The left sobers up
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
A letter, signed Alan Gilbert, Swansea. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into Banning anti-Zionists and The left and free speech; its last sentence was in neither.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
With the Socialist Workers Party deciding to picket Enoch Powell in Bristol rather than smash the meeting up, it seems that the left is beginning to sober up on the question of 'no platform' discussed in Simon Pottinger's article (SO 290).
But it's important to clinch the argument. Free speech is our basic policy. Socialism means the defeat of entrenched power by the mobilisation of long-downtrodden millions of people who at last dare to have thoughts and dreams other than those handed down by official society: thus it needs free debate. And free speech (real free speech, not the limited free speech available in a society where a wealthy minority monopolises the media, education, leisure...) is a vital part of the socialism we fight for.
To try to suppress free speech is tactically dangerous, because it swings democratic-minded people towards your opponent. This danger is great for revolutionary socialists today, as a small minority. Beyond that, there is the objection of principle: the imposition by force of any orthodoxy, even an apparently left-wing one, is anti-socialist.
Does allowing free speech for racists and sexists make them 'respectable'? Hardly, if they are met by militant pickets, as they should be. Does it licence an insult, an attack on the rights of black people and women? Up to a point, yes (and that's why we should have pickets and protests). But the idea of banning all that insults this or that group is highly dangerous, and produces a regime repressive to weaker or less vocal groups. The cure can be worse than the disease: witness the current 'anti-porn' crusade in the US.
Does all this leave us sounding like liberals? Yes! Within the working class we believe in the liberal ideal of reason triumphing through free debate; if we didn't we'd have to give up. Our difference with the liberals is only this: we know that history proceeds through class struggle and not through debate. The needs of the class struggle stand higher than any democratic principle.
That's why we respond to fascists and racists by advocating working class and black self-defence, and argue that such defence groups should deal with the fascists according to the rules of war.
We do what is necessary in defence of the democratic rights of the working class, of black people, of Jews, of women; and if that means ultra-rightist thugs losing some 'democratic rights', we shed no tears!
But it's a different matter to generalise from that (or from considerations of what revolutionaries might do in the tumult of civil war) to toy-Jacobin attempts to ban a wide range of repulsive ideas.