Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labour and public opinion GANG

Socialist Organiser no. 292, 16 November 1986 · scan p. 3 · about 1,663 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Socialist Organiser no 292 13 November 1986 page

Public opinion in Britain is moving to the left. That's the conclusion from a detailed survey of attitudes just published.

In 1983, 37% of people were

against government measures to share out income and wealth more equally. Now it's only 28%. Then, 27% thought holding down inflation was more important than reducing unemployment; the 1985 figure is 22%. 49% used to want less state ownership of industry; now only 30% do.

Support for nuclear disarmament is higher than ever: the proportion who think that nuclear weapons make Britain safer has gone down from 60% in 1983 to 54% in 1985 and 50% in 1986. In 1983, 53% were against reducing military spending;now, only 42% The percentage supporting woman's right to choose on abortion has risen from 37% to 49%. Those thinking that sex before marriage is wrong have declined from 27% to 23%Other polls confirm this picture.

Gallup reports that the percentage of people saying that trade unions are 'a good thing' is, at 67%, the highest since 1964. The proportion saying that trade unions are 'too powerful' has gone down from

84% in 1979 to 45% todayOpinion polls, of course, are notoriously fallible. The figures should not be exEDITORIAL aggerated. Attitudes on many issues are still very anti-socialist. On some questions the shift has been to the right (notably, gay rights: the reason there is probably media coverage of AIDS). And some of the figures may reflect a static public opinion which now appears more to the left' because the world around it has moved to the 'right, with unions being bashed and state industries sold off.

But a broad trend is clear. And it smashes to bits all that the Labour leaders (backed up by the Communist Party and Marxism Today) have been saying about the need for Labour to move rightwards to follow public opinion.

Roy Hattersley is in a 22%rightwing minoritv when he assures BOOI

bankers and industrialsts that a Labour government would put controling inflation before reducing unemployment. Labour's leaders are in a 42% right-wing minority when they promise the armed forces chiefs that they would not

reduce military spending.

What explains the combination a shift to the left in social attitudes with the depressed state of industrial combativity and the labour movement, and the only modest improvement for Labour in the polls? It is, surely, lack of confidence.

Most working class people want a more equal, fairer, freer and less militaristic society than Tory Britain. But they're not confident about how to get it, or whether it is even possible.

And Labour's current stance encourages that lack of confidence. The Tories seem to be upper-class brutes (over half of people tell pollsters that they think Margaret Thatcher cares nothing for ordinary working class people), but they also appear to be confident rulers - people who know Local bobby swings truncheon w Photo: Martin Shakeshaft. quently burgled and followed by two men who stopped him for supposed speeding offences on more than one occasion.

After being stopped and taken to a police station on supposed drugs charges, he was beaten up and given an 'anal inspection' for drugs which left him severely ruptured and in need of medical attention.

Later he was beaten up in an alleyway and had a cigarette stubbed out on his cheek. Steven Shaw believes the men who beat him up were policemen, Martin Walker believes that there is a group of policemen within Manchester who are involved not only in these two cases but in the cases of people like Jackie Berkeley who was tried for wasting police time after alleging she had been raped in Moss Side police station.

This 'cell' of criminal police operates within a law of their own. They appear to use physical violence and intimidation to deter those who have a just and serious complaint against the police force.

Recently Steven Shaw fled the country. He rears the police will prosecute him for wasting police time

Labour apologetic, mouthed

maybe, but

how to run a government and to administer bitter medicine where it is necessary

comes across as shitty, and mealy well-intentioned,

feeble.

"Credible"

Labour's leaders now seem to think that only one thing ranks higher than chasing a vaguelyperceived centre-right public opinion to win votes - and that's assuring the ruling class that the lef tism of the early '80s is finished with. (The recent pamphlet Investing in People' was distributed free to 2000 bankers, industrialists, civil servants and so on, in an attempt - as Labour Weekly put it - to convince the Establishment that Labour is "credible').

That's the way to continue to sap workers' confidence. Labour nationally - and local parties, if the national leaders won't do it -should take a different tack, arguing a bold alternative and seeking ¡ to raise workers' confidence in our ability to reshape society. Steven Shaw's credibility and frighten him off from pursuing his case.

