Don't say'Troops Out, but
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no 292 13 November 1986 page 10 a platform in this country • for the most notorious loyalist bigots -Peter Robinson, William McCrea and Alan Wright.
Of the leaflets distributed at the rally, the most interesting came from the Campaign for Equal Citizenship for Northern Ireland. Bearing all the hallmarks of the Labour Party-based "Orange socialist" Campaign for Labour Representation in Northern Ireland, it argued that the basic problem was British pontical parties "refuse to take members or contest elections in Northern Ireland." An end to this practice would, it argued. "help to end the sectarian political division in Northern Ireland."
Also present at the rally were small contingents from the fascist National Front and British National Party, pursuing their long-standing goal of tempting to forge an alliance betcen British fascism and sections of Aster loyalism. The BNP leaflet called for *Ulster — British Forever! Keep Scotland White! - Free Patnotic/Loyalist Prisoners Now!"
Speakers at the rally were James Molyneux (leader of the Official Unionist Party), lan Paisley (leader of the Democratic Unionist Party) and Martin Smyth (Grand Master of the Orange Lodge in Ireland).
Molyneux's main concern was to distance himself from what he termed "extra-mural activities"' , i.e. violence. He did not condone acts of violence, nor would he encourage anyone to commit them. Those who did not support the existing leadership of the campaign against the Hillsborough agreement should leave the campaign. But peaceful protest should continue andnot be given up because of the "hoodlum fringe element" which hung onto it.
Paisley, clearly the most popular speaker, launched into his characteristic rant. The IRA would be defeated only by the blood of Ulster. Ulster would fight and Ulster would be right. The Scottish people had defeated Mary Queen of Scots, and must now defeat "Maggie". . But It is certainly good for the British left to discuss the Irish question. Such goodness is diluted, however, when the centre of this discussion is a thesis already exposed to public criticism that remains unanswered and of which the current presentation includes new errors and which contradicts itself in its combination of ideas imperialist and anti-imperialist.
The basic proposal is straightforward: that the demand for British Troops Out of Ireland should be linked to a call for a united Ireland within which Protestant Ulster will enjoy a federal relationship to the whole. Equally straightforward is the proposal's weakness: that it links a principled demand of the British left to a tactical option of Irish anti-imperialists. The effect of this can be seen by posing the question: What would Socialist Forum/Socialist Organiser's position be if the troops were removed without the federal guarantee demanded? As the line is given, the only conclusion must be that such a move would be opposed, as surely as Militant and its Irish Monthly would oppose its occurence before their mass party of labour had been established.
Justify
To justify the line requires a combination of incorrect analysis and inaccurate historiography. Central to it is the view that Permanent Revolution - the development of the revolutionary process from bourgeois to proletarian aims — cannot be applied to Ireland.
This is backed by textual quotations from the publications of the 1960s Irish Workers' Group to which most surviving Irish (and several British) revolutionary socialists of that period trace their beginnings. Unfortunately for Socialist Forum, Rayner Lysaght, author of "The Republic of Ireland' (Mercier Press, 1970) contributes to Socialist Organiser's discussion on Ireland. This article was written in 1985. the IWG's line on its country's national question had the weakness often resulting from pioneer achievement. It was affected by the then common left wing assumption that the remaining Irish national demands would be ensured, as they had been posed by the workings of imperialism which would, of course, extract its own, prohibitive price for ensuring them.
For most of the W's ex-members this illusion has been destroyed by the course of political events since August 1969. On the one hand, the anti-imperialists' failure to win this struggle is an obvious and interesting version of the crisis of working class leadership. On the other hand that it is no more is shown by imperialism's contrasting inability to resolve the crisis in its favour: strong evidence for it being more than a political fight and having an inherent potential for Permanent Revolution. The shape of this development has been revealed by events excluded from the Forum's historical survey of the last sixteen years: the post-Bloody Sunday general strike and the hunger strike stoppages. As the struggle moves to the twenty-six counties (as it must do if it is to prevail, but has not yet done lastingly), it must become a specifically proletarian one and in this form, it will spread to the Protestant areas of the six counties.
Those who do not accept this perspective can be divided into conscious groups:
1. The workerists, including at first, most Irish heirs of the IWC including the founder leaders of the People's Democracy. For these, the Immediate need was to turn the six county democratic struggle into a socialist revolution without too much emphasis on the national issue. For such, the workers' state could be coextensive with the six counties, the twenty-six or the thirty-two. Class would out.
The present position of Militant is a version of this in the only form able to survive the last sixteen years: a reformist one.
2. Those maintaining the view held in 1969 by most Stalinists and Republicans: that the aim is to reform Northern Ireland to prepare the way for non-sectarian alliances to unite the whole island to prepare the way in turn, for a 32 county Workers and Small Farmers' Republic.
Although the Organiser/Forum perspective is less complex it is still recognisably stageist: first the Republic with the Protestant province, then the Workers' Republic. The twenty-six county working class is excluded from the first phase. On page 24 of Socialist Forum 2, only the Provisionals and 'the 26 County Ruling Class' (sic) are considered and rejected as possible (traditional nationalist) forces for achieving Irish unity. But who will unite Ireland when, it is admitted, even Protestant Home Rule would have to 'be backed up with a certain element of coercion"? Perhaps the British Army has still an Irish role for Socialist Forum?
Schema Inevitably, an incorrect schema is backed by inaccurate history. The nationhood attributed by some to the Northern Irish Protestants is denied because 'there is a major Catholic Community even within the Protestant heartlands' (p.35). Such an argument can be used to disprove the existence of most European nations. Protestant lack' of nationhood lies not in this fact but in Protestant inability to identify consistently only in relation to it.
More consistently, Socialist Forum minimises the British role in maintaining the Northern Irish state. It asserts (p.1) that O'Neill's reforms before 1968 were the results of pressure from London, rather than from potential multinational investors, then dubious about sectarian, as well as trade union demands on them. On page 9, the collusion of the British forces in the UWC strike is understated. Had the said forces played the same role there as they would in the recent miners' strike, they would have smashed the UWC within days: had they treated the miners as they did the UWC, the strikers would have won decisively.
The understatement of the role of the twenty-six county workers has been remarked already; it compares with the detailed accounts of the Loyalists' reactionary stoppages.
Danger
Finally, the subjective justification for the Forum line must be stated. Two reasons have been given. The first (in Socialist Organiser, 10 April 1985) is the readiness of many British workers to accept the danger of sectarian war as the reason to support keeping the troops. This has been fed them by the media; it is not an informed response and should not be treated as such.
The second argument is the alleged 'need' of the Irish workers in Britain *to be emancipated from....traditional Fianna Fail-type nationalism' . This involves two dubious assumptions: that the said Irish workers are indeed more backward than their British colleagues and that they can be weaned from Fianna Fail by a proposal made originally by Eamon De Valera.
In the 1970s, the predecessors of Socialist Organiser took their stand for the slogan, "Troops Out Now' "Troops Out, But..." is no sort of improvement.
Scan page 11
D INDUSTRIAL INDUSTKIALI