The Aids hvsteria
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Vigil for AIDS victims. Photo: Simon Gosset, Report Clive Bradley take!
facts and the fictic the disease AIDS. AIDS, Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, is like something out of science fiction. Indeed, it is a hackneyed plot: mysterious killer disease ravages the human race; too late, attempts are made to stop it...Most of humanity, in the end, is wiped out, leaving only a few survivors. In the pulp paperbacks, the whole thing usually starts in a germ warfare laboratory, and there may be something in that.
The facts are horrific. So far 278 people in Britain have died of AIDS, out of a total of 548 who have the disease. By the end of the decade — i.e. in the next four years - 10,000 people are expected to die of AIDSrelated diseases. 10,000 have already died in the USA, where there were 26,566 AIDS cases by September 1986.
Last week, the British government set up a Cabinet committee on AIDS, and started a television advertising campaign, in an attempt to influence people's sexual habits to restrict the spread of AIDS. Newspaper ads have been around for a while now.
Is the government doing the right thing? What can and should be done to stop the spread of AIDS? Is this the end of the 'sexual revolution' of the 1960s, as a whole generation retreats into single-partner sex, or even celibacy?
The virus that causes AIDS, HTLV-3, is far more widespread than the syndrome itself. So far, only about three in ten people who have the virus have gone on to develop AIDS and then die, though this percentage does seem to be rising. HTLV-3 is transmitted by blood and semen, and so either by sexual intercourse (including, potentially, oral sex, or by the mingling of blood -via shared hypodermic needles or blood transfusions.
The peculiarity of the virus is that it destroys the body's natural immune system: it kills anti-bodies. And so, when an infection reaches the body, there is no defence, and the victim dies. The 'syndrome' , full-blown AIDS, is the condition in which the infected person is seriously ill as a result of various diseases that the body is unable to resist.
Virus
Up to now, most people with the virus are still alive. General health affects a carrier's susceptibility to disease, and thus to AIDS. There are even stories of people who have developed AIDS and successfully fought for life.
In America and in Britain, the original high risk groups, along with haemophiliacs and drug addicts, were homosexual men. Elsewhere, for example in Africa, heterosexuals have always been just as likely to develop the disease. Now, in America the rate of increase in victims is faster among heterosexuals than among homosexuais. The popular image of AIDS as a *gay plague' is thus more out of step with reality.
Not that this bothers the bigots, of course. The right wing of the Tory Party advocate compulsory screening' (testing for the virus) and then forced isolation for anyone found to be infected. In California there has recently been a big right-wing campaign behind Proposition 64, which would have barred virus-carriers from all jobs involving contact with the public or with food.
The advocates of isolation seem to believe that this would stop the spread of the disease. But as 30 to 40 thousand people are believed to have the virus in Britain alone, isolation would require vast amounts of force, and even in terms of cold calculation would be unlikely to be effective unless literally everyone with the virus was sought out, found and imprisoned.
In any case, isolation is easy to advocate if you suppose it's not you who is to be isolated, HTLV-3 has been described as a very difficult virus to catch. Only very specific sexual activities can spread it. So the idea that somebody who has a virus which can only be spread in very specific ways should be locked up, is nothing short of totalitarian. It is entirely possible for HTLV-3 carriers even to have sex which entails no risk at all for their partners. Imprisonment is a barbaric non-solution.
Science fiction
The virus's science fictional quality resides in its apparent resistance to medical science. There are technical problems in dealing with it in the given in the form of a harmless strain of a virus: a vaccination against smallpox involves an injection with a harmless strain of the smallpox virus. HTLV-3 has no harmless strains, however.
Other techniques, such as 'trapping' the virus at an early stage, are impossible because it can hide in the brain where such a technique would be extremely dangerous.
The capacity of the AIDS virus to lodge in its victim's brain and cause premature 'senile dementia' reduce its victim to a vegetable — without causing AIDS, is one of its more recently discovered and terrifying aspects.
The response of the British government to this scientific challenge has not been very impressive. A miserable £1 million has been spent on research. When a drug was found that could, it seemed, slow down the effects of the virus, the government announced that it was too expensive to make, and only 12 people would be able to have it.
t2.5 million has been spent by the government so far on 'education' -explaining the risks to people in order to get them to change their sexual attitudes. The non-governmental Terrence Higgins Trust - named after the first person in Britain to die of AIDS - has put a lot of energy into persuading (especially gay) people to stick to 'safe sex'. In America there are 'safer sex' TV adverts directed specifically at gay men.
The argument is two-fold: have fewer partners, and do not have intercourse or oral sex to climax. The less promiscuous people are, the less AIDS can be spread.
All of this implies a radical change in our sexual lifestyles. The ability to have more than one sexual partner, increasingly free from moral stigmatism as well as from incurable disease, was one of the cornerstones of the 'permissive society'. . It had its drawbacks, particularly for women, but there can be no doubt that the 'sexual revolution', the emancipation of sex from the horrendous straightjacket of Victorian moralism, was deeply progressive.
