[Dan-Air, the small airline with the small mind…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Dan-Air, the small airline with the small mind, has been told by the Equal Opportunities Commission that it can no longer employ only women as its cabin crew.
I wonder what the terms of employment will be for the men. Will they have to plaster their faces in make-up, wear high-heeled shoes and tight fitting clothes that show off their gorgeous figures?
Will they have to wriggle their bums as they glide seductively down the aisles and smile glamorously at the besuited businessman who insists on demanding yet another brandy, or the child who has just been sick over its neighbour's lap?
The spokesperson for Dan-Air told the press that for 33 years they have employed "girls" . "It always was a glamour job", he said. It's strange, isn't it, that grown women in a job where the obvious physical attributes that go with being a woman are a definite prerequisite for getting the job and that are displayed to the fullest, should be called "girls" wonder if the "boys" will have to display their bulging, bronzed pecs to their interviewers and have their willies measured. Instead of the qualifications being 38-24-36, we will now have 40-½(5 extended).
But of course not. Let's be serious. You don't treat grown men in this fashion. It's belittling. Whereas the job hemaloyed only amos job» was alwavs a , the spokesperson says, "I suppose we live in an enlightened age and we are discontinuing the practice"
Perhaps then this "glamour job" will be seen for what it is now that real grown up people are doing it -airborne waiters, cooks, cleaners and child minders. Just as in the home, the glamour goes out of housework when the men have to do it.
30 October 986
Scan page 6
Its lessons are therefore important of Eastern Europe, and systems were not only for Eastern Europe: all set up there modelled on the USSR workers' movements, all over the itself, the Trotskyists extended the world, can learn from the expereince argument to include these states.
Events in Hungary shocked those utopia; and it proved that the prowho had looked to the USSR and its gramme of such a workers' revolusatellites as models of socialism. They tion would go far beyond the timid vindicated what the genuine Com- proposals of the reformers. led by Leon Trotsky, had been saying it showed the world the vicious, The Trotskyists were not the only character of the Soviet bureaucracy. what happened in the USSR under revolt against the latter-day imStalin in the 1930s. But most others perialists of Russia; there had been had hoped for nothing more radical an uprising in East Germany in 1953 than bureaucratic self-reform. It was that had also been crushed. But the Trotskyists who argued that the events in Hungary were of an bureaucrats who ruled in the USSR altogether different scale. were a counter-revolutionary, anti- Czechoslovakia in 1968 and Poland to be overthrown in a new working in 1980, was especially explosive Socialism must start from the self-activity of the working class: Often mass movements of revolutionary scale put forward demands that in themselves are "reformist', ideas that are incoherent, confused and underdeveloped.
The Hungarian revolution did not come up with a complete, finished programme for a new form of government; but it did demand the wholesale destruction of the form of government that existed.
And in the workers' councils that were created all across the country, the Hungarian workers built the institutions necessary to replace the old clace revolution state. I mis was a real workers fevorution which its participants understood as such.
of Hungary.
Councils
munists, the movement that had been!
for two decades.
socialists who had been critical of working class force who would have because of the severe national opAfter the Second World War, pression that it suffered at the hands when the Red Army occupied much of the USSR. Independence for Hungary was the dominant slogan of the movement from the outset.
This was not a narrow nationalism, but a genuine, progressive aspiration Despite its defeat, the Hungarian for national emancipation. That is revolution proved them right. It pro- clear from the stand made by the ved that working class revolution was Hungarian revolution in solidarity possible, and not some dreamy with the contemporary movement for national independence in Poland, a movement whose example did much to encourage and spark the uprising in Hungary itself.
Also, if further proof were needed, Class repressive, anti-working class The Hungarian workers, identified Hungary was not the first site of with the Polish people: they were all the victims of savage denial of their rights to self government; all the institutions of bureaucratic repression, which clogged up all the pores of national political life, depended for their power on the ultimate sanction of Soviet troops. Take the power of Moscow from behind the Party chiefs in Eastern Europe, and they would be much less intimidating.
This perception was right, of course. In Hungary and in Czechoslovakia, the home-grown bureaucrats were not up to the task of keeping the workers in their place, and it did take Russian intervention to crush the revolutionary movement. In Poland in 1980, it was fear Russian invasion that caused Solidarnose to hold back. Jaruselski too would have been far less formidable but for Breshnev watching his back.
