BOX Lessons of Greece
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
inne 1900 The fr riendship between the two is ONS pre-1917 Social Democircy: truggles now, plus general propagi ada for socialism in the future Struggles in the present are not always piecemeal; and as soon as a struggle is more than pieeemeal: -and sometimes before - it Hesents political problems. What do we do about the Tory government! What do we replace them with? How do we get an alternative?
Unless a political challenge is mounted to reformism, unless revolutionaries can give answers to the overall running of society - how to end unemployment, etc., - the piecemeal struggles will come up against a brick wall and be defeated.
Birchall poses no such alternative; and of course he rejects the idea of working within parties like the Labour Party that have deep links with the trade unions.
By lan Swindale When, at the beginning of this year, Channel 4 screened a fourpart documentary on the Greek Civil War (Greece - The Hidden War), which for the first time in forty years presented to a British audience the view of the defeated left on those events, the self-appointed guardians of "the truth" about Greece within the British Establishment protested vociferously to the Independent Broadcasting Authority.
Being influential people with friends in high places, they were able to secure from Channel an assurance that the programme would not be sold abroad, that it would not be shown again in Britain in its existing form and that in order to provide the necessary "balance" - as if forty years of right wing propaganda mascarading as history hadn't been sufficient - further programmes would Be made presenting alternative views of the Greek Civil War to that roalained in the original programme Monday night's studio discussion Greece a search for truth was presumably ar attempt by Channel 4 to carry out its pledge.
I must say that if I had been one of the right wingers who had lodged the original complaint, I would be no happier after seeing Monday night's offering.
Channel 4 had assembled in the studio a number of leading experts on modern Greek history and asked them to comment on the views of three participants in the events.
Scrappy Unfortunately, the programme was, to say the very least, scrappy. Given a couple of minutes each to present their respective views, the participants were unable to elaborate in any depth on their own experiences.
The experts, likewise were only given a few, short opportunities to express their views which, in contrast to the participants, were based on detailed study of the period and therefore tended to approach the question from a different perspective.
Since the programme-makers' attempt to summarise the history of the period was crammed into a twominute introduction, unless the viewer had a reasonably detailed knowledge of the history of events in Greece at the end of World War 2, it would have been a very difficult discussion to follow.
From the point of view of socialists interested in learning the lessons of the British intervention in Greece and the Civil War it was a particularly frustrating experience. All the participants in the programme, most of whom seem to have beenbrought from America and various European countries, presumably at great expense, would have been worth listening to.
In particular, Heinz Richter, author of an excellent book on Dritich intervention in Greece and Stratis Haviaras, author of two fine HELL VOLUME novels in English set in Greece during and after the Second world war, would have been particularly worth listening to.
Instead, all the experience and knowledge of this important but much neglected period of history that had been assembled in the studio was wasted in a debate that rarely got its teeth into the main issues, which added nothing to the original programme and which will have satisfied neither the right or the left wing protagonists in the debate on the Greek Civil War.