Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Report from inside South Africa The crisis the terror

Socialist Organiser no. 294, 27 November 1986 · scan pp. 6–8 · about 2,295 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

On this page we reprint excerpts from a document produced by socialists inside South Africa. It outlines the crisis facing the Botha regime as it attempts to modernise Apartheid in the face of mounting resistance from the black working Students fight police in Cape Town. Photo: Azania Worker. 1984 to 1985 were years of continual mobilisations, strikes and revolts. It was in these years that new forms of struggle by workers and students came to the fore.

Factory occupations, alternate education and street/defence committees made their embryonic appearance. Black workers' industrial struggles increased dramatically. In 1984 according to official figures there were 469 strikes mobilising 181,942 workers. The formation of COSATU was also a significant victory. The tri-cameral parliament and the local councils were a dismal failure. Out of 34 municipal councils elected in December 1983, only three were still functioning at the end of 1985. 200 local councillors have been forced to resign. Almost 20 have been assassinated. According to government figures, 900 police homes were petrol-bombed. The regime made the movement pay a heavy price for challenging its rule: nearly 1,200 people were murdered, many maimed and nearly 25,000 people arrested during 1985 alone.

The struggle in the past while, although heroic, was also wracked with internal contradictions, an absence of long-term perspectives and plagued with a sectarianism that on occasion gave rise to vicious internecine conflict. Many of these factors created an opening for agent provocateurs and the police who class.

channelled the physical struggles ed.

discontent into among the oppressAntonio Gramsci, describing Italy before the fascist takeover could well have been referring to the South Africa of the 1980s when he wrote "The old order is dying, but the new refuses to be born, in this great interregnum a whole series of morbid symptoms arise... " The application of the "necklace" came to symbolise the apocalyptic situation in which South Africa was plunged. Although this was meted out to collaborators, it was also used against those where mere suspicion or circumstantial evidence was present. More ominously it was often used against ideological opponents in the liberation movement. This sectarian indisciplined lactivity, if it continues does not augur well for the liberatic movement.

The economic The economy has reached a stage of development which calls for substantial reforms. The ruling class understands that a bourgeois reformist solution needs to be found. For the liberal bourgeoisie, the presently constituted racist political system has outlived its usefulness.

Yet, the state, for a number of countervailing reasons, cannot embark on fundamental reform and in the eyes of the oppressed and exploited it has no legitimacy for reforThe strong arm of the state. Photo: ming itself. Adjusting the system too in much could create a breach for the 19 liberation movement to surge through. The legalisation of trade 54 unions for instance, far from taming ba workers, have instead made workers mi more militant.

The regime is more conscious than the liberal bourgeoisie that certain apartheid laws if abolished, could well open up an insurrectionary situation. The liberals and imperialism bank on it being possible to negotiate with black representatives, primarily the ANC, in order to reduce this risk ad to thoroughly reform the system without the masses getting out of control. At present, as can be seen by the large scale repression, the Nationalist Party does not believe in this possibility. Botha is seeking to gain time, to manoeuvre and to avoid an open crisis today in his own government.

Capitalist domination has now lasted more than a century. Production tions, very different from the traditional colonial economy have been firmly established. This development has not only resulted in increasing class differentiation among the oppressed but has also opened the way to the beginnings of class consciousness among the black workers. The Social African social formation is an advanced capitalist one with the concomitant existence of national oppression. National oppression continues to exist because the majority of the population are denied democratic rights on the basis of skin colour. The social formatio exhibits a complex interplay of class and colour. The phrase racial capitalism' is an apt one.

Class The theory that says the South African social formation is colonialism of a special type or internal colonialism is wrong. This theory emphasises national oppression at the expense of class exploitation. More seriously, it provides the theoretical justification for a national democratic revolution, not combined with class emancipation.

The South African economy went Mario Zwi (Reflex)

to a recession at the beginning of 182. Retrenchments and unemployent drastically increased. By 1984, 1% of urban women and 36% of urin men had been unemployed for ore than two years.

Since the beginning of 1985 the olitical effects of the crisis, coming I top of the economic recession, ive broght about a much more rious crisis than the political conselence of Sharpeville 1960 or Soweto 176.

The bosses have taken advantage the recession to strike important ows against the trade unions. They ive attempted to restructure the inastrial apparatus by fusions betzen big companies, thereby causing ore unemployment. They have also troduced new technologies which splace labour intensive sectors of dustry. Many workers have seen rough these measures. Some trade lions have demanded access to the counts of the companies and a say er retrenchments and working contions.

Recovery?

In order to find remedies for this economic crisis, the regime has vainly tried different policies for economic recovery. It re-instituted a 'Commercial Rand' for overseas financial markets in order to favour foreign investment. In 1984, it tried to boost domestic consumption through fiscal measures, which resulted in high inflation. At the end of 1985, the declared priority was the fight against unemployment. But none of these measures have been able to bring the country out of recession and even less, defuse the political crisis.

The appearance of 'ungovernability' ad the real growth of the mass movement, particularly the unions as well as the inability of the state to control the resistance using the 'normal' legal framework of state control, has forced even 'conservative imperialism' to the realistion that apartheid would not survive in the medium to long-term. For them a realignment of capitalism is needed. Simultaneously, the major foreign investors reached the same conclusion and started reducing their 'exposure" by withdrawing capital and refusing

Scan page 7

strikers • lend more capital to g fric en before the widespre or disinvestment. This This precipitated tate he economic crisis.

The state of emergency - a short reprieve?

