Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Different approaches to childbirth

Socialist Organiser no. 292, 16 November 1986 · scan p. 8 · about 609 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Apartheid, people's sanctions is an all-inclusive category, including trade union action. In fact, present at the workshop was a trade unionist who had fought, unsuccessfully, for a boycott of South African fruit at Portsmouth Health Authority.

Athough the conference platform was staid and bureaucratic, and a very worrying, clearly wrong and potentially dangerous view was reiterated many times by platform speakers and in the workshops that the nationalist struggle against the apartheid state was reaching a peak and would soon be successful -"in just a few months" according to one platform speaker - in the workshops some elements of a debate did begin to emerge on some key issues.

This debate needs to be exrended further in East London.

Struthous, Socialist Workers' Party. Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Ro a First meeting of Brent AntiFascist Action. Sunday 23 November, 2.00 p.m., Brent Town Hall. Speakers trom AFA and Searchlight.

SATURDAY 15 NOVEMBER at 10 am, Exhibition Hall, Adrian Boult Complex, Chamberlain Square, Birmingham. Labour Listening to Women on Health, hosted by Jo Richardson, shadow minister for women's rights, Wendy Savage, consultant obstetrician and Dr. Rajinder Lotay, an expert on wellwomen clinics among others. Interviews with panel members between 12-2pm.

Contact Eileen Murfin, 021-236 8884 or Anna Healy, 01-708 1867 Different approaches to childbirths have been much discussed recently, with the Wendy Savage case revolving around the tension between "modern" high-tech methods and womancentred methods.

Comparatively little research has been done to evaluate these different approaches but recently the British Medical Journal carried a report on a survey to see if women who were accompanied and supported by female companions throughout their labour fared differently from those receiving "normal" attention.

The survey was organised by American medical scientists in the Social Security Hospital in Guatemala City. Healthy women having their first baby who were in early labour were asked to participate on arrival at Hospital. It agreeable, they were assigned either to a "control" group, where they received normal care (attention from time to time in a crowded labour ward), or to a group, where in addition they had constant support and companionship from one of three Guatemalan women.

Trained

These women were not trained in obstetrics (childbirth practice) but supplied emotional and physical support, including backrubs, holding hands, explanation and encouragement. Perhaps most important, the mothers-to-be Provos, Prote! working class THE were assured they would never be left alone. The results were striking indeed with far fewer perinatal (around birth) complications in the supported group. For example, while 17% of the 249 "controls" needed Caesarean sections, only 7% of the 168 supported group needed them (43 versus 11). Only 2% of the supported group needed induction of birth (by hormone injection) while 13% of controls did (33 to 4).

Labour

Labour was much shorter in the supported group - 7 hours 40 minutes on average, as opposed to 15½ hours for the controls. Women who lived alone benefitted even more from support. The chance of these findings occurring by accident ranges from 1 in 100 to less than 1 in 1000., The reason probably lies in the anxiety and tension that may attend childbirth, particularly the first one. Adrenalin, released into the bloodstream during stress, reduces contraction of the womb, lengthening labour, and may reduce blood flow to the foetus, with a possible lack of oxygen and risk of stillbirth (a reason for Caesarean sections).

What is now beyond doubt is that constant support can be of enormous benefit during childbirth. Unfortunately, it is also beyond doubt that this Tory government would not be inclined to allow the NHS to pay for such support.

tants

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 292

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →