[A system of society in which the workshops…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-12-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
A system of society in which the workshops, factories, docks, railways, shipyards etc. shall be owned by the nation... seems best calculated to secure the highest form of industrial efficiency combined with the greatest amount of individual freedom from state despotism...
State ownership and control is not necessarily socialist - if it were, then the army and the navy, the police, the judges, the gaolers, the informers and the hangmen would all be socialist functioaries as they are all state officials - but the ownership by the state of all the lands and material for labour combined with the cooperative control by the workers of such land and materials, would be socialist...
To the cry of the middle-class reformers, 'Make this or that the property of the government' , we reply — 'yes, in proportion as the workers are ready to make the government their property' James Connolly Provos, Protestants and working class politics WORKERS' LIBERTY Provos, Protestants, working SATS and INSTER • class politics Akers Liberty no is availa • postage, from Box 8 4 NA A unique confrontation between the views on the left.
What sort of united Ireland could win the support of Protestant workers? What way to working class unity?
nice t1 plus ondon SE15 There are overwhelming reasons why the labour movement should oppose and fight every single act of privatisation. Privatisation is a central part of the Tory onslaught on working class wages and conditions. Privatisation is another name for a series of organised robberies of society orchestrated for the rich by the Tory government. It is part of an ideological offensive against any sort of socialism. So 'Sid' should be told not to let himself be used and conned.
There is more to it though, and it is more complicated than it seems.
Why have the Tories got away with so much without provoking a powerful working class movement against privatisation? And the signs are that if the government lasts it will be able to press ahead with more and bigger denationalisations without provoking much of a fight, except perhaps from those whose conditions are immediately and directly affected.
Much that the Tories are doing is popular and much that they are dismantling is unpopular. The labour movement has been put on the defensive politically and ideologically.
What is the answer to what ideologically committed, militantly capitalist, Tory government is doing? When Mrs Thatcher says she is out to change the political balance in Britain decisively and to kill socialism, what do we say? It isn't enough to say 'Defend Nationalisation' - though we should say that.
One reason why the woking class hasn't roused itself to fight against privatisation is that Nationalisation in Britain has never been working class or socialist. The model of the public corperation adopted for Nationalised bodies by the 1945 government locked the Nationalised industries into the control of government appointed directors bound the workers to exploitation for decades to come. to pay compensation to the shareholders.
The workers controlled nothing, least of all their own workaday lives.
Even when Nationalisation was very popular and brought serious improvements to the workers - as it did in the coal industry, for example — it still had all these disadvantages. And it brought other disadvantages.
In the coal industry nationalisation was the signal for a close collaberation between the union leaders - Arthur Horner and then Will Painter, both CP members - and the stateappointed management, a partnership which lasted for almost a quarter of a century.
And look what that got the miners - a slow slide in wages, bitter strikes in the 70s, vicious hatcheting from Tan McGregor in the 80s.
Coal, steel and British Leyland, the industies in which the profesional industrial thugs, McGregor and Michael Edwards - the latter appointed by a Labour governmentoperated most brutally against the workers, are all nationalised industries!
Leon Trotsky Socialist supported nationalisation as a means of ending exploitation of workers by the bourgeoisie. In Britain nationalisation has been only a different technique for organising that exploitation, always closely integrated with 'privatised' exploitation.
For it to have been otherwise the working class would have had to get rid of all the exploiters, taken political power, and run both industry and society in its own interests.
That is the difference between socialist nationalisation and what we have had.. The Irish socialist James Conolly put it all very succinctly long ago. So did Leon Trotsky!
In a pamphlet, "The death agony of capitalism and the tasks of the Fourth International' — which militant with its idolitrous worship of bureaucratic nationalisation and its practice, where it has had power, in Liverpool of bureaucratic and often bone-headed municipal 'socialism' would do well to remember - Leon Trotsky wrote:
The point is that The difference between these demands and the muddle-headed reformist slogan of 'nationalisation' lies in the following: (1) we reject indemnification; (2) we warn the masses against demagogues of the People's Front who, giving lip-service to nationalisation, remain in reality agents of capital; (3) we call upon the masses to rely only upon their own revolutionary strength; (4) we link up the question of expropriation with that of seizure of power by the workers and farmers.
only a means to an end: working class emanciation from exploitation. It is not itself the end, and if we forget that we not only confuse the means with the end, but risk losing sight of our real goal.
The problem the left faces with the ideological offensive of the Tories is that much of the demogogic attacks by the Tories on bureaucracy and so on rings true to many workers and therefore a defence of the old bureaucratic nationalisation and municipalisation rings very hollow.
The left must not allow its hostillity to what the Tories are doing to trap us into a blind political defence of the old pre-Thatcher status quo, of which we were long the most severe critics, albeit from the left.
We must combine defence of working class jobs and conditions in the industries being privatised and active resistance to privatisation with a vigorous ideological offensive of our own in which we counterpose to Thatcherism not bureaucratic nationalisation but libertarian socialism — real socialist forms of public ownership, under workers' control locally and nationally.
Tell Sid the answer is socialism. Psst...Crusader here. The Voice of Britain. I'll say this only once so play close attention. My mission is to unmask pinko traitors. I've plenty of suspects. Sir Roger Hollis for starters. Problem: He is dead. My masters at SSERPXE want live mole - better copy. Then intelligence expert Nigel West (cover - mild mannered Tory candidate for Torbay 'Rupert Allason') comes up with astonishing accusation - Lord Rothschild is our man. He arranged for publication of Wright's book. How did Rothschild know Wright? West says the man who masterminded the meeting between Rothschild and Wright NONE OTHER THAN ANTHONY BLUNT!
But my masters don't like this. Peer of the realm, great family and all that. Rothschild definately not a pinko traitor. Former SSERPXE Chapman Pincher, brought out of retirement to clear Rothschild.
Now Pincher mixed up in whole business. Vitally important to kill rumour that. Rothschild and former MI6 head, Sir Arthur Franks passed state secrets to Pincher for his book. Then story comes out that 'M' herself sanctioned Pincher's book written in conjunction with Wright!
Things looking very bad. Armstong making complete pillock of himself down-under. Haver's refusing to carry the can and is threatening to spill the beans if Armstrong doesn't change his story in court. SSERPXE Control says: "Take the heat off 'M' at all costs'. Pincher says Labour party masterminding •dirty tricks' campaign to same HMG over bungled Sidney job. Kinnock putting Party before coun try etc.
Best of all we can reveal that Kinnock has been colluding with that smart arsed, Aussie lawyer. Damn near treachery when you think about it!
Oops! How did we know about Kinnock's collusion? Oh dear! Don't say Pincher's old cronies in MI5 put a tap on the Welsh windbag's phone? Not just after it's come out about the Young Turks burglarising Wilson, plotting military coups and so on? Very bad timing. Fouled up the whole SSERPXE operation. CampbellSavours, Dalyell and the rest of the pinko rabble baying for M's defence or into MI etc. blood, demanding investigations into MIS etc.
New instructions now issued from Control: "Abort whole operation'. Find a Fall-guy to take the blame for the whole balls-up. Bad luck on Sir Robert. But then he did take a swing a one of our photgraphers, didn't he? How about, 'he's a wally amongst the Wallabies'?.
295.
Scan page 4
After Clive Bradley's letter in last weeks SO I'm not sure what his quarrel with Mick Ackersley and Jack Cleary is about. Clive objected to Mick Ackersley's assertion that Zionism logically means support for the right of Israel to exist and that those who support Dear Comrades
----- pull-quotes -----
THE DEBAT ON IRELAN