Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Socialist Organiser no 290 30 October 1986 page…]

Socialist Organiser no. 290, 30 October 1986 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 787 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Socialist Organiser no 290 30 October 1986 page the Photo: Report. notorious banner of defending freedom against the Left.

It is against this background that the principle consideration of the question of how we fight racism and fascism arises. There can be no recognition of any individual's or group's freedom to organise violence or intimidation against ethnic groups. We should not defend the 'freedom' of fascists. But the question arises - how do we fight them? By bureaucratic bans? Or by mobilisations?

No platform' can play a central part in the fight against racism and fascism. But it is not sufficient; and its precise meaning and liimts have become blurred. Often it is reduced to meaningless jargon, used vaguely to express the idea that you have the right to suppress those you don't like:

Rule The non-negotiable rule as far as we are concerned is this: fascists and racists should not be allowed to inflict verbal, their target groups.

*No platform' is too frequently understood merely to mean a ban imposed by the central authority in a student union. In reality, an effective fight against racism and fascism has to fall to large-scale mobilisations.

A student union is a body made up of the entire complement of students and therefore reflects most of the levels and currents of opinion and interest in broader society. Therefore the use of any bans inevitably gives those banned the chance to raise the cry of free speech and against tyranny, etc., etc., and rally the support of those who do not agree with them in defence of their claim to democratic rights.

For avoid as much as possible going into battle against racists and fascists under the banner of denying them free speech. The banner of defence o free speech is a powerful weapon.

A demonstration of this from British experience should suffice. In 1968 the Asians of Kenya were expelled. They had been given British passports when Kenya achieved independence four years earlier, but when they needed to use them the Home Secretary, James Callaghan, committed one of the most repulsive acts in the history of the British labour movement and of the British Labour Party. He slammed Britain's door in their faces. Their British passports were made useless to them, they couldn't enter.

Enoch Powell, a member of the Tory Shadow Cabinet, made a speech that unless Britain immediately stopped immigration he like the Ancient Romans' foresaw 'the Tiber foaming with blood' Powell had immediately become the rallying point for all the racists in Britain. Heath sacked him from the Shadow Cabinet because of the speech. Dockers and Meat Porters struck and marched in support of Powell through the streets of London.

There is little reason to doubt that they marched because they agreed with Powell's racism. But they marched not in support of Powell's racism but under the slogan 'free speech for Powell'.

In contrast, by far the grearest anti-fascist demonstration in history took place in New York in 1939 not under the banner of no free speech for fascists' but under the banner of protesting against the fascists and defending their targeted victims, the Jews, the labour movement, ele.

These lessons need to be taken board.

The overuse of bannings, can play into the hands of our enemies.

Mass mobilisations and pickets of obnoxious speakers in all the so-called 'grey areas, including those involving members of the Tory Party, are far better to prevent the organisation of racism.

In fact a powerful picket opens up the option of actually stopping the meeting without taking responsibility for denying them free speech.

Another consideration, A bureaucratic ban, handed down from on high in a student union and not backed by mass mobilisation will almost always give those banned the chance to appeal to the middle ground on the grounds of defending free speech. A mass picket can prevent racists entering the building; and so the question of the ban - giving them the initiative on free speech is irrelevant.

The reality is that the Tories have gained hegemony over the last seven years. The left has been largely on the retreat. In these conditions we have to take account of the balance of forces and avoid playing into the Tories' hands.

What is requires is that the democratic socialist left and all those we influence should do the following things:

a. Make a bold and sincere declaralion of where we stand on freedom and democracy and use that to educate ourselves against the stupidities of South Bank, Sunderland, etc.

b. Conduct a vigorous policy of reliance on mobilisation and demonstration rather than bureaucratic bans — the exceptions being Nazis and foaming at the mouth, organising racists.

Scan page 4

GRAI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 290

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →