Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Free speech and the fight against racis Executive, writing in capacity, looks at the

Socialist Organiser no. 290, 30 October 1986 · scan p. 3 · about 633 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Has the left lost its basic commitment to free speech? Pottinger, a member of NUS Over the past couple of years, banning those you don't agree with has become a display of left credibility in the student movement. Not only have fascists (quite correctly) been banned, but this tactic of 'no platform' has been used to ban Jewish Societies. When Tory MPs have visited colleges, there have been discussions, at least, about whether to ban them.

The Tories, inevitably, have picked up on this. Shortly a Bill will go before Parliament, attempting to make 'no platform' illegal!

Autonomy

While the Bill is a gross infringement on student union autonomy, it has forced the left seriously to examine its gut responses to those with whom it disagrees, and to discuss the best way to fight racists and other reactionaries.

Last week Enoch Powell spoke at Bristol University. In previous years and at other colleges, it is likely that Powell would have been banned. This year he was picketed, involving more people in political activity than a ban ever could. Choosing a picket rather than a ban meant that Powell was denied the opportunity to whip. up support by demanding free speech.

This tactical consideration needs to be married to a discussion on the principles involved in denying and defending free speech.

Three things need to distinguished and separated out.

a) Our basic principles — liberty; individual and group freedoms; free speech; the rights of minorities -especially of hated minorities.

b) The question of the best way to fight against racism and fascism.

c) Factional considerations of how best to defend ourselves against Tory attacks in which they are using the 'no platform' issue and waving the purloined flag of free speech' Freedom from tyranny and bitrary rules; freedom of speech or publication; the right of minor October 1986 page 10 to exist and organise even though they be hateful to the majority; the right of minorities not to be subject to majority tyranny — which implies the voluntary acceptance by the majority of limitations to their power -these ideas are central to a democratic society, whether it be society at large or in a students union. They would be central even in a stable democratic socialism.

The alternative to these principles is various forms of tyranny, including the democratic tyranny exemplified, for example, in recent referendums in Ireland on the question of divorce and abortion - where the Catholic majority vote to impose its morality on dissenting minorities.

For socialists too, these concerns which we take over from the bourgeois democrats of the pastare central. We recognise that society is riven down the middle with class conflict, and it is not possible to set up Queensbury rules to be applicable at all times and in all circumstances.

The working class should not be bound by formal democracy, treating it as a fetish. Under capitalism even the best liberal laws are intertwined inextricably with laws protecting the exploitation system as a whole.

Freedom and democracy remain centrally important to socialists and the working class.

The working class can only rule, as a class, democratically. We are therefore concerned at all times that the democratic functioning of our own labour movement and the bodies of which we have leadership. We tyranny guard against any 'majority , and guarantee the rights of minorities — especially where we don't like them. As Rosa Luxemburg said:

Rights *Democracy is not democracy protecting the rights of those you prove of, democracy is always for person who disagrees." These matters of principle, not tactics.

It is a measure of the state of the Left that the Tories have lyingly but with some plausibility mobilised s upport for their policies under the HARRINTO LES PNL NO NAZISIN CE TA ONIT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 290

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →