Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The meaning of Zionism

Socialist Organiser no. 294, 27 November 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 662 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

JC The government is to spend f20 million to publicise the risk from AIDS, Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome.

But a big part of the tunding is to be taken from existing programmes of research into the disease. Six laboratories involved in looking for a cure face closure.

The publicity is already causing some raised eyebrows — referring, as it does, fairly explicitly to sexual activity.

But the Department of Health have stopped short of plain language. Instead, some of their publicity would be better described as a scare campaign -"Your next sexual partner person... The one that gives vOu AIDS'. Having waited so long to do anything, the Tories are now trying to make us panic.

At the same time, social Liverpool's Black Caucus have brought out a report on what they describe as the racist policies of Liverpool City Council. The Black Caucus came to national prominence last year when they came into conflict with the council over its appointment of Sampson Bond to the position of race relations adviser.

Bond was a Londoner, Fowler is scrapping the Health Education Council, and has ruled out more cash for VD clinics -which test and counsel people infected by the AIDS virus.

aspirations of the black community by cutting off grants to black groups and freezing appointments to race relations posts.

Tony Byrne, the new leader of Liverpool Council, comes in for particularly sharp criticism in a chapter entitled The Growth of Municipal Stalinism"

*The Racial Politics of If all that being a Zionist meant or implied was support for the right of an Israeli Jewish nation to exist, and opposition to their forcible inclusion into a "democratic secular state', 1 would have no quarrel with Mick Ackersley and Jack Cleary (Letters, SO 293).

I am even prepared to concede that if that is all you mean by it, then I am a 'Zionist' too — it would be logically irrefutable.

But I don't think that is all it means. Zionism is an ideology - a "decayed' one, no doubt, but an ideology all the same. There are two claims in particular of this ideology that I think we should oppose. First, is that the movement for the creation of Israel was a movement of Jewish national liberation. Whatever the subjective intentions of its adherents, it was in practice a movement of colonial conquest.

Second, even if it had not been a reactionary movement in this sense, the project of a Jewish state would have been a false method of fighting anti-semitism in Europe (as false as a notion of a 'homosexual state' for other victims of fascism); and a ridiculous method of developing a Jewish socialist movement as the 'socialist' Zionists believed.

Just history? I don't think so. Whilst, to repeat, defending the rights of the Jews, we have to explain the origins of the conflict. It is simply impossible to discuss the question of Palestine without doing so. These historical issues are therefore very live political issues.

And the Israeli state is recognisably Zionist - recognisably the product of the Zionist movement. It is a state

for Jews, as opposed to a state for its

citizens; Arabs expelled since its creation cannot live in it.

I oppose a programme to conquer Israel. think that to propose the self-obliteration of the Israeli Jewish nation is utopian rubbish. I think that the expelled Arabs have no absolute right, in the sense of a right that in principle could be entorced by external armies and thus conquest, to 'return'. But I do think they have a right in a more minimal sense, to live in Israel, and that their exclusion is chauvinist, indeed racist.

Zionism, minimally, is Israeli Jewish chauvinism. I do not think we should call ourselves "Zionists' anymore than, through support for Palestinian national rights, we should be Palestinian nationalists.

To do so obscures real political issues rather than clarifying them.

CLIVE BRADLEY, London

----- pull-quotes -----

services secretary Norman Militant

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 294

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →