Hungarian Tragedy
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Peter Fryer was a reporter for the Daily Worker - predecessor of the Morning Star - sent out to cover the events in Hungary in 1956. What the British Communist Party had wanted was a servile description of the struggle of "Socialist Hungary' to resist 'counter-revolution'. That's not what they got.
First the Daily Worker's editors had to change Fryer's dispatches; then they had to suppress them; and later they expelled him from the Party.
Peter Fryer wrote about what he actually saw in Hungary: not counter-revolutionaries, fascists and reactionaries, but millions of ordinary working class people rising up against state tyranny, poverty and national oppression.
He saw the Soviet tanks, obeying Moscow's orders, move in to mow them down.
Fryer's book, which he wrote immediately in 1956, is a masterful denunciation of Stalinist hypocrisy, deceit and moral corruption. As he puts it, the book "poured itself on the page white-hot" . It is an angry, PETER FRYER outraged, indignant defence of the Hungarian revolution against its physical and ideological assassins.
And it is deeply moving.
Thirty years on Fryer's polemic has lost none of its vividness; his disgust at the whole experience has lost none of its emotional and political force.
-Trotsky Fryer was soon after won to Trotskyism. But Hungarian Tragedy is striking among other things for the extent to which he had already broken with the ideological worldview of the 'Communist' Parties. His conclusions point towards an attempt to reform these parties; but his politics are not those of a confused and disillusioned Stalinist.
This account is no mere emotional outburst. Fryer is extremely clear on a number of political questions that many would-be Trotskyists equivocate over thirty years on. He notes that some Hungarian workers looked to the West for help, and comments: "I for one do not regard these as counter-revolutionaries. If after eleven years the working people, goaded beyond bearing, look to the West for succour, whose fault is that? If the Americans are guilty of seeking to foster counterrevolution...surely the Rakosis and the Geros are a hundred times more guilty for providing the soil in which seeds sown by the Americans could grow". . (p.23). «It did not need American-trained emigres to influence the people" - (p.32).
Fryer ridicules the idea that the Hungarian people were either 'subjectively' or 'objectively' (intentionally or not) in favour of capitalism, and pours scorn on attempts to justity the second Soviet invasion as a "regrettable necessity"
Yet he is absolutely forthright: *But even if Nagy had been making and presence to convey thé than life heroics of Otello.
The story is about the 'green-eyed god' of jealousy. Otello descends from his miraculously saved ship as a hero, the vanquisher of the Turkish fleet.
But he's risen so high only to be brought down by the insidious poison of his ensign, lago, who feels slighted by Otello's choice of Cassio rather than him for captain.
Hero For a respected hero, adored by his wite, Desdemona, Otello very easily talis prey to suspicion when lago beings hinting of an affair between Cassio and Desdemona. Otello is all too ready to believe that Desdemona might prefer the blonde, handsome Cassio to him - he fears his blackness is a handicap.
lago resents this "thick-lipped savage' and seeks to destroy him.
The film does go over the top at times. Belief must be suspended when the mortally wounded Otello is still able to sing in full voice.
Desdemona is almost too cloyingly sweet, and she's unbelievably passive - she seems almost eager to give up Soviet tanks concessions all along the line to fascism, even if counter-revolution had succeeded, even if White Terror had been raging, it must be said, said openly and with emphasis, that from the standpoint of socialist principle, the Soviet Union would still not have been justified in intervening..It was a clear and flagrant breach of...(the principle) that no nation can be free if it oppresses other nations." (p.68).
How many toy-town *Trotskyists" today would claim such Desdemona and Otello her life. lago is fully convincing and I felt rather relieved when he got speared at the end. clarity on this issue?
Fryer's condemnation of Stalinism, of official Moscow 'communism' is extremely powerful. *Stalinism is Marxism with the heart cut out, de-humanised, dried, frozen, petrified, rigid, barren. It is concerned with 'the line'. , not with the tears of Hungarian children..." (p.79).
Fryer's book is a socialist ciassic. It cannot be recommended too strongly. Its republication is a great service to the labour movement.
The music is dramatic and the singers in fine voice. If you've never been to an opera, give it a try. ON THE
----- pull-quotes -----
HUNGARIAN Clive Bradley reviews Peter Fryer's book on Hungarian revolt a 1956: "Hungarian Tragedy".