Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The left and Russia

Socialist Organiser no. 290, 30 October 1986 · scan p. 5 · about 528 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

(letter to eld L abr Organ ser Comrades.

Your letter to Gorbachev is motivated by a sincere desire to influence the international peace process. You are right to be concerned that Mrs Thatcher will simply use her visit to the Soviet Union as a public relations exercise, and a propaganda ploy.

But are you right to believe that Gorbachev is an ally in the fight for peace? We think not. The underlying assumption of your letter is that where Thatcher is a hypocrite, Gorbachev is sincere; where Thatcher is a war-monger, Gorbachev is genuinely working for peace. From this you appear to conclude that Gorbachev is a friend of the British labour movement, who may need some advice and warning on the intentions of the British Prime Minister. You appear to believe that a friendly voice from Britain will encourage Gorbachev further down the road of "constructive disarmament proposals"

If Gorbachev, or the Soviet people, can see that not everyone in the West is a hostile cold-warrior, constructive peace proposals will be forthcoming, you suppose.

It is a widespread view on the Left that the USSR is essentially concerned to bring about disarmament, or at least that it is more genuinely concerned to do so than the USA is. The Cold War is put down to US aggressiveness alone, with the USSR portrayed as a passive victim. This image is popular on the left far outside of pro-Moscow circles.

It is essentially false, though there is a germ of truth to it.

The USA and its allies have a lead in nuclear weapons, and much of the initiative in the nuclear arms race has come from the West -from the use of the first A-bomb through to the development of a first-strike strategy.

But the view of the USSR as being essentially non-warlike is drawn from psychological, emotional and political needs, too. When Reagan and Thatcher base their case for nuclear weapons on the Soviet threat' , the Left wants to undermine their argument simply by denying that the Soviet Union is expansionist or aggressive at all., But it is a naive view. Gorbachev is not the same as Reagan - he rules over a very different social and political system. But Gorbachev is not a friend of the peace movement in Britain; and he is not a friend of anyone fighting against US or British imperialism.

Gorbachev is the opposite of a friend to the labour movement. He presides over a system in which the working class is held in an iron totalitarian grip in the USSR and Eastern Europe, Bureaucracy The Soviet bureaucracy which Gorbachev leads is opposed to progress towards freedom and socialism. Thirty years ago, the Hungarian people discovered to what extent Gorbachev's predecessors would go to crush progress towards freedom and socialism.

And let us not forget that the man responsible for crushing the Hungarian revolution was Krushchev - Krushchev, the great 'destaliniser' , the liberaliser of the Russian system; Krushchev who showed his commitment to world peace by backing down over the 'Cuban missile crisis" in 1962. The most liberal of Gorbachev's

----- pull-quotes -----

Tony Benn and ur Party from

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 290

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →