Socialism or SDP Mark 2
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Eric Heffer's new book, 'Labour's Future:
Socialism or SDP Mark 2?' raises a number of key questions for the left today: What role can socialists play in the Labour Party? What attitude should we take to the "socialist' countries of Eastern Europe? And how can we defend democracy in the labour movement? We reprint below extracts from "Labour's Future". We invite contributions to this Labour must base itself on class struggle, not on slick then is the real choice:
Are we to go forward to rebuild and develop the Party as an instrument of socialism, that will fight for a socialist Britain as part of a socialist world, or are we to be a party which waters down its socialism, and settles for managing capitalism. The argument as to what the future holds will continue for a number of years. It will not be settled between now and the next General Election. That is why we have to concentrate on winning that election, whatever our views and despite our fears.
Labour at the Crossroads The Labour Party is at the crossroads. It has made important socialist gains in policy and organisation over the years, but those gains are now being pushed back. The difficulty which left-wing socialists face in the Party today is that they, more than anyone else, want the defeat of the Thatcher Government, and because of that are reluctant to raise legitimate criticisms of the way in which the Party is goI believe the best way to win the election is to be bold, to argue the socialist case unflinchingly and not to pretend that we do not want to change society in any fundamental way. It is important to remember that the Tories under Mrs Thatcher came out boldly for their type of reactionary Toryism and won. People like to know what political parties stand for and what they intend to do.
The Labour Party needs to be a socialist campaigning party, not merely a party dominated by its media image. Unfortunately that is the direction in which we seem to be going at present.
There are two ways of dropping Labour's socialism. There is the Gaitskell way, open and honest like the man himselt, and there is the other way, killing it off by kindness, paying lip service to it but in reality ignoring it.
That, I fear, is the danger today, and in this connection, I stand by what I myself wrote in the Labour Leader in October 1985: 'I am deeply concerned at some of the ideas that are being floated and pursued in the movement. We are witnessing a wholesale revisionism of socialist ideas, the abandonment of genuine socialist revolutionary politics and an attempt by some to turn the Labour Party into another SDP. This process has been helped by some on the so-called Left, who only a few years ago were fanatical supporters of Tony Benn, when he stood for the Deputy Leadership. Some have become arch revisionists. This is unforgiveable because such positions neither give us m electoral victory short term or funmental social changes long term...
The Party faces two dangers. First • revisionist, reformist drift to the right, and secondly a response to that drift which is sectarian. The former problem at the moment is greater than the latter. If we have policies which are indistinguishable from those of the Social Democrats it will not be Labour that benefits, but our enemies. It will be the road to defeat.
Clarifying, updating, even changing certain policies is perfectly acceptable, providing they rest on basic socialist foundations. After six years of Thatcherism,_a socialist _programme is more important than ever."
tyranny This break down of the authority of the Soviet Union produced a development which severely tested the commitment of the Labour Party to those struggling for freedom in Eastern Europe - the Polish workers' formation of Solidarity.
It was clear that the official trade unions in Poland were basically adjuncts of the State, and instruments of the Party hierarchy. The workers in Poland wanted a trade union organisation of their own which was free and independent of the State and the Party, and which they could control themselves.
The fact that the Church, or at least some of the priests, supported COAL, THE NATIONS Solidarity in no way detracts from the importance of the development, ENERGY FUTURE neither does it make the movement of workers basically anti-socialist as some, including left-wing trade union leaders, have suggested. SAVE -When I first raised the matter of support for Solidarity on the NEC, 1 WITH THE NO had a tremendous struggle to get my resolution accepted. Some of my COAL natural allies opposed it and one trade union member suggested that not be supported. I reminded him that he himself had supported an unofficial movement, in the NOT Seamen's Defence Movement, in his own union years before.
-That movement had, at one stage, talked of forming a new union and I was one of those who urged them to remain in the NUS and fight to DOLE change it because they had the opportunity to do so. In Poland such opportunities did not exist and i the workers had to forge new instruments to make any progress.
The NEC were proved right in giving their support to Solidarity and that was particularly underlined when the miners' strike took place.
The Polish Government, like the South African government, exported coal to this country during the strike. _presentation. The 'official' unions (Solidarity had been suppressed) did not object and Arthur Scargill and the NUM leaders had to make a strong protest to the head of the Polish Government.
In a foreword I wrote in a pamphlet issued by the Eastern Europe Solidarity Campaign titled The British Labour Movement and Oppression in Eastern Europe' , I made it clear that in my view it is impossible to create a socialist society without freedom. Socialism and freedom are indivisible. Socialism means the flowering of the human spirit, not its destruction.
Yet in parts of the world, oppressive measures have often been taken against critics in the name of socialism. Such actions are a blot on the name of socialism, and have held back the progress of the workers' movement in Western Europe for decades. Many trade unionists and workers in the West who over the years have gained hard-won democratic rights and fight to protect them, sometimes unsuccessfully, look at what happens in the so-called 'socialist' countries and say, If that is socialism, we want no part of it' Within the Labour movement there are, however, a tiny minority who continue to live in the past. They defend just about every action of the Soviet leaders, believing that in doing so they are protecting the Soviet Union from capitalist forces internally and from hostile capitalist elements outside. Because diplomats and visitors from the Soviet Union tend to meet predominantly with trade unionists and politicians who hold these views, they get the wrong impression of how their countries' policies are perceived outside. Socialists should at all times attempt to put the record straight.
Dissident groups and individuals seeking democratic changes should receive the support of socialists in the Western capitalist countries, even if we do not always fully or even partly agree with their political ideas or positions. To give such support does not mean that one is siding with those reactionaries who wish to create conopens a debate on Future Socialism means something radically different from the management Welfare State...
Scan page 7
"If we mean to constitute a really democratic society, permeated by the spirit of social equality, we shall have to find ways of replacing old incentives of fear and habit with new inducements more consistent with the recognition of equal human rights...Social ownership is only half Photo: John Harris
----- pull-quotes -----
Against Stalinist Against
Solidarity was not a real union but a breakaway, and therefore it could