Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Eric Heffer: Standing cl and firm

Socialist Organiser no. 293, 20 November 1986 · scan p. 7 · about 1,568 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

frontation and possible war, Unfortunately, the Soviet and other East European communist leaders are helping the reactionary forces by their actions against those who are critical of the regimes. They are, of course, protecting their own privileged positions. If free and open debate took place in these societies, the people would demand changes, just as they did during the Polish Solidarity upsurge, the Hungarian revolution and the Czechoslovakian Spring.

democracy is frequently suggested that groups within Labour's ranks constitute separate parties within the Party. There is undeniably a grain of truth in this. Any organisation within the Party must to some extent have a membership with a dual loyalty, a commitment to both the Labour Party itself and to the organisation that is working for its objectives within it. There is nothing wrong with that provided the group takes the view that its objectives are to maintain, protect and develop the fundamental principles of the Party. We have always been a federal organisation and should not fear changing back towards a more federal, decentralised structure.

The Labour Party has never been a democratic centralist organisation and in my view should never become one. Democratic centralism is advocated by both the Communist Party and the Trotskyist groups. It is a theory which allows democratic discussion within the organisation but demands that all members present the majority position in public. In practice the centralist half of the equation has tended to dominate the democratic half. T of my youth, the books by oday, compared with the days Marx and about Marxism are more widely available and more numerous. But whilst there are university courses in this field there has been little education, since the collapse of the NCLC, amongst working class organisations in the basics of Marxism. The various Marxist groups have helped fill the gap left by the NCLC. Socialist Action, Socialist Organiser, Militant, The Morning Star, Labour Leader and many others, do an important job of helping to teach young workers the nature of society, the character of the State, and the centrality of class struggle. It would be a serious retrograde step if such papers were banned for sale in the Party, and their supporters driven out.

The Labour Party has never been a uniform body, though some in the leadership who have opposed democratic centralism in theory have come close to carrying it out in practice.

There are other movements, apart from the Marxists, in the broader socialist body which have great merit. One example is the Christian Socialist Movement The type of policy required is what I have described for want of a better phrase, "Revolutonary Reformism' . To some extent Cole was the precursor of that concept, although he never used the phrase. In 1954, he wrote a pamphlet published by the 'New Statesman and Nation' in which he said "This pamphlet is about Socialism, by which I mean a society without class, and not one in which a new class structure has replaced the old. It is not about the policy to be followed by a Labour Government which is not seeking to establish a classless society, but only to nationalise a few more industries and add a few more pieces to the equipment of the Welfare State.

"It is an attempt to indicate a way of action for those socialists who feel a sense of frustration because to them the battle; the other half is real participation by the workers in control - not only at the top, but at every level from the work group upwards. By participation 1 do not mean merely consultation; I mean real control."

At the moment, despite the new NEC document on social ownership, we are neither being offered real social ownership nor real control by the workers. With the concept of "new partnership' we are back in the realms of Gaitskell's pamphlet, 'Industry and Nationalisation', Tony Crosland's 'The Future of Socialism' , John Strachey's "Contemporary Capitalism' and the Party Policy Statement of 1957, 'Industry and Society'.

Unite European workers Not all European countries are This is the case with most of the Scandinavian countries as well as Austria and Switzerland. One cannot ignore the EEC, it is a fact of life which affects our legislation and our political and personal lives. I believe we should work for socialist and working class internationalism in Europe without making the EEC a najor issue of contention at the present time, even if some of the European Socialists wish to do so.

1 am not saying here that the Party should abandon its position on withdrawal from the EEC, that is still essential. But I do believe that we should step up attempts to bring the left together in all parts of Europe to fight in the EEC, on the Council of Europe, and in all wider European organisations for nuclear disarmament, the phasing out of nuclear power, greater control over the multinationals, concerted aid to the Third World, and working class unity in action throughout the European trade union movement.

In 1980, the Labour Party issued another pamphlet, 'The Dilemma of Eurocommunism' which, though now bypassed by certain events, does not date in its essentials. Part of its message is that in the EEC it is important that the industrial and political working class movement should, as far as possible, join together in action to fight the multinationals, and to put forward an internationalist perspective. Though this will not be easy it must, in my view, be tackled. British socialism cannot build a wall around itself or solve its political and economic problems in isolation.

The movement should enter into discussions with all sections of the labour socialist/communist movements in the EEC at the earliest possible moment and at all levels. There are some positive discussions that can take place immediately, not on the basis of defending the Common Market by discussing the best way to operate the capitalist system which exists in the countries of the EEC, but on the basis of what actions we can take in all the EEC countries to spotlight trade union solidarity advocating socialist policies which stretch across national boundaries.

John Bloxam reviews "Labour's Future" by Eric Heffer.

When Labour's right wing and the soft careerist left got together at this year's Labour Party conference to vote Eric Heffer off the NEC they knew what they were doing, as readers of Heffers' new book, "Labour's Future - Socialism or SDP Mark II?" can see for themselves.

Few figures on the Left have better credentials than Eric Heffer has.

On central life and death ques tions for the working class, where many good people on the Left are confused and woolly, Heffer is sharp and clear.

Take for example the question of Stalinism. One of the most sickening things on the Left right now is the regrowth of sympathy with and illusions in the Stalinist states. It is considered no disgrace to write for the Morning Star, a "newspaper" dependent for half its sales on the good will of the East European and USSR SOCIALIST OR SOP Available price €4.95 from Verso, Meard Street, London NW1. governments and which is little more than a venal propaganda sheet for those governments.

Respectworthy socialists like Tony Benn and the officers of Chesterfield Labour Party write letters to the totalitarian dictator Gorbachev as though the labour movement has something in common with him.

The single greatest scandal in the British labour movement today is the connection many of our trade unionists - and the best of them, like the NUM - continue to have with the police-state pseudo-unions of the Stalinist states. Lots of left wingers half-approve the Stalinist state's suppression of the Polish labour movement, Solidarnosc.

Defeats

It is as though the defeats and setbacks the British labour movement has suffered in recent years have bred a new need for the sort of quasireligious belief in Stalinist "socialist fatherlands" which was so common in the 1930s, '40s and '50s.

Where there is so much confusion and backsliding, Eric Heffer is perfectly clear in his condemnation of Stalinism and unambiguous in his support for Solidarnosc.

No less clear is his posing of the issues facing the British labour movement - socialism or Mark 2 SDPism.

Yet Heffer is a man of many sides, some of which must seem contradictory. Though his views on socialism and the class struggle are those of a Marxist, Eric Heffer is a Christian Though he knows very well, and says, that any serious threat to the ruling class from the working class would be likely to produce a ruling class offensive to crush the labour movement - like that which devasted the Chilean labour movement and has so far led to 13 years of brutal military rule — nevertheless, Heffer is convinced, on balance, that socialism can be achieved peacefully in Britain.

Book Even where he is, in our view, mistaken, Eric Heffer's book poses sharply all the questions now facing the labour movement. It is a wide-ranging book delving into history as well as into current political issues. These ideas are important, especially now that the right wing, wearing its Kinnockite mask, is on the offensive. They should be discussed widely, We print some short excerpts from Eric Heffer's book in this issue of Socialist Organiser to stimulate that

----- pull-quotes -----

'Revolutionary reformism'

TERIC HEFFER LABORSE FUTURE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 293

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →