Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Workers against Stalinisn

Socialist Organiser no. 290, 30 October 1986 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 2,058 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

of Hungary 6. The Workers" Council itself reserves all rights to: a) approve and ratify all projects concerning the enterprise; b) decide basic wage levels and the methods by which these are to be assessed; c) decide on...foreign contracts...

7..the Workers' Council resolves all conflicts concerning hiring and firing...

8. ...has the right to examine the balance sheets and to decide on the use to which the profits are to be put.

9. The Workers' Council handles all social questions in the enterprise. (cited in Lomax, 'Hungary 1956', pp. 140-1), This is a far-reaching programme for workers' control. Moreover, for a short period, the workers enforced it: they did take control.

Ban An undemocratic feature of the councils was a total ban on the operation of political parties within them, although at the same time the workers were advocating a multiparty system and free elections. This of course was the result of the workers experience with the Communist Party, which had acted as a spying adjunct of management.

It was also a reaction to the distorted 'Leninism' of official ideology which proclaimed the right of 'the Party' - i.e. the state - to command the workers.

It points to a further, and more complex, issue, however. Whilst both the general demands of the revolution and the specific demands of the councils were wide-ranging and radical, the councils on the whole do not seem to have envisaged a political role for themselves. They saw their role as limited to the workplace. Political questions would be dealt with somewhere else.

This has been a common feature of bodies like the Councils; the Italian factory councils - which took over the factories in 1919-20 — defined themselves in the same limited, mainly 'economic' way.

And this points to a 'missing ingredient' in the Hungarian revolution: there was no organised, poltical force within the workers' movement attempting to make conscious the potential for taking state power.

The soviets in 1917 didn't come onto the political stage fully aware of their own capacity to take over the reins of government. In fact, the survival of pro-capitalist governments from February to October depended, to a large extent, on the lack of such awareness among the soviets" members.

What changed that, so that in October the soviets did seize state power - replace all the old government institutions with their own - was an active, political party -the Bolsheviks, later renamed the Communist Party.

A similar party in Hungary mighti have made all the difference. political party that had studied history, digested the lessons of history - particularly the very relevant lessons of 1917 - and developed an overall strategy, could have transformed the councils, and won their majority to the idea of gathering all power into their own hands. That would not, of course, have guaranteed the defeat of the Soviet troops; but it would have strengthened, politically, the movement against them.

Develop

Politically, the Hungarian revolution never had the chance to develop beyond the call for a government under Imre Nagy. That does not detract from the revolutionary working class character of the movement, but it does show the limits to the political consciousness of the majority of workers.

Nagy was a member of the ruling Party, a former Prime Minister who had been victimised by the Stalnists as a 'right-wing deviationist' • In other words, he advocated democratic reform.

His own ideas were not very clear or developed. He favoured Hungarian independence, neutrality - his government in 1956 did negotiate Hungary's withdrawal from the Warsaw Pact - individual freedom. In general, therefore, he was essentially closer to Western Liberalism than Marxism - his ideas did not go beyond these liberal democratic concerns.

His appeal, nevertheless, lay precisely in his advocacy even of liberalisation, and in that he was seen as distinct from the corrupt party chiefs who had expelled im.

It is often alleged by stalinists Nagy's programme was for the restoration of capitalism in Hungary.

And it is arguable tht if the working class dynamic to the revolution had somehow been exhausted rather than extinguished; and a stable government under Nagy or someone Ike hım consolidated, Hungary could have evolved in a West European 'social democratic' direction.

Certainly in Hungary, as more recently in Poland, many opponents of the regime explicitly looked to Western Europe as a model.

From this many supposed socialists conclude that the workers' movement in Hungary, or Poland, is reactionary, anti-socialist and so on -and is better crushed than allowed to flourish. Others go less far, but are half-hearted in their support of the workers' movement; sentiments are widespread to the effect that Solidarnosc in Poland must have something wrong with it if it is so loved by Reagan, Thatcher and the Pope, In two important respects, the programme of 'classical' Marxism - of the early Communist movement before the rise of Stalin - contradicts both these attitudes. First, it has been a principle of socialists that *the nation that oppresses another nation can never itself be free" Countries like Hungary and Poland, as we have seen are nationally oplionsed by Russia — as indeed are nainside the USSR ike the Ukraine, Latvia, Armenia and so on.

These nations have a right to self-determination - independence, if they want it — unconditionally. (In very exceptional eircumstances, such as a newly victorious workers' revoluton fighting for its life, there might be other considerations). Their right to self-determination, in other words, does not depend upon their first agreeing to be socialist — still less on them agreeing to adopt the Russian Stalinist system.

Trotsky Trotsky indeed argued tht the revolution in countries oppressed by the USSR would necessarily begin as a national revolution. As we have seen, he was right about that; and it would make no sense to recognise the importance of the demand for national independence only to contradict it by equivocating on the issue of Russian occupation.

The second issue in a way is more profound. Many socialists who condemn Stalinism, or who even agree with Trotsky's call for a new workers' revolution, believe that because capitalism has been abolished in Hungary and similar countries, these systems are of a vastly more progressive nature than Western Europe. The restoration of capitalism would therefore be a step backwards of historic proportions.