Liberalisation of the law on abortion, liberalisation of the law on homosexuality - small and insufficient changes, but changes nonetheless that affected millions of people: all of that is under threat.
AIDS has been a godsend to the "Moral Majority' , It you will torgive the phrase. Promiscuity, and worse, homosexual promiscuity -blasphemous, godless pursuits -have brought the wrath of heaven down upon their perpetrators. The ravings of religious nuts are echoed in the more secular claims: Peregrine Worsthorne, speaking at Marxism Today's 'Left Alive' last week, commented on the legalisation of homosexuality that "the disadvantages are only now becoming rather lethally apparent". In other words, homosexual sex is seen as the cause of the disease - which is like saying that eating causes food poisoning or sneezing causes colds.
So AIDS has been used as a stick to batter all those liberated" morals held by the permissive generation.
Tories
The right wing being on the offensive anyway against feminists, homosexuals, single-parent families and so on, AIDS could not have come at a better time. With the help of HTLV-3, or the threat of it, the Moral Majority may indeed find that in 20 years time, young people have only one sexual partner for their entire lives, who in many cases they will marry.
For the Tory government, there is a big contradiction in all this. As yet, the Department of Health have resisted the ultra-right wing remedies compulsory screening, isolation, etc. They have decided, very late in the day, to focus on a campaign of education. To their credit — and it is one of the few things that is to their credit in the whole thing - they have accepted that people will have sex, whatever Mrs Thatcher has to say, and that it is pointless calling on people not to do so. And so their campaign has to be explicit in a way that inevitably causes howls of protest from the Mary Whitehouse Brigade.
It needs to be more explicit: people need the full facts about safer sex if they are to choose whether or not that is the answer for them. And explicit talk about sex, and even particular sexual activities, and the open public acceptance that homosexuals exist, will help slow down the right wing pull of the AIDS hysterics.
As much as a campaign about safer sex, what is needed is a vigorous campaign to dispell the myths that have developed about AIDS. An Observer-Harris poll last week found that no less than 69% of people think AIDS can be caught by kissing; 49% think it can be caught from a glass or cup.
Codes of practice on media reporting need to be implemented. The National Union of Journalists has a code of practice on AIDS coverage, but you could not be blamed for never having noticed.
Safe, or safer sex is not, however, a long-term answer. The absurdity of advice against intercourse is no doubt clearer to most people now it is being given to heterosexuals. The answer to the spread of syphilis was not to stop having sex but to find a cure.
Finding a cure or vaccine does pose big medical problems, as we have seen. But it will require vastly greater amounts of money being spent on it. £1 million is pitiful; some sources say E2 million but this is hardly better.
There is always the possibility that there simply is no way to defeat HTLV-3: it is the ultimate, invincible virus. But it is far too early to make such a rash conclusion. Science has only scratched the surface. More money and more research is more likely to find the answer than little money and little research.
In the meantime we need to defend those suffering from AIDS from growing institutionalised discrimination. It needs to be repeated over and over again that AIDS victims are no danger to anyone unless specific forms of sexual contract are made or blood is mingled. AIDS sufferers are human beings who, deserve to be treated as such WOMAN'S In the trade union movement you have to do a lot of learning fast if you are a woman. I'm sure the same applies to men. But the structure is built by them so it is more accessible to them.
We have to be familiar with a ton of initials and procedures which have a lot to do with aping the bosses and very little to do with the class struggle.
To become active women trade unionists we also suffer a great deal before gaining from the lessons we have learnt.
Part of that learning is not to stick the old procedural label on your opponents.
'Oh he's a hack, opportunist, careerist" we are told about men within the movement. Well, that's OK then. We know what we've got to tackle, but are the labels always accurate?
Mostly these men are "had its" The sooner you recognise the had it's the better. Your confidence soars.
Had it What can you do when you run up against a 'had it'? Speak to someone in your union who has been about tor, say, tive or six years. Is the name of the 'had it' familiar? Perhaps he was 'on the left' then?
They you understand: the more compromises and principles people sell to keep their positions the more personal and vindictive they become to others who expose and threaten them.
If you think you were the first woman to be subjected to male 'had its' rantings - take heart. Speak to other women and men - disarm that power. Tell tale signs are when they go apoplectic when challenged about a relatively minor issue that isn't going their way. The fear of being defeated makes them try to humiliate you in a very personal way, So what can you do about it?
Tip A good tip to help you overcome the fear of dealing with management is to imagine the man (manager) with no clothes on, sitting there naked. The desk moved away. It's not a sexual thing. Far from it. It's that only the trappings of the bosses make them seem formidable.
Well the same tricks are useful in handling trade unionists who play bosses' games.
Take awaythe toys from the boys. Take away the labels from the boys too.
I've been in several unions including CPSA" had its" in all of TGWU and them. I can usually spot them now. It's very easy to forget and just see other women trade unionists as feeble if they get intimidated. We learn together.
There's no shame in being a learner revolutionary. It's when the learning stops that worry293:20 November