The Botha regime is faced with a ituation where it has to conciliate liverse interests inside the ruling class nd imperialism, as well as take acount of pressure from its electoral sase. Since the middle of the 1970s, he Nationalist Party has lost a third if its electorate. A part of these lost oters have gone to the fascist right - benefitting the Conservative Pary, HNP and AWB. From 1974 to 982 the Nationalist Party has seen its lectoral influence among Afrikaaners drop from 86% to 56%. Botha needs a strong influence in the solice and the army. He cannot allow hese crucial areas to fall into the lands of the fascist right. Unlike the atter, Botha understands that represion alone cannot save the system.

It is widely acknowledge that Sotha's reforms have achieved too ttle too late. The reliance of apitalism on the black workng class as led to the latter's strengthened bjective position, which is one of he fundamental causes of the uparge in 1984-5. Ever since the mass rikes in Durban in 1973, and the oming into being of black conrosness, mass resistance continued nabatedly. This factor, combined ith the economic and political crisis -cans and the diminishing electoral ase at his disposal, left Botha with a im margin of manoeuvre. Attempts move the mass movement into a oderate approach was transformed to its opposite.

Incorporate

The general thrust of Botha's reforms was to preserve capitalism by corporating privileged layers of middle and working class blacks.

sonomic and political concessions are made. Attempts were made to eate a black labour aristocracy -om those workers who were legally mowed to live in urban areas. Wiehahh-Riekert was, in many respects, an attempt to extend the strategy of incorporation so successfully pursued towards the white workers between the 1920s and the 1940s, to include the better paid and more highly skilled sections of black workers. But the black workers were not so easily bought off. The regime's strategy was in ruins.

The ostensible reason given for the state of emergency is that a massive and diabolical plan worked out by the South African Communist PartyANC-UDF to bring down the government was planned to coincide with June 16. While many organisations were planning church services, meetings, rallies and perhaps even a march, something along the lines of an insurrection is inconceivable. The regime certainly used June 16 as an excuse for the crackdown it long wanted.

Reasons The real reasons for emergency were that:

1. It needed to reassert its i own initiatives. Its political program mes for the oppressed were in a sh ambles. The collaborators (literally) to be given a new lease of li fe. The statutory councils cannot i also be allosed to collapse. The regim le needs political room for manoeuvre , to implement its economic progran ame for the oppressed communities.

To do this it is essential to: sistance 2. Curtail the popular re and roll back the gains madi e in the last few years by trade union s, community, student and p olitical organisations.

3. The CP-HNP-AWB thr eat is a real one for the Botha regin ne. The Nationalist Party depends for its parliamentary majority on th le votes of the white working class ar id petty bourgeoisie. Botha, a vetera n of 50 years of Afrikaner politics, m ust well remember the fate of the party's founder, General JBM Hertz og, who was outflanked on the right s when he threw in with Jan Smuts' South Africa Party — the representa atives of English-speaking capital. Ex- -cabinet minister Andries Treuernicht and his breakaway Conservative p arty is waiting in the wings for swelling white popular reaction to allow them to do to Botha what the Nationalists did to Hertzog.

The state of emergency serves as a palliative to placate the desires of the fascist right. It is foreseeable that the regime might make use of the AWB as some kind of unofficial adjunct to the police and army. This eventuality, widespread in Latin America, could have a devastating effect on the left if we are not prepared to defend ourselves. The murders of Turner, Mxenge, Goniwe and others will be a drop in the ocean compared to what we might face.

4. Finally, talking to some people who have been released and judging from the questions put to them during the interrogation sessions, it seems that the state of emergency is also one big information-gathering exercise.

General Motors strikers argue with scab According to the South African Labour Bulletin (SALB) only about 300 workers are left out on strike in the battle between General Motors and black trade unions in Port Elizabeth over the American multinational's plans to pull-out' of South Africa.

The workers have been on strike for four weeks now after it became clear that working conditions, union organisation and pension rights would all be at risk as a result of GM handing over control of its South African operations to local management.

After a vicious attack by the security forces on strikers picketing the plant last Monday, an attack which led to the arrest of at least 16 trade unionists, the unions have switched their tactics.

The campaign main elements.

Firstly, they are concentrating on a legal battle to win the reinstatement of all those sacked by GM including the 567 victimised after the security forces smashed up the workers' occupation of the plant.

Secondly, the unions are attempting to draw on support from anti-apartheid organisations in the townships to prevent large-scale scabbing.

Freddie Sauls of the National Automobile and Allied Workers Union (NAAWU) put it like this:

"The only way GM can break the strike is with the security forces. They can't break the strike by hiring scabs. That's impossible because the scabs are staying in our townships. And the scabs will be "consciencised" and influenced in the townships where they live."

But the problem for the strikers is that the 'African' townships in the Port Elizabeth area are far better organised than the so-called 'coloured' ones.

This could lead to the introducfion of a dangerous 'ethnic' element into the situation with the majority of scabs turning out to be coloured, a problem compounded by the unemployment rate of up to 60% among blacks. But so far the strikers who are fifty-fifty 'African' and 'coloured' have shown great unity.

Management have also turned to recruiting unemployed white workers as scabs (white unemployment in the area is now over 30%, among the highest in the country).

According to SALB the media inside South Africa have tried to portray the strike as a strike against disinvestment and therefore by implication a strike against the call for disinvestment and sanctions. But this is not the case. The strike is not against dısınvestment as such. Rather, it is against the bad effects that disinvestment can potentially have on workers and working class organisation:

Scan page 8

Socialist Action's Alliance for Socialism conference held last weekend attracted about 400 people on the Saturday and 250 on Suncampaigns were sanctified they were star speakers, and more often people whose approach meant that any disagreement with them automatically branded you an alien and "a hostile" of some nat?

----- pull-quotes -----

political crisis the response ruling class.

GM face

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 294

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →