Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The German revolution

Socialist Organiser no. 292, 16 November 1986 · scan p. 9 · Clive Bradley · about 1,223 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Socialist Organiser no. 292 13 November 1986 page 9 If you have seen Margarethe von Trotta's new film 'Rosa Luxemburg', and want to know more about the revolutionary tumult in Germany at the end of World War 1 during which Luxemburg was murdered, then you should read this book.

As Germany approached defeat, its top circles of bureaucrats and army chiefs became convinced that their rule was in danger. Strikes were sweeping the country.

The ruling class turned to the leaders of the once-Marxist Social Democratic Party (SPD), which had ted itself to the capitalist order by supporting Germany's war effort. On 4 October SPD leaders joined the government.

But the rebellion from below continued to grow. On 4 November a workers' and soldiers' council took power in the port of Kiel. Within the next few days the revolution had spread to all Germany's major cities.

On 9 November the SPD leader Scheidemann, swept along by the excitement of a huge workers' demonstration, declared Germany a Republic. The whole imposing structure of the monarchy had collapsed in a few days.

The SPD leaders formed a joint government — a 'Council of People's Commissars' , they called it - with the more left-wing Independent Social Democrats (USD). They told the workers that this was a socialist government, and they managed to get the Berlin workers' and soldiers' councils to endorse the government: Meanwhile they were assuring the army high command that they would Martin Thomas reviews 'The German Revolu ti and the debate on Soviet power' edited by John Riddell, published by Pathfinder Press.

keep order.

Rosa Luxemburg and her comrades had been in open opposition to the SPD leaders since the beginning of the war, which they denounced as an imperialist war of conquest. Now they argued for the workers' and soldiers' councils to take power into their own hands.

A 'socialist" government in the chancellery in Berlin, they argued, was not the socialist revolution. In a manifesto published on 11 November their slogan was 'Organise the Power Anew from Below'. The workers' and soldiers' councils must replace the factory-owners, the government bureaucrats, and the military hierarchy, rather than tailing behind a "socialist' government which governed in cooperation with those entrenched powers.

The SPD leaders responded by scheduling parliamentary elections for 19 January and arguing that the workers' and soldiers' councils must be subordinate to this parliament. Their hidden message was: leave the permanent state machine intact.

In Berlin, however, the police headquarters had been taken over by the revolutionary workers on 9 November, and the old police force replaced by a force of left-wingers under the leadership of Emil Eichhorn. On 4 January the SPD leaders sacked Eichhorn.

This move provoked a week of ragged fighting in Berlin between the revolutionary workers and the Freikorps, an elite right-wing army unit established to try to give a backbone to the disintegrating armed forces. On 15 January Rosa Luxemburg and her comrade Karl Liebknecht were murdered by the Freikorps.

Revolutionary unrest continued in Germany, on and off, until late 1923, but the revolutionaries never managed to recover from that terrible initial setback.

Power

John Riddell's collection includes not only the appeals by Luxemburg and her comrades for the power of workers' councils or (as they put it) a workers' parliament, but also documents from the SPD and USPD. The comparison with the weasel words of the reformists makes the clarity and insight of the revolutionaries stand out all the more.

Another interesting item in the book is an article by Karl Radek — a leader of the Russian Bolsheviks who had also been active in Germany - about the lessons of the January 1919 Soon after Eichhorn was sacked Karl Liebknecht had been persuaded to put his name to an appeal declaring the SPD government overthrown and a revolutionary government installed in its place. Together with leftwing members of the USPD, he called on the workers to come on the streets for a struggle for power.

In the chaos of those days, Rosa Luxemburg and other central leaders of the just-formed Communist Party did not know what Liebnkecht was doing. When they heard, they were shocked and angry: they considered Liebknecht's move utterly premature, a dangerous exercise in toy-revolution. But they could not agree on an effective policy for orderly retreat.

The revolutionary workers continued to come out on the streets -to find no leadership either from the wavering. USPD or the paralysed Communist Party.

Radek compares this episode with July 1917, when there was a mood among the Petrograd workers for a direct attempt at power in Russia. The Bolsheviks considered it premature. They were able to explain their view. They could not stop the spontaneous revolt, but they gave it a more organised character and helped to limit its inevitable defeat.

What was the difference between Russia and Germany? For Radek it was "the newness of the (German) Communist Party, the absence of a rounded Communist organisation, in which tactical principles are firmly rooted as a result of prolonged collective work... " He points out that even the most experienced leaders of the German Communists had up to then been only agitators and propagandists, concerned exclusively with urging the workers forward, and completely unaccustomed to cold calculations of the tactics of mass struggle.

It is a sobering and vivid illustration of what it means to say that working class revolution requires an organised Marxist leadership.

Fortunately, the Department of Health don't at present go along with this 'radical policy'. But as public criticism of government inaction mounts, I certainly feel no confidence that they won't get pushed in that direction.

The enforcement of the radical approach would require a totalitarian stae compounds in which thousands of people who have the AIDS virus (30,000 to 40,000 in Britain alone) would be rounded up and left to rot. Compulsory screening' testing for the virus - would require draconian measures, too. And there is absolutely no reason to believe that any of it would produce any result -except to make the lives of potential AIDS sufferers a nightmarish misery.

The solution to the AIDS epidemic is a cure, or a vaccine. There are considerable scientific obstacles to the development of either — but so long as the government continues to spend a pathetic £1-2 million on research, those obstacles are not going to be overcome.

In the meantime we need to slap people like our enlightened gentleman in Everyman into detention centres for those suffering from poisonous, reactionary ideas. and see how they like it.

The disease is likely to dominate our lives for some years to come, if we are optimistic. For those who have a single sexual partner (who is faithful), and who are happy with that, it will remain a fairly distant worry. Many people either cannot find a single sexual partner or do not want one. For them, AIDS will be an ever-present thought at the back of the mind. We need to make sure that there is a firm stand against what would amount to the criminalisation not only of AIDS sufferers, but of AIDS VIrUS carriers. Such social brutalitv is a nightmare vision of the future that to my mind is ever worse than the vision of AIDS ever more rampant and out of control.

13 1986

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 292

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →