Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Why we are not Zionist

Socialist Organiser no. 290, 30 October 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 1,010 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

I disagreé with some of what Mick escape to America, or Britain, where Ackersley had to say in his review of Pillar of Fire. I didn't see the pro- to go. And where were the com- most of them would have preferred centration camp-like ghettoes in gramme so I can't comment on it; but munists, homosexuals, gypsies, trade To say that in a "sense", , then, unionists supposed to seek refuge? A Socialist Organiser is "Zionist" is sense has been 'confined to history' It is true that Zionism in its original 'refuge' was not the answer - as post-1948 history has tragically thus akin to saying that we support and condone all of this - and the Jewish state. But I cannot agree that - the movement for a separate In any case, the fate of the 'refuge' manifestation of the Israeli govern- ment's foreign and domestic policy in Zionism as a term now means no would have depended on Allied the region, namely the continued and more than the belief that the Israeli systematic terrorisation of the Jews have the right to a state. If this SO is right to bend the stick against anti-Zionists and non-Zionists are is so, the majority certainly of Israeli the "idiot anti-imperialists' on the question of the Middle East; but I behind the sentiments expressed in I understand the motivation "Zionists' . I do not agree that SO's think maybe there's a danger of ben- the article — there is no easy solution position is, or should be in any sense to this situation: and that most solutions put forward by the Left in oppressive in the Israeli state flows Much of what is reactionary and essence reduce to an external and forceful destruction of not only the from its specifically Zionist Israeli state but Jewish society (and character. That it is defined as a state for all Jews rather than its citizens is immigrate to Israel but displaced not incidental; that Jews are free to I wish to correct the balance of, and one of the central assertions made in this position Mick Ackersley has But in trying to differentiate from Arabs are not, is not incidental the article "The making of the Jewish Zionism is a thoroughly racist and Unionising IBM liable to lead to an underestimation either. These features, among others, understate this aspect of the issue is define Israel as a Zionist state, and to *Zionism is a term that has now ceas- ed to have any very clear meaning" However, as ht asserts, it does mean Mick Ackersley states that reactionary ideology - one today based upon the maintenance of power of one people, the Jews, organised in their own militarised of the problems posed by the Middle *the right of the Jewish state of state, over that of a dispossessed and Israel to exist" , even if perhaps dispersed people, the Palestinian Hitler; but it seems to me to under- open their borders to Jews fleeing anti-semitism of the 'democratic' Allies prior to 1948 in refusing to Similarly, it is right to condemn the ly based upon the democratic wishes ple, is a state fundamentally resting. of the vast majority of its Jewish peo- upon the oppression of over 2¼ But the state of Israel, a state clear- systematic brutalising and oppression people is that in fleeing the Holocaust they built a homeland by the The terrible tragedy of the Jewish "maybe if a Jewish state had been mine that condemnation to add million Palestinian Arabs - Arabs scattered throughout the Middle East this day continue a hard, bitter, of another people — a people who to created, the Jews of Europe would have had a refuge, and millions might (and elsewhere) or forced to live under the Israeli state's military con- misrepresented and all too often forgotten struggle against this reality.

have survived." Maybe. But tar bet- trol of the annexed West Bank and ter, surely, if they had been able to Gaza Strip, not to mention the conSocialist Organiser no 290 30 October 1986 page 4 Not imp ACAS is the official conciliation and arbitration service for industrial disputes. It is, of course, supposed to be completely impartial -umpire standing above the class struggle.

But Pat Lowry. the chair of ACAS, seems to have forgotten about keeping up this pretence. Last week he made a speech denouncing the very timid and moderate Trade unions from across the world will be meeting in London on 12-13 January to plan a campaign for unionisation in IBM.

Price The price of defeat: according to figures given in Parliament last week, 49,000 mineworkers have been made redundant since the end of the 1984-5 strike.

The giant computer firm has always been tirmly non-union. Its rapid growth and huge profits have enabled it to offer workers job security and relatively good pay, and on that basis to beat off previous unionisation drives.

IBM in the US, however, is now talking about severe job cuts, and a determined international campaign could have success.

Spelled from their homelands South Lebanon. the review raises broader issues.

shown.

military success in north Africa. top ACAS official came out with enthusiastic Palestinian and Arab peoples. support for no-strike deals. Strikes ding it too far.

CLIVE BRADLEY, "Zionist" London.

The Financial Times headlined its report of TUC secretary Norman Willis's speech to personnel managers last week: "Union members no longer want strikes"

gone too far the other way!

According to Willis, increasingly, members state" in SO 289. will be looking to their unions to provide progress without strikes and without pickets - quite simply, with the minimum of hassle" East conflict.

As if up to now strikes have been a matter of "radically" altered. Arabs. workers preferring a punch-up to boring negotiations! In fact unions' ability to win advances without strikes has always depended on the credibility of the threat to strike.

Tell the boss that you want a quiet life at all costs, and he will think he BRYAN EDMANDS can ride rough-shod. London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 290

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →