Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Jungle utopia

Socialist Organiser no. 292, 16 November 1986 · scan p. 9 · about 613 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Belinda went to Mission' Jesuit Father Gabriel (Jeremy Irons) wants to convert the Guarani Indians, living near what was then (1750) the border between the Spanish and Portuguese empires in South America. So he scales a sheer rock face by a huge waterfall, finds a clearing, and starts playing his oboe. The Indians gather round, charmed, and in a trice they are building cathedrals, labouring happily on banana plantations, singing hymns, and smiling fit to burst.

Rodrigo (Robert de Niro), another Jesuit missionary, was previously a slave-trader and murderer. When the Spanish and Portuguese empires, jealous of the over-mighty Jesuits and their obstruction of the slave trade, decide to break up the missions, Rodrigo helps the Indians resist by force of arms while Gabriel resorts to prayer. Both, however, are defeated and killed.

Thus does 'The Mission' make a crite story out of a fascinating episode of history, In the film the Indians are cheerful savages with big hearts and big smiles; in the whole considerable length of the screenplay, they get barely two dozen words of script between them. Usually they are represented by beaming crowd scenes or by winsome children, The Jesuits are cardboard goodiegoodies, with hardly more intelligent dialogue to their account. The only intellectual interchange in the film is when Cardinal Altamirano (Ray McAnally), a Papal envoy sent to persuade the Jesuit missionaries to concede for the greater good of their Order world-wide, muses to himself.

The Jesuit colonies in Paraguay were a unique social experiment. But they were not idyllic utopias. They were organised according to a sort of barracks communism: the Indians owned nothing, receiving however an equal share of the production, and the Jesuits, with their military-type hierarchy, controlled everything.

The colonies established themselves, and grew - they started in the 17th century, and had a population of some 30,000 by mid18th century - with considerable use of the sword. They do seem to have provided a more productive and comfortable way of life for the Indians, and protection from the slavetraders; but they steamrollered the Indians' own culture, and made them into a subject people.

Voltaire

Voltaire, writing at about the time the film Is supposed to depict, described the colonies like this: "The reverend fathers own the whole lot, and the people own nothing; that's what I call a masterpiece of reason and justice...

"An excellent dinner was served on gold plates, and while the Paraguayans ate their maize on wooden dishes in the open field in the full blaze of the sun, his reverence the Colonel retired to the shade of his arbour"

Voltaire supported science and enlightenment, and saw the Jesuits and the Church as defenders of ancient corruption and obscurity - in other words, he was a supporter of the then-new capitalist system, which would despoil the world with fresh ferocity.

All the complexities of this history are flattened out in this film, in favour of a focus on the trite psychological contrast between Gabriel and Rodrigo, the man of prayer versus the man of arms.

Even that is not very well done. Gabriel would have been as out of place in the 18th century Jesuits as in the modern CIA. Rodrigo's conversion from slave-trader to Jesuit is handled by an utterly excessive digression where he kills his brother. DOK Many characters have not only the accents, but also the manner, of late 20th century big-city North Americans.

The film proceeds not by continuous narrative, but by a succession of set-piece scenes. It needs cutting: some of the scenes are prolonged with ludicrous heavy-handedness.!

The scenery is, to be sure, spectacular; and the accompanying music is excellent. ON THE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 292

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →