The Birmingham pub bombings: lailing the innocent
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-11-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Chris Mullin with his book on those jailed for life for the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings, 'Error of Judgment' : (Photo: Stefano Cagnoni/IFL). The book supports the case of the 'Birmingham Six Defence Campaign' that they were wrongly convicted; the campaign is also supported by Birmingham Labour MP Clare Short. Inset: senior cops at a press conference on 2 December 1974. imprisoned for many of the IRA bombings in Britain in the 1970s, according to Channel 4's *Beyond Reasonable Doubt' (Sunday, 16 November).
The best known case is that of the men found guilty of the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings. The incriminating evidence against them was the result of a chemical test which allegedly showed that two of the six had been handling explosives. This, combined with the proven connection of the men to the IRA - the day before the bombing tive of them had attended the funeral of Michael Gaughan, an IRA member who had died on hunger strike in Britain -was enough to send them to prison for the biggest mass murder in recent British history.
However, the forensic evidence has now been searchingly questioned. Not only was the chemical test not carried out vigorously enough, but the result itself is extremely dubious. What is supposed to show nitroglycerene could equally show nothing more than a harmless. substance found on cigarette packets, table tops or playing cards. Given this, the case against the six simply collapses.
These men have, in effect, been in jail for a dozen years becuse they went to Michael Gaughan's funeral!
Moreover, it seems clear that the men were severely beaten while in police custody, as well as by prison warders afterwards. Medical experts have argued this from photographic evidence. The police claim otherwise and a police inquiry exonerated the police from the charge.
Yet despite all the evidence accumulating that the men should be retried, the Home Office refuses to act. And Lord Denning, former Master of the Rolls, provides an interesting insight into the Establishment's thinking.
Denning is vehemently opposed to reopening the issue of police brutality. Why? If there is a new inquiry, it may turn out that the six men were beaten and if that happens, it will prove that the police were lying. Now we couldn't have that, could we?
The same logic seems to underlie the Home Office's obstinate refusal to allow an appeal. If they are innoERROROF bombi armingham le Chris Mullin OF MARXISM