Debating federalism
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
I was interested by Liam Conway's letter a few weeks ago about his experience when he argued for a federal united Ireland in his local Labour Party.
I have recently debated this issue in my ward Labour Party and in a workshop at the Communist Party's 'Left Unlimited' weekend school with Clare Short MP and Matt Merrigan (former president of the Irish In the ward there was a brief debate between myself and a right-winger, and then a vote: the great majority abstained. After the meeting I was told: "Yes, some federal solution seems to be the answer in Ireland. But I can't see how At 'Left Unlimited' Clare Short agreed "Some degree of federalism will be there". But her focus, and that of Matt Merrigan and CP speakers too, was on the British state They said that if British troops pulled out immediately, there would be a terrible sectarian civil war in Northern Ireland; but "if Britain Unionisis last Nivember in Belfast burning an effigy of Thatcher pulled out on a planned and organis- uninterest rer cratic: pro- persuade them that they are green ed basis, then there would be no Now withdrawal with a political settlement is better than withdrawal Sympathisers ofg OrkeR Parwithout; but the essence of the matter ty said that the ans rer was for a general socialist propaganda, the is not less or more speed — just being Labour government te legislate social SWP also have a reliance on the slow about it won't necessarily bring and democratic- improvements in Kritish state. On the front page of a settlement! - but what a Northern Ireland which will facilitate Socialist Worker a few months ago democratic political settlement could class unity thet (after which, at a hey called for the British state to later stage, the issue of a united lisarm the Protestants.
As far as l can see, the left Labour' view represented by Clare Sul Da bekina all TINR memhers to hand in Short differs trom the not-very-eit view in my ward mainly by greater Catholic and Protestant wenters for confidence in the capitalist state to immediate economic sunuggles and see off the Protestant workers! (I say for socialism. Very good. But what Protestant workers especially, since does it have to do with Partition or a Matt Merrigan was emphatic that it was chiefly the workers, not the Pro- Sociaiist propaganda and testant bourgeoisie, who militantly economic militancy may convince oppose a united Ireland). A strange Protestant workers of the need for basis for a left wing to define itself! Catholic-Protestant class unity on Interestingly, most of the speakers economic issues (which many of them from the floor had the same great understand anyway) even of the confidence in the British state dealing supremacy of class issues over nawith the Protestants (and the same tional/communal issues: it will not The Big Bang and the growing in- This is not • new problem: the rightwing Wilson governments of the '60s, ternationalisation of capital which had far tighter controls at their markets described in SO 290 raise disposal than exist today, were some fundamental questions unable to avoid the economic about socialist economic pressures from international finance shuffling capital around the world.
Traditionally, the Labour Left has We should have some more discussion in SO on the sort of economic Strategy - import control?, en supported the Alternative Economic croachment" on capitalist power through planning agreements and limited nationalisations. SO has always argued that this strategy is both nationalist - import controls cause unemployment elsewhere -and utopian - it is not possible to "control" capitalism or to create socialism behind the tariff walls of a The forces behind the 'Big Bang"
reinforce this argument. Dennis Skinner asks in SO 290 "Why is it not possible to have statutory controls over the export of capital?" (in the programme for the next Labour government). The shortest answer is that it just wouldn't work: as soon as any government or potential government announced its intentions to impose controls, the capital it was trying to control would be moved elsewhere within minutes. As Martin Thomas pointed out in SO 290, these markets are outside the control of any national government, whether Hattersley thinks he can get round this problem by winning the confidence of the international bankers and showing that a Labour government would not be a threat to their interests - hence his recent trip to talk to the US in New York. Even so, any sort of Labour government will still face the same problem of having no control over the capital markets.
TOECENTRE As the Tories increase their efforts to frighten unemployed people off claiming benefit, new figures show that £750 million a year goes unclaimed in supplementary benefit.
The figures, announced About 25% of violence is estimated to be wifebattering; more certain figures rate domestic violence at one-tenth of unemployed in a parliamentary written reply last week, are for 1983. The government's own estimates for social security fraud are much lower - £4.7 million to E135 million.
The Restart scheme has been used to bully nal police report leaked to the Observer last Sunday, the reason for this is that the police do not take wife-battering TUC). it would work...
dealing with the Protestants.
claimants into signing off - 2% of those who go through the mill have their money cul oll, and bloodbath" another 8% or so abandon their claims - and now the government is planning new measures to grill new claimants on their availability for work' Department of Employ ment workers have been given "targets'. They must be. Hence federalism. achieve "at least 30 signoffs per year" - not by finding jobs, of course, but by intimidation. workers 'from ba Ireland can be raised)
Speakers Tom the SOc workers
----- pull-quotes -----
A Y0. gramme to reach