Banning anti-Zionists
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): a letter, signed Tony Greenstein, Labour Movement for Palestine, with the editor's reply in italics; transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (Alan Gilbert's letter The left sobers up, now on its own page). The page head dates the issue 13 November 1986. "attepts" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
In his article 'Free speech and the fight against racism', Simon Pottinger makes some interesting points. However, in highlighting the misapplication of the no platform tactic viz. the banning of pro-Zionist Jewish Societies, he ignores the other side of the coin, i.e. the consistent and continual attempts by the Union of Jewish Students to ban their opponents.
This has taken a number of different forms, including leaflets which attempt to equate the PLO with the National Front by the Glasgow Jewish Society.
Two years ago UJS made strenuous attepts to ban Lenni Brenner, author of 'Zionism in the Age of Dictators', which detailed the record of the Zionist movement during the '30s and '40s in Europe. Despite his record in the civil rights movement and his clear opposition to all forms of racism, an attempt was made to ban him as a fascist and racist.
In recent weeks, UJS have attempted to ban me from speaking on various campuses in conjunction with the leadership of NOLS. At the School of Oriental and African Studies, UJS attempted to ban me, despite my successful opposition to a passage in the Palestinian motion which would have banned the local Jewish Society.
At Thames Polytechnic, following a letter from the Chair of NOLS, Ben Lucas, the Labour Club was forced to postpone a meeting at which I was to speak and institute a debate on Palestine at which I would have been one of the speakers. UJS then attempted to use the 'no platform' policy to have me banned by the union. At both colleges UJS failed in their attempts to ban me.
The reason they failed was because it is hardly likely that if I were, in the words of a leaflet distributed by UJS at Thames, "a racist and an anti-semite", that I would have been the target of repeated attacks by fascist organisations, both physical and verbal.
I hope, therefore, that both Simon Pottinger and SO will, when they attack the misguided attempts to ban Jewish Societies, also condemn equally forthrightly the attempts by UJS to restrict and curtail those of their opponents, in particular Jewish anti-Zionists, to put the contrary view on campuses.
Editor's note: Yes, of course, Socialist Organiser supports Tony Greenstein's right to express his opinion on Israel, and we condemn attempts to silence him.