From mass strikes to guerilla warfare Resistance in Peru
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-10-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Last week I tried to identify some of the distinctive features of the Marxist method of studying issues. I concluded by saying that Marxism shares with orthodox social science a commitment to checking theories against facts, but they go about this in different ways.
Take economics for example. Orthodox economics starts from a theoretical 'model'. Society is a collection of individuals. Each possesses a certain amount of "abour' or 'capital' • Labour and capital can be combined in certain technical proportions to produce certain goods. Each individual sells so much labour, or so much capital, buying with the proceeds various goods; his or her choice is made on the principle of maximising 'utility' This model can be developed further by complex mathematical calculations.
All orthodox economists will admit, however, that real life is not like that. So they supplement the basic model by countless specialised sub-theories. Keynesian economics, for example, is all about what happens to the basic model when individuals hang on to cash for a while rather than spending their income promptly:
By refining and multiplying subtheories, orthodox economics can bring itself closer and closer to the facts.
Checked
But the basic assumptions and concepts are never checked against the facts. And the question is never asked: why do individuals behave economically in this dogeat-dog way? Concepts are not clarified. What is 'capital'? Factories and machines? Money? Some muddy mixture of the two?
The basic model is 'ideological': it is a set of spectacles through which to view the world which is determined not by any critical analysis but by unreasoning acceptance of the mental framework of a particular class at a particular time.
Thus orthodox economists can use their 'model' - drawn from the assumptions of the middle class in industrial capitalist society - for studying very different societies.
They talk about 'capital' and returns on capital' in the Middle Ages. Of course they discover that earlier societies operated irrationally' and modern capitalism is, give or take a few details, 'rational' . A great scientific discovery! But it is nothing but a rehash of what they implicitly assumed in the first place.
Marxist research has to start, like any other, with the facts as structured by current 'common sense What distinguishes Marxism is that it then attempts a critical and historical analysis of concepts.
It digs beneath 'price' and "profit" , for example, to value and labour-time. And more than that. Marx commented on some economists who, like him, believed that value was determined by labour-time, that they had never asked the questions why labour was represented by value, and what sort of labour was so represented. Marx asked those uestions.
Marxists cannot, of course, escape from their own time and circumstances. Their concepts, like anyone else's, reflect the viewpoint of a particular class at a particular time: the working class in industrial capitalism, But Marxism has this advantage:
that it undertakes to explain other viewpoints as not merely mistakes" but reflections of other plass interests, and to argue why its viewpoint is supenut. of Peru.
Last week's article described the military coup of 1968, which was followed by a reformistnaitonalist policy under General Velasco.
Much of the left rallied to Velasco. But the US was hostile, and the military elite itself became divided.
Peru became increasingly isolated in the continent. And when Velasco began to develop an authoritarian personality cult, a group of progressive army officers formed an alliance with the moderate officers to topple Velasco.
However the second period of military rule, under General Morales Bermudez, soon moved right, expelling the progressive officers and reversing many of the previous period's reforms. Bermudez also introduced a stabilisation deflationary economic programme.
Faced with a cut in their living standards and the withdrawal of many of the previous gains they had made under Velasco, the working class responded with a series of mass strikes which reached its climax in the July 1977 general strike and the 81 day national strike of the teachers' union, Sutep, in May 1978. The ferocity and extent of the struggles forced the military to announce a time-table for the return to civilian rule beginning with an election for a Constituent Assembly in 1978, to be followed by presidential and congressional elections in 1980. The elections for the Assembly took place against a background of violent strikes, massive unrest and increasing repression. In spite of the repression, the left had managed to put together two main fronts, the Focep, headed by Hugo Blanco, which was an alliance of Trotskyists, independents, and the small pro-Albanian party; and the UDP, the Democratic and Popular Unity, which consisted of many Maoist and Mariatuguist groups.
Boycott
However the largest Maoist party decided to boycott the elections. The left groupings obtained 30% of the vote, the highest percentage they had ever received, with Focep obtaining 12.3% which was to represent the high-point of Trotskyist influence in Peru. But the Assembly was dominated by the centre right, and after three years of mass mobilisations and repression the left and the mass movements seemed unable to cope with the new situation. Haya in a characteristic opportunistic alliance with the right became President of the Assembly, and just before his death signed the new constitution which enfranchised illiterates.
Haya's death threw APRA into turmoil, and led to a bitter internal feud. The left too split after the failure of the Revolutionary Left Alliance to work together. The left entered the campaign with five separate groupings, and in the 1980 elections their total vote dropped considerably from their 1978 high.
APRA's internal feuding, and the strong-armed tactics of their Presidential candidate also led to a decline in the APRA vote. The clear winner of the 1980 elections was Belaunde, the victim of the 1968 coup. Almost unnoticed at the time Sendero attacked a polling booth, and called for a boycott of the elections. Significantly in the areas around Ayacucho, where | Sendero unorthodox measures. Above all he initiated a programme of economic recovery in place of the orthodox recessionary policies of the IMF. This economic emergency plan raised wages including that of the minimum wage, improved agricultural prices, reduced interest rates, froze prices after increasing electricity prices, and devalued with a promise to maintain the exchange rate for a year.
Cut In addition the military budget, especially for hardware, was severely cut (for example an order for 26 French Mirages was cut to 12); and payments on the debt restricted to 10% of exports. The latter action in particular has aroused the wrath of the international financial community, especially as Garcia has accompanied his action with ringing denunciations of imperialism and the unjust distribution of the world's wealth. As a consequence Peru has received little new foreign credit, and its failure to maintain its payments to the IMF led that institution to declare Peru ineligible for further borrowings. Although the economy has performed quite well with inflation falling and growth resuming, there are worries that the foreign exchange situation could become critical.
In many ways Garcia has stolen the left's clothes, leaving them trailing behind him. Garcia ordered a halt to the use of barbaric methods to counter the terrorism of Sendero,gave legal status to the Indian communities of Ayacucho, and has attempted to boost the income of the rural poor both to stem the emigration to Lima (Sendero was picking up considerable support among this group and weaken the support for Sendero. His policy seemed to be working when, during a meeting of the Socialist International in Lima, the armed forces killed over 400 Sendero prisoners in a prison riot. Violence is never far from the surface in Peru. If Garcia fails then the alternative is not likely to be the IU or a resurgence of Trotskyism, but a military take-over and the growth of Sendero.
Socialist Orgamber no 290
----- pull-quotes -----
OF MARXISM Explaining
Second part of Phil O'Brien's analysis