moreover, the outcry it has caused in South Africa will put strains on the freedom of other academics to go there and establish or strengthen links with opponents of apartheid.

Criticism

There has been some criticism, too, of the methods employed against O' Brien. These were reminiscent of much of the 'no platform' tactic employed on campuses in Britain, and suffered from similar problems. Conor Cruise O'Brien is not a socialist, but he is a serious and obdurate liberal. Opposition to the tactic of the academic boycott should not put him outside the pale of democratic opinion. Suppression of his right to speak smacks of an anti-socialist authoritarianism that is not a force for liberation.

Socialists of course should aim to isolate supporters of the racit regime in South Africa, as part of a general campaign of solidarity.

But links between opponents of apartheid, inside and outside the country, and in particular links between socialists, help rather than hinder the struggle for liberation. The exchange of experiences and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 289

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →