[Last time 1 discussed how Marxist theory "digs…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Last time 1 discussed how Marxist theory "digs beneath 'price' and 'profit', for example, to value and labour-time* The German Marxist Karl Korsch made the same point: "It is a method which leaves nothing out of account, but which refuses to accept things uncritically on the strength of a superficial commonon-garden empiricism soaked in prejudice... (Orthodox) economics 'theorises' by constantly invoking appearances...
"It seems not to know, or not to want to know, that beneath the surface of this immediate reality there lies a profounder dimension, nore difficult to grasp, but just as real; a dimension that embraces not only the given reality itself, but also its continual alteration, its origins, development and demise, its transition to new forms of life in the future...
Korsch calls this approach 'dialectical'. But what does the famous word 'dialectical' mean?' It goes back to ancient Greek philosophy, and in general means nothing more complicated than 'to do with the unravelling of contradictions and complexities by critical inquiry' The 'triad" thesis-antithesissynthesis is sometimes quoted as being the gist of dialectics. It is not or not, at least, so far as Marxism is concerned.
That 'triad' was much used by the 18th century German philosopher Immanuel Kant. Marx however, took his cue from Kant's successor Hegel, who much disliked all such pat formulas Kant was a typical philosopher of the age of the Enlightenment, when people first began to think that social institutions could all be judged and remoulded according to human reason. Previously, the social order had generally been regarded as essentially god-given and unchangeable.
Hegel advanced beyond Kant by pointing out that 'reason' is not something given once and for all, but something which changes as the world changes. Although Hegel himself was a conservative, the subversive nature of his method can be gauged from his credo:
Philosophy must beware of the wish to be edifying...The life of mind is not one that shuns death and keeps clear of destruction; it endures Its death and in death maintains its being. It only wins to its truth when it finds itself in utter desolation.
The quirk in Hegel's philosophy, however, was that for him it was not changing forms of production and economic life which generated changed standards of 'reason'; on the contrary, the changing forms of material life were generated by the evolution of Reason, of the Absolute Idea; or, more precisely, they were the evolution of Reason. "All that is real is rational; all that is rational is real?
Marx turned Hegel upside down by rooting his analysis in the changing forms of economic life. And by doing so he got rid of the mysticism in Hegel the notion of an abstract force of History, acting behind and above human beings with a predetermined goal.