Events in Hungary and Poland show that the workers do not want 'capitalism back'. The Hungarian workers repeated over and over again. that they were opposed to the capitalists and landlords and in favour of socialism.

But in any case, even if the workers. were demanding that capitalists be given back their factories, it would not justify the crushing of the workers. Socialism depends upon precisely the sort of working class self-activity that reached such dramatic levels in the Hungarian revoluiton. Thousands and millions of workers can be wrong — have confused and reactionary ideas. But if they are wrong they must be given the chance to learn and to change.

A working class with reactionary ideas that is free to struggle, to fight, can change, and develop socialist ideas instead. A working class crushed under the jackboot is not able to develop at all. Socialism is not possible if the workers are smashed -even in the name of defending socialism'.

Defend

As the Hungarian revolution demonstrated, the people who can defend socialism are the workers - the only force, indeed, which can create it. There is no socialism set apart from the real lives of the working class. Bureaucrats, still less tanks, cannot create socialism - although in exceptional circumstances they have proved themselves capable of deposing the old capitalist class. But as Marx said, the liberation of the workers is the task of the workers themselves.

Turn to page 9 for a review of Peter Fryer's book "The Hungarian Tragedy". Next week Socialist Organiser will include a profile of the Hungarian opposition toda

Scan page 8

John Blos reviews ti issue of reland, and the British hard left's attitude to Ireland, are the subjects of a new pamphlet edition of Workers' Liberty, the magazine published by The conventional wisdom on the hard left today is that Northern Ireland is no more than the latest revolt against British colonialism and imperialism. The majority of the population of Northern Ireland, who passionately identify themselves as British and are determined to remain n the Uk, are dismissed as just 'pro-imperialist, and thereby classified as people whose interests, desires and concerns need not be taken into account.

This conception of the conflict in Northern Ireland has spread from sections of the revolutionary' left until today it permeates the attitude simplistic terms. one did, questions.

British troops? of much of Labour's left wing. The search for Irish votes by candidates such as Ken Livingstone in Brent East gives some on the left a direct motive of self-interest for presenting the Northern Ireland conflict in these At the same time the Labour front bench has used the Anglo-Irish Agreement as the occasion to resume Labour-Tory bipartisanship on Northern Ireland. Labour retains a notional commitment to a united Ireland, but in practice a new Labour government will do in Northern Ireland what the last Against this background Workers' Liberty challenges the conventional wisdom of the far left on Ireland. It poses the following probing How can working class unity be achieved? Are the Protestants a distinct community with collective rights, or just a privileged group! What sort of united Ireland could conceivably win the support of Protestant workers? What strategy can secure a united Ireland and the withdrawal of Workers' Liberty reprints a wide-ranging debate on Ireland which originaily apAvailable for £1 plus London SE1 4NA.

peared in Socialist Organiser. The debate includes all the points of view which exist today on the hard left.

Workers' Liberty continues the debate in an imaginary dialogue written by Socialist Organiser editor John O'Mahony, 'Provos, Protestants and working class politics . This debate centres on Socialist Organiser's commitment to the idea that the intra-Irish conflict can best be solved by some form of federal Ireland, giving autonomy to the mainlyProtestant areas in the North; perhaps together with closer connections between Britain and Ireland. WORKERS LIBERTY Provos, Protestants, and ULSTER working SAYS class politics ebate on Ireland Is this proposal a 'sop to imperialism' , as many on the left have alleged? What is the relationship between the struggle of the Northern Catholics and Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution? These issues are examined in great depth.

The continuing and deepening Protestant opposition to the Anglo-Irish agreement makes these questions very urgent for the British left. Whether or hot you agree with its conclusions, the new issue of Workers' Liberty is an interesting and very important contribution to the debate on Ireland. In the days after the exprosion at Chernobyl, a radioactive cloud was blown across Europe, reaching Britain a week later. Four days after, Environment Secretary Kenneth Baker told Parliament, "The effects of the cloud hve already been assessed and none presents a risk to health in the UK."

That this was a deliberate lie is beyond doubt. Worse, it was merely the first in a long series. The evidence was given in a recent "New Scientist' article, written by David Webster, a former dviser to the House of Commons Environment Committee. So what is the truth? Seven weeks before Chernobyl, the National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB) recommeded a new limit for exposure of the public to artificial radiation (apart from medical before the ban in June.

It stretches the bounds of belief to snapping point to say, as the Welsh Secretary did, that "there is no evidence" that lambs with high radiation levels had been eatern. That this statement is technically correct is in fact an indictment of the government's failure to monitor radiation levels in fresh meat and vegetables. In badly affected Strathclyde, only three sprigs of parsley and leek were tested — the leek was over EEC limits!

After Chernobyl, the government claimed to accept the 1 mSv limit but really used the old limit (five times higher!) to decide whether lamb was fit to eat.

Deaths It is obvious that deaths, iIness and genetic damage will occur in Britain due to Chernobyl. As early as 6 May, the

----- pull-quotes -----

Workers' Liberty-

18p postage from SO, Pr Box 823,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 290

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →