Putting the record straight
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
launch pad for a national invited at the request of some SSiN Organiser no 291 November 1986 page 10€ NUS is in deep trouble with its anti-loans campaign. SSiN have proposed a nationally integrated campaign. This would tie together our demands for a t35 a week minimum grant with a rolling programme of direct action against loans and cuts, using the November 12 day of action as a launch pad for a national demonstration.
Ideally, the demonstration would have been held on November 28, the day NUS submits to the Baker Review on student financial support.
But this strategy has been rejected; instead NUS continues to compartmentalise and the highlight of the loans campaign will be, on President Vicky Phillips' say-so, getting students to sign a pledge committing them to take personal action against Loans should they be introduced!
Not surprisingly, many colleges are particularly unhappy. —Over 50 colleges wrote to NUS executive last week demanding that a national demonstration be called, showing the level of dissatisfaction with the Executive's timidity.
This Wednesday, NUS is organising a briefing day on loans. During the lunch break there will be a fringe meeting to discuss how to rescue the campaign and how to intervene at NUS conference to ensure the Executive are forced to campaign proPolly Vittorini's report of the SSIN AGM, 'No alternative from SSIN' (SA, 24th October) is more bilious than factual.
Firstly, the Middle East debate at the AGM. Polly asserts, 'the resolution. reserved its condemnations not for the murderous policies of the state of Israel but for the bombings at Rome and Vienna airports'. The facts suggest the opposite.
The motion does condemn civilian bombings and it also reads, 'Israel rules the Palestinian Arabs as a dictatorial colonial power. It maintains control (in the West Bank) by systematic brutality and a permanent. reign of terror.. This is hardly evidence of, as Polly puts it, SSiN having 'capitulated to the racism of the Zionist State'.
However if rejection of the democratic secular state slogan is this. capitulation then we suggest that Polly takes up the argument with her international co-thinkers, especially Ernest Mandel, whose own position is closer to SSiN's than the democratic secular state formulation.
Polly asserts that Tony Greenstein was 'clearly invited to the AGM only to give the semblance of a debate. But had Polly bothered to ask she would have been told that Tony was invited at the request of some SSiN comrades who agree with him. Tony and his co-thinkers got equal speaking time to SO supporters —which in our minds constitutes a debate and not a 'semblance of a debate' Polly complains that SSiN discussed making direct links with South African trade unions rather than how NUS could be pushed into campaigning on its own policies. In fact we did discuss the main problem with NUS carrying out its own policies - that FE Anti-Apartheid Groups are not seen as very important, but this is not NUS's anti-apartheid roblem The biggest overall with main problem is that NUS is sectarian. The existing policy of NUS rules out possibility of NUS adopting detainees, organising strike support work exchanging materials with South African students unions, should they want to. We think this sectarianism is important, even if Polly does not.
Polly considers the lack of detailed discussions on 'the key issues being In Socialist Action tw weeks ago (SA 151), Pollv Vittorini, a student at the School of Oriental and Africa Studies (London) wro an article attacking Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN) and its AGM for being undemocratic and unrepresentative. Here we print a reply jointly signed by 36 NUS members from up down the country, Vittorini's original article and a second letter to Socialist Action following their refusal to print our reply That, when added to the debate on the Middle East, the South Africa workshop, various organisational discussions, including elections and lesbian and gay, and black caucuses, amounts to a lot of discussion for a one-day conference. And it is interesting that Polly has absolutely nothing to say about what we actually did discuss. We can only conclude this silence is because she has no idea what the left in NUS are doing, let alone what they should be doing.
Polly observes that many SSiN comrades are SO supporters. But to conclude from that that SSiN must be undemocratic is a non-sequitur. Could Polly please give us evidence of undemocratic practices?
Let's have OUR»
Scottish students' demo On the subject of democracy it seems pertinent to ask Polly a few questions. At which meeting of Campaign Group Youth was she elected to be the observer at the SSiN AGM? At which meeting was there a position taken on the Middle East? Someone from SSiN was at all the recent meetings and neither decisions were taken at any of them.
Following on from that we would like to ask Polly some more questions, and these concern the discussion she refers to as 'arousing much interest at the SSiN event itself. What is the structure of Campaign Group Youth? Who makes the decisions? Who can join and when does it meet?
SSiN are che major opposition to the LCC in the entire student movement precisely because we give answers to the real questions and problems students in NOLS and NUS face. We try to deal with reality as we See it, not to prepackaged formulae. We take seriously our work in NOLS and NUS which is why SsiN wants to develop a relationship with the Campaign Group. And that is also the reason why we are more than happy to challenge Polly to a debate, at any time, any college on any subject of her choosing.
Simon Pottinger, Vice-President, NUS; Melanie Gingel, NUS Executive; Michele Carlisle, NUS Executive; Sue Rossiter, NOLS NC Shaun Hayes, Sabbatical Officer, Essex University; Lee Robson, Sabbatical Officer, Warwick University; Dave Brennan, MANUS Convenor; Richard Bailey, North Yorks NUS Convenor; Andy Rathbone, Wessex Area NUS Convenor; Jim Kairnes, Welfare Officer, Langside FE; Martin Donoghue, Area Executive member, Aberdeen; Martin Snowden, General Secretaiy, Kent Area NUS; Mark Tatum, Bradford University Welfare Officer; Ruth Cockeroft, Sheffield University Executive; Jill Mountford, General Secretary, North Staffs Poly; Paul Carey, Staffordshire Area NUS Executive; Colin O' Driscoll, Berks Area NUs Convenor; Paul Magarry, MANUS Executive; Steve Kyden, Chair, Manchester Polytechnic Labour Club; Sandra Cartlidge, MANUS Women's Officer and Manchester University Labour Club Executive; Tim Hopson, Sabbatical Officer, UMIST; Martin Pagel, MANUS Welfare Officer; Rachel Kennedy, MANUS Treasurer; Sian Richards, Site President, South Manchester Community College; Colleen Fairbrother, SE Wales Area NUS Convenor; Stuart Beeston, Sabbatical Officer, UCL; Neophitos Ttofias, Sheffield University Labour Club Executive; Gail Cameron, Sheffield University Women's Group secretary; Richard Aplin, Sheffield University Anti-Apartheid Group Secretary; Reb Short, Secretary, People's College Students Union; Neil Stonelake, PCL Student Council; Grahame Fairbrother, UCC Executive; Deb Strawbridge, North
----- pull-quotes -----
Photo: Steve McTaggart (IFL). EDUCATION