Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How not to fight Kinnock

Socialist Organiser no. 294, 27 November 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,485 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no 293 27 November 1986 Page 10 desire to win elections necessarily means abandoning any commitment to socialism in order to 'win the middle ground'. Trying to win elections necessarily cuts across an orientation towards direct action struggles, because the audience for socialist ideas is only ever the 'militant minority' Serious socialists in the Labour Party, therefore militant orientate towards this minority rather than try to win elections.

"Once it is seen that politics arise from the everyday struggles in the workplaces, that it is here rather than in elections that workers begin to question the prevailing ideas of capitalism, then you can see that the road to socialism is quite different to that taken by the Labour Party." (September 29, 1984).

Since the left were as committed to electoral politics as the right, they did not know how to argue back when the right said socialist policies nad to be jettisoned so as to regain votes." (SW, June 29).

This is a very odd view of the basic problem of reformism - indeed of what reformism is.

The problem with the 'parliamencary road to socialism' is not the wish to win elections. it is the inevitability of violent ruling class resistance if an elected left government seriously tries to fight for its programme. Allende in Chile failed not because he ran for election, but because he did not go on from the election victory to move Do left policies lose votes for Labour? Sometimes they do - when the Labour leadership sabotages the election campaign by denouncing the Party's policies, and by engaging in a witch-hunt. If the Labour leaders say Labour's policy is ultra-left lunacy, no wonder voters agree.

The Labour left replies that we eed a Labour leadership that will ght for Labour policies. A real campaign by Labour for socialist policies would gain votes. But the SWP accepts the basic terms of reference of he Labour right about how to win elections: that 'winning the middle ground" means "being moderate"

What's wrong with Labour is not at it tries to win votes. You have to votes even to go on strike. You to win votes indeed — not a Parliamentary election perhaps, but votes all the same, in workers' councils, for example — to make a revolution.

And the basic fault of the Labour left is neither a failure to get involved in strikes, nor that it doesn't know how to answer the arguments about winning elections. It answers the vote-catching arguments rather better than the SWP does. Many ordinary Labour Party members do get involved in strikes — many, indeed, run them. The SWP know about Labour Party members' involvement in the Of course, the Labour Party does function primarily as an electoral machine, and this is a serious problem with it. But electoral activity is not necessarily counterposed to working class action. The Bolsheviks made great efforts to get representatives elected to the Duma - the parliament in Tsarist Russia. The Communist International, when it was still revolutionary, took electoral activity very seriously — not just to make propaganda, though that was central, but with the intention of winning elections.

The trouble with Labour is much deeper. The Labour Party is controlled by a bureaucratic apparatus closely entwined with the trade union bureaucracy. And the central feature of this overall labour bureaucracy is its accommodation to, and dependence upon, the capitalist state. Labour governments have rested upon the capitalist state; and what. has crucially distinguished them from Tory governments is the greater degree of collaboration between the state and the trade union bureaucracy that they have been able to organise. a future Labour government would draw much of its strength, as a government, from its ability to draw the trade union bureaucracy back into 'the corridors of power from which they have more recently been 1986 unceremoniously booted.

It is this relationship between the Labour bureaucracy and the state that makes Labour a reformist party, not the fact that it wants to win elections.

State

The question for revolutionary socialists, therefore, is this: how can we break the labour movement as a whole from its reliance on the state? Of course, as the SWP argues, a focus on direct working class struggles and a fight to give those struggles direction is irreplaceable for socialists. Any Marxist organisation worthy of the name sees those struggles as the central arena of its work. But just to build an organisation that promotes those struggles is not an answer to the problem of a labour movement fundamentally compromised with the capitalist state.

Merely to put the argument *socialists need a Party quite different to the Labour Party" (SW, September 29 1984) begs the question. We need a reality quite different to the present one. Yet we have to start from present day reality. The Labour Party exists; it is enormously powerful; it structures, shapes and profoundly affects and limits the class struggle; and a real alternative to Labourism cannot be built just by "For the next three weeks I shall be a very strong Labour supporter."

Paul Foot, Daily Mirror columnist and SWP member, during the 1979 election campaign. putting out an appeal for it.

Where the Labour Party expresses the political concerns of reformism, the trade unions express its economic concerns. Labourism is trade unionism extended into the 'political' — i.e. Parliamentary — arena. It is the principle of trade unionism -bargaining within the system - applied to society as a whole.

The problem of Labourism is therefore not just a problem of the Labour Party - with its electoral focus — but a problem of the overall politics of the entire labour movement.

The deep-rooted reformism of the labour movement does have a profound effect on individual militants. Otten they do move to the right, get sucked in, become bureaucratised. Leon Trotsky said: "The trade unions are a culture medium for opportunism". . The Labour Party too. But what's the answer? Splendid isolation, sectarian 'purity'? No: it is to link participation in the broad movement with the development of an organised tendency ideologically sharp enough to fight the pressures to accommodation; to integrate individual activists into that tendency rather than leaving them as individuals.

The SWP's perspective lacks a real strategy for working class power. Essentially, they provide no link between "small strikes now' and some "big bang' Armageddon in the future. Logically, their strategy is just to build up an organisation through immediate struggles until the day...

In theory, an organisation of some size could be built purely out of direct struggles — strikes in particular. But unless it relates to the overall questions - how to fundamentally change the very nature of the working class movement - it will be fundamentally sterile, especially during big political upheavals.

HIt will also be sterile We say: don't back down, don't cave in to the right, keep fighting. And we fight for our programme, our political answers. Otherwise we let the Labour leaders off the hook.

Revolutionary politics cannot be just 'workers' struggles' versus 'elections' Industrial militancy is not in itself a political answer to anything. A political answer must deal with issues. of the overall running of society - to point towards ways to defend workers' interests at a society-wide level, to begin to organise the workng class to take power.

How do we end unemployment? 'Organise, occupy, fight for the right the SWP used to chant.

Yes, but how? Share out the work, establish workers' control over hours with no loss of pay.

How do we fight declining living randards? Go on strike, says the SWP, for higher wages. Fine: bui such sectional struggles need to be linked to an overall working class solution - automatic wage rises in line with a workers' cost of living index.

Marxists have to carry out a political struggle to convince workers of these solutions. Part of that struggle is demanding of the existing Labour leaders that they support struggles now; fighting them if they don't; and fighting for our overall political solutions throughout the labour movement.

One-sidedness The SWP's one-sidedness leads them to low-level concentration on "basics' — workplace organisation — at the expense of giving general political answers. During the miners' strike, for example, it led to ultrapessimism, and a failure to argue for the necessary class-wide solidarity action.

Now they conclude that workplace militancy is off the agenda for a period, and that they can do nothing much but fish among the Labour left.

Revolutionary Marxism is not distinguished from reformism by indifference to elections or by organisational separation from the Labour Party. For revolutionary Marxism politics comes first - the political answers that we give to immediate questions, our political programme. The SWP's approach is fundamentally apolitical, and thus, fundamentally, the opposite of revolutionary Marxism.

----- pull-quotes -----

decisively against the old ruling class. Left wing

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 294

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →