[Worth thinking about, perhaps just as a Xmas…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Worth thinking about, perhaps just as a Xmas gift, is the recently published 'The Labours and Researches of Evans'. Cartoons by Phil Evans on Tory Employment Laws, privatisation, unemployment, racism and South Africa, get the serious message across but in a far from gloomy way.
Price £1.50; published by the Labour Research Department.
Still less is it clear how we are going to get one. Birchall says we need a centralised 1, disciplined party. But often it is difficult to see what defines this party other than centralisation, discipline and a commitment to workers' self-activity. There is a gaping hole in the middle - political ideas; policies for workers to fight for. "Workers' self-activity' in itself is not a policy.
Birchall makes his point with remarkable frankness. "Such an alternative must have two components: on the one hand, a generalised account of an alternative society based on workers' democracy; on the other, the building up of workers' confidence in their own self-activity through piecemeal struggles in the present." (p.220).
This hardly differs in essence from the approach of the left wing, of He poses the issue falsely: it is not a question of whether or not it is possible to "transform social democracy from within', but of how a revolutionary party is to be built. But in any case, Birchall's approach leads him to a bizarre argument.
"But on the few occasions when the left do come out on top, their victory is likely to be a hollow one, for the right simply change the rules of the game... Where they can't bend the rules, they walk out. In 1920 the French Socialist Party voted by a maioritv of three to one to ioin the Communist International; the right wing left to form a new party"
The formation of the French Communist Party proves the impossibility of defeating the right wing, then, does it? This is so ridiculous that it leaves you speechless, or whatever the equivalent is if you're reading.
Nevertheless it's a good introduction to the crimes of reformism, and a useful reference book. Birchall has certainly done us all a favour by gathering the information together in one bookin
Scan page 10
SSİN Socialist Students in NOLS