National independence and democracy — the Hungarian workers were calling for free elections and a multi-party system — are the sort of demands that historically have been associated with anti-colonial revolutionary movements or with the European revolutions generated by the rise of capitalism as a new and (in its time) progressive form of society.
But like many great revolutionary democratic movements this century, the Hungarian revolution was powered and led by the working class. It was a movement for national democracy that from the outset had a distinct working class character.
Thus far it was quite similar to other revolutionary movements, including the Russian revolution of 1917 itself. Hungary is peculiar because it was a revolution against a regime in which capitalism had been overthrown, albeit bureaucratically and without opening the road to a socialist reconstruction of society:
It is a damning comment in itself on the so-called socialist system in Hungary that the central demands of the people against it were chose characteristic of the rise of the bourgeoisie.
The existence of widespread workers' councils raised the real possibility of a working class regime based on them. The Hungarian revolution — if it had been allowed to develop and not been drowned in blood - need not have finished with a Westminster-style Parliament. could have gone beyond that to install a regime of real, grass roots democratic working class power. A Parliament could not have replaced the existing bureaucratic state apparatus; workers' councils could.
Such a regime would be vastly more democratic than Westminsterstyle democracy, where, once someone is elected, the electors have virtually no control over what he or she does for another four or five years. And Parliaments keep well clear of the economic fortresses of power; in fact, though not in theory, they are subordinate to the permanent unelected power of the bankers, the bosses, the top bureaucrats and the military chiefs] Delegates to the workers' councils, however, were subject to permanent checks and control from below. And the councils were concerned with the actual running of the factories.
During the revolution the councils established an uncontested position of power in the factories; and the idea that the factories belonged to the workers - rather than to the state bureaucrats, and still less to the deposed capitalists — was reluctantly accepted even by the workers' opponents.
The councils did not take state power: they did not declare themselves a new governmental authority on a national scale (although some local councils did make such declarations). But they could well have done so.
And for the period of 100 hours that the USSR abdicated its power in Hungary real power was, in fact, held by the councils and the armed workers.
In this respect, too, the situation in Hungary in 1956 was similar to that in Russia in 1917. There too workers' councils were formed. There too the councils in fact controlled what wen on in the cities, and later more generally.
Power But there too, until the councils -which were called 'soviets' - actually established themselves as the real government, they shared power with a Provisional Government' ', the representative of the old ruling class hanging on for dear life.
Until the soviets acted upon the power that they had, there existed "dual power' - the capitalist class in Russia held on to political power by default, because of the political immaturity of the workers.
There are of course important differences between Russia in 1917 and Hungary in 1956. The Hungarian working class were a much bigger proportion of the population; and the Hungarian workers were struggling against an allegedly socialist regime - one that in any case had disposed of the old Hungarian bourgeoisie. But the parallels are demolish striking.
What were the ding? The deman student demonstra were already very expressed deep-ro cerns. They include of Soviet troops; : mittee cleansed Stalinists, and a under Imre Nagy new economic "autonomy' in amnesty for po freedom of the pr with the Polish in ment.
This general pro democratic de galvanised a mas within that the were formed. O Parliament of Wc Budapest met, dr ment on the role c These laid out i the extent to whic to take control ov lives. According 1 Parliament:
"1. The factor workers...
2. The supreme the factory is the democratically workers.
own executive con 4. ...The directi and the highest er elected by the cil...after a public 5. The director i • workers demands of the original tion on October 22 wide-ranging and oted popular coned: The withdrawal a new central comof the corrupt new government ; new elections; a policy; workers' the factories; an ›litical prisoners; ess; and solidarity dependence move›gramme of largely mands quickly s movement, and workers' councils n 31 October a orkers' Councils in awing up a stateof the councils. in very clear terms h the workers were er their day-to-day to the 31 October "1. The factory belongs to the belongs to the controlling body in Workers' Council elected by the 3. The Workers' Council elects its ...The directors (of the factory Workers' Coun 5. The director is responsible to the
----- pull-quotes -----
he lesson Clive Bradley draws out some of the lessons for socialists today of the great workers' rising against Stalinism in Hungary 30 years ago.
workers' defence squad in Poland, 1,980, s aga Stalinisn
DoNe Di Stalin's stati