Steven Shaw's father says that his son has lost all faith in getting justice, and leaving the country was the only way that he could resume some sort of 'normal' life.

Martin Walker's book is an important record of corruption and violence within Manchester police force. The questions it asks need to be answered by the likes of Chief Constable Anderton and the Manchester labour movement should follow up the allegations and demand justice for people like Steven Shaw.

The police can choose to answer the allegations. What is more likely is that they will defend their record and protect their image by prosecuting those making the allegations. The labour movement must be prepared for such a move and mobilise to defend those who may become victims of their own legitimate complaints.

*With Extreme Prejudice" by Martin Walker can be obtained from the Justice for Steven Shaw Campaign, c/o Manchester. University, Students Union. These days you cannot open a newspaper without reading something about AIDS. But giving Paul Johnson his head to sound off on the subject was surely an act of gross irresponsibility on the part of the Daily Mail.

Paul Johnson is "an intellectual" of the radical right. Back in the '60s he was a lefty of Maoist persuasion. In the early 70s he switched over to more or less mainstream reformism and edited the New Statesman for a while. By 1979 he was a born-again Thatcherite. Contempt for the working class has been the only consistent feature in his critical evolution.

What he's against is young people being told about it in schools or anyone at all discussing birth control, the practicalities of preventing sexually transmitted diseases or - horror of horrors - what actually...sort of...goes on. Between men and women it's beastly enough. Between men and men (women and women hasn't occurred to him yet) it's... well...just horrible.

Paul Johnson's personal problems are a matter best left for in-depth discussion between him and a properly qualified psychiatrist. They become positively dangerous when national newspapers give him space to air his views on subjects like AIDS (in last Tuesday's Mail) or sex education (coming shortly in the Telegraph).

Most serious commentators realise ignorance remains the major enemy in the battle against AIDS and that the recent government advertising campaign did litte to promote elementary practical measures like the use of condoms or to dispel widely held myths like the possibility of picking up AIDS from lavatory seats.

For Paul Johnson, however, AIDS is an excellent opportunity to give all his pet prejudices a hearing.

After attacking Labour's policy on nuclear power (yes, he manages to work that in!) Johnson goes on to assert that "Labour's alliance with the homosexual lobby, especially in local government, entail real risks of hastening the spread of the undoubtedly large-scale killer AIDS."

No evidence of argumentation, 01 course: trivial things like facts are just too tedious for a great mind like Johnson's. He does present an argument of sorts for his next point: AIDS is clearly "associated with drug abuse" . Well done, Paul! "The government is at war against the drug traffickers" • Therefore it does not help ifthe Labour spokesmen and councillors attack the police whenever they conduct large scale and much-needed operations against drug traffic in the inner-cities". So that's what was going on in Handsworth and St. Pauls - AIDS prevention exercises!

All this may seem laughable rather than pernicious. But the really nasty stuff is yet to come: *In Nairobi...70% of female prostitutes are believed to be infected. The control and screening of arrivals in Britain from African countries therefore form an obvious part of preventive measures...it does not help if Labour raise the hideous cry of "racist" whenever the government brings in new entry rules."

This is an idea we can expect to hear much more of so it might be worth noting that recently the DHSS rejected on the grounds that either all visitors should be tested (causing chaos at the major ports, etc) or none. And what about British visitors returning from, say, America?

Johnson's other brilliant proposal is to "discourage sexual contact among homosexuals and to warn the population at large that homosexual activity now carries the risk of death"

The problem here is that Labour is now in the grip of "homosexual militants" using the rates to promote their propaganda among school children in the guise of sex education"

No mention of the need for more funding of research; no discussion of ideas like mass mailing and Thatcher's television advertising; no practical proposals at all save backing the police at all. times, tightening up on immigration controls on blacks and informing the public of the little known fact that there is a connection between homosexuality and AIDS.

"On the issue of AIDS," concludes our great thinker, "Labour is playing politics with human lives" . No one would accuse Paul Johnson"of doing that, of coursé.!

----- pull-quotes -----

lith extreme prejudice. The police are out to undermine

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 292

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →